Gedmatch calculators on Vahaduo

[Jana]

Since the averages of Transdanubia and Budapest area are so close, and are also pretty much connected historically, I was thinking to merge these two and make a Transdanubia+Budapest single average. What do you guys think? I believe it's better if Hungary has only 3 regions+Transylvania.

Yeah, makes sense.

[Dunai]

It's your choice ultimately. From my experience on Moldova and Romania, capital regions are close to the surrounding area, with minor differences attributed to migrants, both internal and external.

Yes, I do find larger region averages more helpful, rather than reducing them too much into sub-regions, unless if historically and culturally it is rather important to do so (as is the case of separating neighboring Székelys from Csángós).

[17571imre]

Since the averages of Transdanubia and Budapest area are so close, and are also pretty much connected historically, I was thinking to merge these two and make a Transdanubia+Budapest single average. What do you guys think? I believe it's better if Hungary has only 3 regions+Transylvania.

i agree with this idea

[Jana]

Now we finally have respectable sample size for Croatian regions, except for east(Slavonia), which should improve reliability of these averages:

Littoral 48
North 41
East 7
Bosnia-Herzegovina 52

However as already said there is a person possessing 70 Slavonian (eastern) Croat gedmatch kits, who agreed to share them and despite she still didn't there is a hope we see them one day and improve eastern average significantly.

[Impaler]

Updated:

Distance to: Impaler
6.95099992 Turk_Bulgaria_Central
6.97003985 Turk_Bulgaria_Northeast
8.09246872 Turk_Eastern_Macedonia
8.12070810 Turk_Balkan_average
8.39867251 Pomak_Central-Macedonia
8.74612739 Turk_Western_Thrace
8.89303098 Bulgaria_Northeastern
9.15427769 Vlach(Aromanian)_average
9.23794349 MacedonianWest
9.51309098 Pomak_Drama
9.56806668 Bulgaria_Southeastern
9.62356483 Moldova_South_Gagauzia
9.68487997 MacedonianEast
9.69077396 Turk_Central_Macedonia
9.70603936 MacedonianCentral
9.76225896 Vlach_North-Macedonia-Highlander
9.78160519 MacedonianNorthWest
9.82931330 Bulgaria_Southcentral
9.86289511 Macedonian_Average
9.88468007 MacedonianPelagonia
9.97186542 Bulgaria_Northcentral
9.98393710 MacedonianSouthWest
10.03396731 Bulgaria_average
10.05594849 Bulgaria_Southwestern
10.05707214 MacedonianGreeceNorthWest

Distance: 235.5620% / 2.35561999
Target: Impaler | ADC: 0.25x RC
55.6 Turk_Central_Macedonia
20.9 Turk_Bulgaria_East
16.9 North_German
6.6 Chamar

[oszkar07]

Updated

Distance to: Oszkar
3.72317069 Austrian
5.04733593 German_East
6.84580163 German
7.72020077 Hungarian_Transdanubia
7.93366246 Hungarian_Budapest
8.14288647 Czech
8.20928133 Croat_north
8.25083632 Slovenian
8.77519800 Hungarian
9.59022419 Hungarian_Northern
9.87765876 Slovak
9.98206892 Hungarian_Alföld
10.03557173 FRA_Alsace
10.13897924 German_West
10.81012026 Swiss_German
11.34536469 Croat
11.34722874 North_German
11.42959317 Hungarian_Transylvania
11.68116861 Dutch_South
11.72224381 Swiss_German2
12.05646714 Pennsylvania_Dutch
12.07142494 Sorb_Lusatia
12.36786158 Székely
12.46889730 Croat_East
12.48244768 Sweden_Svealand_East
12.55726085 Swedish
12.70312954 Csángó
12.70418829 FRA_Belgica
12.93080431 Dutch
13.26481813 Swiss_French
13.46034546 Croat_Littoral
13.48333416 Dutch_Central
13.53704547 Dutch_North
13.72289692 North-Swedish
13.86021284 South_Polish
13.94702477 Sweden_Svealand_West
14.37213972 English_Southeast
14.55567587 Sweden_Götaland
14.57431302 Denmark
14.62748099 Ukrainian_Ivano_Frankivsk
14.64223685 Bosniak_Bosnia_proper
14.68415813 English_Midlands
14.69716980 FRA_Armorica
14.82737333 Croat_Bosnia&Herzegovina
14.83493175 Bosniak_Krajina
14.90192269 Norway_South_Central
14.96533661 English
15.09196806 Bosniak
15.24642253 Norwegian
15.36027018 Bosniak_Sarajevo

[Leto]

Updated:

Distance to: Impaler
6.95099992 Turk_Bulgaria_Central
6.97003985 Turk_Bulgaria_Northeast
8.09246872 Turk_Eastern_Macedonia
8.12070810 Turk_Balkan_average
8.39867251 Pomak_Central-Macedonia
8.74612739 Turk_Western_Thrace
8.89303098 Bulgaria_Northeastern
9.15427769 Vlach(Aromanian)_average
9.23794349 MacedonianWest
9.51309098 Pomak_Drama
9.56806668 Bulgaria_Southeastern
9.62356483 Moldova_South_Gagauzia
9.68487997 MacedonianEast
9.69077396 Turk_Central_Macedonia
9.70603936 MacedonianCentral
9.76225896 Vlach_North-Macedonia-Highlander
9.78160519 MacedonianNorthWest
9.82931330 Bulgaria_Southcentral
9.86289511 Macedonian_Average
9.88468007 MacedonianPelagonia
9.97186542 Bulgaria_Northcentral
9.98393710 MacedonianSouthWest
10.03396731 Bulgaria_average
10.05594849 Bulgaria_Southwestern
10.05707214 MacedonianGreeceNorthWest

Distance: 235.5620% / 2.35561999
Target: Impaler | ADC: 0.25x RC
55.6 Turk_Central_Macedonia
20.9 Turk_Bulgaria_East
16.9 North_German
6.6 Chamar

Try removing the Balkan Turk populations.

[Dunai]

Okay, in K13, delete these:
Hungarian,30.52,32.40,14.21,7.17,10.58,1.23,0.92,0 .51,1.19,0.56,0.36,0.19,0.16
Hungarian_Budapest,31.23,32.45,14.11,7.29,9.79,1.3 7,0.91,0.59,1.06,0.51,0.3,0.22,0.16
Hungarian_Transdanubia,31.72,31.63,13.96,7.34,10.5 6,1.07,0.98,0.4,1.08,0.56,0.31,0.17,0.2

And add these:
Hungarian,30.43,32.55,14.23,7.16,10.44,1.29,0.9,0. 54,1.19,0.55,0.36,0.2,0.15
Hungarian_Transdanubia+Budapest,31.23,32.45,14.11, 7.29,9.79,1.37,0.91,0.59,1.06,0.51,0.3,0.22,0.16 (n=130)

[Leto]

Updated:

Distance to: Impaler
6.95099992 Turk_Bulgaria_Central
6.97003985 Turk_Bulgaria_Northeast
8.09246872 Turk_Eastern_Macedonia
8.12070810 Turk_Balkan_average
8.39867251 Pomak_Central-Macedonia
8.74612739 Turk_Western_Thrace
8.89303098 Bulgaria_Northeastern
9.15427769 Vlach(Aromanian)_average
9.23794349 MacedonianWest
9.51309098 Pomak_Drama
9.56806668 Bulgaria_Southeastern
9.62356483 Moldova_South_Gagauzia
9.68487997 MacedonianEast
9.69077396 Turk_Central_Macedonia
9.70603936 MacedonianCentral
9.76225896 Vlach_North-Macedonia-Highlander
9.78160519 MacedonianNorthWest
9.82931330 Bulgaria_Southcentral
9.86289511 Macedonian_Average
9.88468007 MacedonianPelagonia
9.97186542 Bulgaria_Northcentral
9.98393710 MacedonianSouthWest
10.03396731 Bulgaria_average
10.05594849 Bulgaria_Southwestern
10.05707214 MacedonianGreeceNorthWest

Distance: 235.5620% / 2.35561999
Target: Impaler | ADC: 0.25x RC
55.6 Turk_Central_Macedonia
20.9 Turk_Bulgaria_East
16.9 North_German
6.6 Chamar

Try removing the Balkan Turk populations.

[Ion Basescul]

Updated:

Distance to: Impaler
6.95099992 Turk_Bulgaria_Central
6.97003985 Turk_Bulgaria_Northeast
8.09246872 Turk_Eastern_Macedonia
8.12070810 Turk_Balkan_average
8.39867251 Pomak_Central-Macedonia
8.74612739 Turk_Western_Thrace
8.89303098 Bulgaria_Northeastern
9.15427769 Vlach(Aromanian)_average
9.23794349 MacedonianWest
9.51309098 Pomak_Drama
9.56806668 Bulgaria_Southeastern
9.62356483 Moldova_South_Gagauzia
9.68487997 MacedonianEast
9.69077396 Turk_Central_Macedonia
9.70603936 MacedonianCentral
9.76225896 Vlach_North-Macedonia-Highlander
9.78160519 MacedonianNorthWest
9.82931330 Bulgaria_Southcentral
9.86289511 Macedonian_Average
9.88468007 MacedonianPelagonia
9.97186542 Bulgaria_Northcentral
9.98393710 MacedonianSouthWest
10.03396731 Bulgaria_average
10.05594849 Bulgaria_Southwestern
10.05707214 MacedonianGreeceNorthWest

Distance: 235.5620% / 2.35561999
Target: Impaler | ADC: 0.25x RC
55.6 Turk_Central_Macedonia
20.9 Turk_Bulgaria_East
16.9 North_German
6.6 Chamar

It's definitely simpler than that IMO.