0


Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 8,835/73 Given: 8,960/67 |
That Scythian sample is redundant and sensless because it represents a mix of "real" Scythians and some kind of a Bell Beaker-like population. It plots between Balkan Slavs and North Italians. Otherwise your model just seems to change the breakdown of the Paleo-Balkan ancestry and not it's actual amount.
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 52,629/1,011 Given: 43,539/788 |
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 8,835/73 Given: 8,960/67 |
Decided to take up Feiichy's idea for myself. I'd say the sampling here is fair considering the absurdely low distances to all of the balkan averages, but if you have any suggestions, feel free to add.
Spoiler!
Target: Slovenian
Distance: 0.3803% / 0.38028983
56.7 Slavic
25.3 Germanic
10.8 Paleo_Balkan
7.2 Eastern_Mediterranean
Target: Croat
Distance: 0.2564% / 0.25638615
59.3 Slavic
16.1 Germanic
15.6 Paleo_Balkan
9.0 Eastern_Mediterranean
Target: Bosniak
Distance: 0.2649% / 0.26486108
62.7 Slavic
19.0 Paleo_Balkan
12.0 Eastern_Mediterranean
6.3 Germanic
Target: Serb
Distance: 0.1302% / 0.13022115
55.2 Slavic
31.3 Paleo_Balkan
7.9 Eastern_Mediterranean
5.6 Germanic
Target: Montenegrin
Distance: 0.3155% / 0.31548324
43.0 Slavic
30.9 Paleo_Balkan
17.1 Eastern_Mediterranean
9.0 Germanic
Target: Macedonian
Distance: 0.4005% / 0.40054855
46.7 Paleo_Balkan
36.4 Slavic
12.3 Eastern_Mediterranean
4.6 Germanic
Target: Albanian
Distance: 0.5368% / 0.53677785
58.2 Paleo_Balkan
27.6 Slavic
11.5 Eastern_Mediterranean
2.7 Germanic
Target: Bulgarian
Distance: 0.0814% / 0.08138267
43.3 Slavic
29.1 Paleo_Balkan
21.6 Eastern_Mediterranean
6.0 Germanic
Target: Romanian
Distance: 0.0797% / 0.07967599
47.1 Slavic
31.6 Paleo_Balkan
14.0 Eastern_Mediterranean
5.5 Germanic
1.8 Turkic
Target: Moldavian
Distance: 0.0839% / 0.08386034
61.5 Slavic
20.0 Paleo_Balkan
12.3 Eastern_Mediterranean
4.1 Germanic
2.1 Turkic
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 8,835/73 Given: 8,960/67 |
...
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 18,280/95 Given: 14,328/51 |
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 18,280/95 Given: 14,328/51 |
Nice distance
Target: Dušan
Distance: 1.4077% / 1.40772730
64.4 Slavic
35.6 Paleo_Balkan
Target: Dušan
Distance: 1.4077% / 1.40772730
36.6 Slavic/Sungir6_Early_Medieval_Russian_I2a_I2a_
20.6 Paleo_Balkan/MJ12_Thraco_Kimmerian_
17.5 Slavic/Ukraine_Lutsk_Medieval_VK541
10.3 Slavic/Viking_Sweden_Gotland_VK454
8.4 Paleo_Balkan/I9006_Greece_Mycenaean_3287_ybp
6.6 Paleo_Balkan/I4332_Croatia_MBA_3516_ybp
Distance to: Dušan
1.79944108 41.40% Paleo_Balkan/MJ12_Thraco_Kimmerian_ + 58.60% Slavic/Sungir6_Early_Medieval_Russian_I2a_I2a_
2.30020233 33.60% Paleo_Balkan/I9006_Greece_Mycenaean_3287_ybp + 66.40% Slavic/Viking_Poland_Cedynia_VK212
2.38761442 31.80% Paleo_Balkan/I9006_Greece_Mycenaean_3287_ybp + 68.20% Slavic/AV2_Hungary_Szolad_540_640_AD_540_640_AD_
2.56403743 42.20% Paleo_Balkan/MJ12_Thraco_Kimmerian_ + 57.80% Slavic/Viking_Sweden_Gotland_VK454
2.89198780 28.60% Paleo_Balkan/I9033_Mycenaean_1352_bc_M_ + 71.40% Slavic/Sungir6_Early_Medieval_Russian_I2a_I2a_
2.91615950 24.60% Paleo_Balkan/I9033_Mycenaean_1352_bc_M_ + 75.40% Slavic/Ukraine_Lutsk_Medieval_VK541
3.00537627 26.00% Paleo_Balkan/I9006_Greece_Mycenaean_3287_ybp + 74.00% Slavic/Sungir6_Early_Medieval_Russian_I2a_I2a_
3.08740914 25.60% Paleo_Balkan/I5769_Bulgaria_IA_2600_ybp + 74.40% Slavic/Ukraine_Lutsk_Medieval_VK541
3.15846542 48.00% Paleo_Balkan/MJ12_Thraco_Kimmerian_ + 52.00% Slavic/AV2_Hungary_Szolad_540_640_AD_540_640_AD_
3.31129070 50.20% Paleo_Balkan/MJ12_Thraco_Kimmerian_ + 49.80% Slavic/Viking_Poland_Cedynia_VK212
🔴
🔵
⚪
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 18,280/95 Given: 14,328/51 |
Sungir6 is found on outskirts of Russian city of Vladimir, some 200 km east of Moscow.
Off course it doesnt have paleo-Balkan admixture. Are you crazy?
🔴
🔵
⚪
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 3,464/7 Given: 1,535/1 |
Danes or Norwegians are better as Stearsolina said, because modern Swedes have Finnic and Balto Slavic influence.
I tried to quickly filter out all the purely Germanic samples from G25:
the Szolad, Collegno and Vikings are also in k13 ancient.Code:Germanic:DEU_MA_ACD_STR_355,0.124067,0.137096,0.064488,0.054264,0.048009,0.021753,0.001175,0.002077,0.002659,0.008018,-0.004547,0.012289,0.000446,-0.012248,0.022937,0.020949,0.007823,0.001774,0.000754,0.011506,0.001747,0.005812,0.006039,0.01205,0.004191 Germanic:DEU_MA_AED_106,0.125205,0.133034,0.064865,0.067184,0.03416,0.020917,0.00517,0.008769,0.002863,-0.009476,-0.006171,0.002548,-0.012042,-0.006193,0.019544,0.008486,0.015255,-0.006968,-0.015964,0.005503,-0.003244,0.012736,-0.017378,0.005422,-0.000239 Germanic:DEU_MA_AED_249,0.125205,0.126941,0.071653,0.04845,0.043085,0.023706,0.020211,0.001385,0.003477,-0.01057,-0.011854,-0.002398,-0.009663,0.003303,0.019679,-0.002784,-0.026598,-0.001774,0.004148,0.00988,0.01697,-0.006554,0.000123,0.007953,0.010658 Germanic:DEU_MA_Alemanic_Byzantine_NIEcap12c,0.117238,0.133034,0.069013,0.059109,0.030467,0.013666,0.008695,0.013615,-0.002659,0.001276,-0.003897,0.006744,-0.015015,-0.003165,0.018594,0.005834,-0.002608,0.006841,0.005531,-0.003377,0.006738,0.006801,-0.004437,0.014942,0.006706 Germanic:DEU_MA_ALH_1,0.118376,0.129988,0.06939,0.051034,0.048009,0.023148,0.014101,-0.000692,0.006136,-0.001822,-0.002436,0.003447,-0.008474,-0.012248,0.012486,0.008088,-0.005215,0.004307,0.00817,0.009755,0.009858,0.004699,0.001725,0.002771,-0.002395 Germanic:DEU_MA_ALH_10,0.12862,0.132019,0.065242,0.047481,0.045239,0.023985,0.006345,-0.002308,0.002863,0.004009,0.001461,0.003447,-0.011298,0.004679,0.019137,-0.002254,-0.02386,0.010135,0.005279,-0.009254,0.003868,0.012736,-0.003328,0.012291,-0.000239 Germanic:DEU_MA_NW_255,0.118376,0.140143,0.060716,0.049742,0.041546,0.006693,0.020681,0.015692,-0.004909,-0.000364,-0.004384,0.007793,-0.012339,-0.003441,0.026194,-0.006099,-0.025164,0.0019,0.014581,0.003252,0.004617,-0.003833,0.008874,0.023136,-0.001796 Germanic:DEU_MA_STR_316,0.125205,0.12491,0.071653,0.057494,0.040315,0.03012,0.019976,-0.004154,0.000205,0,-0.010718,0.003297,-0.012487,-0.004129,0.028501,-0.008751,-0.019036,0.007095,0.006285,0.002876,-0.001373,0.00915,0.000493,0.01928,-0.00455 Germanic:DEU_MA_STR_486,0.120652,0.137096,0.04714,0.055233,0.042162,0.020638,0.008695,0.011999,0.010431,-0.005467,-0.002923,-0.006894,-0.017245,0.005367,0.007193,-0.002121,-0.028293,-0.002534,0.010559,0.008379,0.007237,0.001484,-0.01972,0.011568,-0.001078 Germanic:DNK_BA_RISE276,0.126344,0.135065,0.05506,0.05168,0.035391,0.030957,0.024206,-0.012692,-0.01493,0.002551,-0.006658,0.015137,-0.001933,-0.008257,0.013436,-0.004906,0.00665,0.005828,0.018729,0.001251,0.005116,0.001113,0.00456,0.007591,-0.022992 Germanic:DNK_BA_RISE47,0.105855,0.139128,0.071653,0.053295,0.024004,0.029284,-0.00188,0.002308,0.000409,-0.010205,0.000812,0.002698,-0.007433,-0.023946,0.014251,0.013259,0.00691,0.013302,0.01169,0.008004,0.030696,-0.018672,-0.002958,-0.002289,0.000239 Germanic:HUN_MA_Szolad_SZ11,0.134311,0.137096,0.058454,0.047481,0.038776,0.02008,0.00752,0.002308,-0.004704,-0.008747,-0.005196,0.006894,-0.010406,-0.006744,0.015201,0.012729,0.004824,0.000253,0.000503,0.004502,0.000125,0.004328,-0.001109,0.011688,-0.005508 Germanic:HUN_MA_Szolad_SZ12,0.135449,0.135065,0.060339,0.048127,0.047393,0.015339,0.0047,0.005307,-0.001227,-0.002916,-0.007632,0.002398,0.000149,-0.006468,0.019272,0.002387,-0.000522,-0.003801,0.003017,0.007754,0.010606,0.005564,-0.00456,-0.001928,-0.001437 Germanic:HUN_MA_Szolad_SZ13,0.133173,0.133034,0.065996,0.059109,0.041238,0.017012,0.00423,0.001154,-0.005522,-0.004191,-0.007632,0.007493,-0.008622,-0.004542,0.016422,0.006232,0.001043,-0.002407,0.007165,0.002876,0.015473,0.014715,0.003328,0.01458,0.000359 Germanic:HUN_MA_Szolad_SZ16,0.133173,0.128972,0.068259,0.062662,0.035699,0.019522,0.002585,0.009923,0.001432,-0.005832,0.001137,0.008992,-0.005946,-0.006881,0.024158,0.006232,-0.008084,-0.000253,-0.003017,0.009004,0.003244,0.005193,0.001109,0.014219,0.003353 Germanic:HUN_MA_Szolad_SZ2,0.122929,0.139128,0.070144,0.067184,0.038469,0.018128,0.00611,0.006461,-0.000205,-0.009294,-0.000974,-0.00015,-0.008474,-0.00055,0.017372,-0.006629,-0.022296,0.005954,0.005908,-0.004627,0.015597,0.000742,0.007395,0.008555,0.002634 Germanic:HUN_MA_Szolad_SZ22,0.130897,0.131003,0.057699,0.06137,0.044008,0.011713,0.00517,0.002538,-0.000409,0.000547,-0.012991,0.005845,-0.004906,-0.010735,0.010586,0.012463,0.000782,-0.003801,0.002891,0.012381,0.009109,0.004328,-0.004314,0.005663,0.003952 Germanic:HUN_MA_Szolad_SZ4,0.134311,0.133034,0.064488,0.056525,0.035699,0.021196,0.011751,0.007154,-0.001841,0.004191,-0.005846,0.001649,-0.013082,-0.001376,0.026465,-0.002519,-0.024121,0.004687,0.00176,-0.004002,0.006988,0.007543,0.004067,0.013737,0.001796 Germanic:HUN_MA_Szolad_SZ7,0.135449,0.135065,0.066373,0.062016,0.035083,0.01255,0.00611,0.005307,0.003272,0,-0.011205,0.0003,-0.007433,-0.010322,0.018729,0.002784,-0.005476,0.000127,0.001885,0.002376,0.009234,0.007419,0.001602,0.015785,-0.001197 Germanic:HUN_MA_Szolad_SZ9,0.138864,0.125926,0.069013,0.066861,0.036622,0.03012,0.00188,0.011999,0.011658,-0.000547,-0.011692,0.003597,-0.008176,-0.003716,0.029994,-0.001193,-0.00665,0.001394,0.00088,0.007629,0.011355,0.005812,-0.003451,0.014942,-0.001796 Germanic:ITA_Collegno_MA_CL145,0.132035,0.139128,0.060339,0.067507,0.041854,0.018686,0.0094,0.01223,0.001023,-0.009841,0.000812,0.006594,-0.00446,-0.001239,0.02918,-0.006364,-0.029336,0.004561,0.010056,0.003752,0.006489,0.010263,-0.002465,0.017231,0.002634 Germanic:ITA_Collegno_MA_CL146,0.129758,0.131003,0.063356,0.05491,0.040931,0.015897,0.003525,0.010384,0.001023,-0.006925,-0.002761,0.004346,-0.017988,-0.007982,0.026873,0.001193,-0.0103,0.003294,0.010056,0.011255,0.006239,0.004328,0.003944,0.017954,0.000838 Germanic:ITA_Collegno_MA_CL151,0.134311,0.129988,0.065242,0.062016,0.042777,0.019522,0.00846,0.014307,-0.002045,-0.005467,-0.004384,-0.001499,-0.010704,-0.010046,0.035694,-0.007292,-0.023469,0.006841,0.005656,0.008879,0.008235,0.008903,0.002465,0.016629,-0.001796 Germanic:ITA_Collegno_MA_CL83,0.132035,0.133034,0.065242,0.036499,0.0437,0.025379,0.00846,0.003461,0.005931,0.000182,-0.01023,0.002548,-0.016799,-0.000413,0.027008,0.001856,-0.007693,0.009502,0.006034,0.005628,0.008859,0.004204,-0.002342,0.014098,-0.002874 Germanic:ITA_Collegno_MA_CL84,0.133173,0.136081,0.07203,0.042636,0.049548,0.019801,0.005875,0.006923,0.010431,0,-0.008444,0.005545,-0.011447,-0.011973,0.023887,0.007823,-0.005476,0.003801,0.005782,0.004502,0.005865,0.002226,-0.008134,0.013978,0.000838 Germanic:ITA_Collegno_MA_CL92,0.135449,0.132019,0.070144,0.04845,0.037238,0.013945,0.00799,0.020307,0.005522,0.002551,-0.013478,-0.001649,-0.005798,-0.004404,0.02348,0.005171,-0.023208,0.005321,0.004777,-0.003502,0.008735,0.008903,-0.00493,0.003615,0.001078 Germanic:ITA_Collegno_MA_CL93,0.132035,0.140143,0.066373,0.05491,0.041238,0.014223,0.00846,0.013846,-0.002659,-0.007472,-0.008444,0.003747,-0.011893,-0.01156,0.03678,0.013259,-0.005737,0.002407,0.002263,0.001751,0.018093,0.009892,-0.000739,0.009399,0.005149 Germanic:Scythian_MDA_o_scy303,0.129758,0.131003,0.065242,0.063308,0.037238,0.02008,0.00846,0.003461,0.007158,-0.007472,-0.000812,0.002398,-0.00773,-0.011147,0.015336,0.024529,0.014473,0.001267,-0.001508,0.006378,0.006988,0.001237,-0.001972,0.001084,0.008263 Germanic:SWE_IA_RISE174,0.122929,0.123895,0.067127,0.058463,0.041238,0.02008,0.005875,0.007615,0.002863,-0.009659,0.003735,0.001948,-0.006987,0.003853,0.020358,-0.006762,-0.015385,0.006461,0.009427,0.00025,0.00025,0.002844,0.002465,0.011447,0.000359 Germanic:SWE_LN_RISE97,0.117238,0.133034,0.060339,0.058463,0.036314,0.004183,0.001645,0.007154,0.002454,-0.000729,-0.002923,0.003147,-0.006392,-0.01156,0.021851,0.019888,0.012126,-0.003927,0.012444,0.004877,0.012852,0.012489,-0.003451,-0.009158,-0.002275 Germanic:SWE_LN_RISE98,0.121791,0.12491,0.070899,0.072029,0.041546,0.0251,0.012691,0.008077,0.003681,-0.00328,0.00341,0.008393,-0.005946,-0.014038,0.019544,0.019491,0.0103,0.005574,0.006662,0.013882,0.005989,0.00272,0.001849,-0.000602,-0.002395 Germanic:SWE_Ollsjo_BA_oll007,0.120652,0.12491,0.056191,0.051357,0.038161,0.015618,0.00752,-0.002308,0.001227,0.004738,-0.005521,-0.002997,-0.009663,-0.01968,0.015201,0.005038,0.009388,0.00076,0,0.014382,0.002371,0.002473,-0.001725,0.005302,0.006706 Germanic:SWE_Ollsjo_BA_oll009,0.126344,0.133034,0.067127,0.063631,0.040623,0.016733,0.002585,0.005769,0.008795,0.00328,0.001786,0.01139,-0.005946,-0.000413,0.027958,0.014452,-0.016428,0.010515,0.003771,0.002501,0.006863,-0.007914,-0.004314,0.005302,-0.004431 Germanic:SWE_Ollsjo_BA_oll010,0.133173,0.140143,0.070144,0.051034,0.029544,0.018128,0.006345,0.015922,0.002863,-0.010205,0.000325,0.016785,-0.013974,-0.012661,0.012622,0.003315,0.005476,0.001267,-0.00264,0.024387,0.021961,0.004946,-0.001232,0.009037,0.005748 Germanic:VK2020_DNK_Jutland_IA_VK582,0.136588,0.13405,0.070522,0.069445,0.036007,0.022869,0.009635,0.013615,0.012885,-0.004374,0.006333,0.019633,-0.014271,-0.021744,0.015472,0.010607,0.001304,0.007095,0.00176,0.02101,0.014974,-0.000247,0.000986,0.025666,-0.00467 Germanic:VK2020_DNK_Sealand_IA_VK521,0.12862,0.131003,0.069013,0.063954,0.044008,0.022032,0,0.013615,0.008999,-0.010934,-0.003085,0.003447,-0.008028,-0.002752,0.020629,0,-0.020861,0.007728,0.005908,0.008879,0.012977,0.010263,-0.002588,0.010363,-0.002515 Germanic:VK2020_DNK_Sealand_IA_VK532,0.121791,0.131003,0.063356,0.063631,0.041238,0.018965,0.004465,0.010615,0.003068,-0.013668,-0.002761,0.007793,-0.00773,-0.004679,0.02538,0.007558,-0.007171,0.006588,0.009302,0.006628,0.002371,-0.000866,0.000739,0.01687,0.003712 Germanic:VK2020_DNK_Sealand_LNBA_VK214,0.117238,0.118817,0.079572,0.075905,0.048317,0.020638,-0.00094,0.01523,0.008181,-0.02278,-0.00682,-0.00045,-0.010852,-0.00289,0.023751,0.009546,-0.022948,0.01647,0.004148,-0.003377,0.018343,0.000742,0.000863,-0.000241,0.010897 Germanic:VK2020_NOR_Mid_IA_VK523,0.125205,0.125926,0.07731,0.06783,0.048009,0.023148,-0.00094,0.012461,0.006749,-0.017677,-0.003248,0.002548,-0.005203,-0.007707,0.020358,0.013392,-0.002086,-0.002407,0.003394,0.004002,0.004492,0.000495,-0.004437,-0.001084,0.001916 Germanic:VK2020_NOR_North_IA_VK418,0.125205,0.132019,0.070144,0.064277,0.040315,0.019522,0.00423,0.013846,0.007567,-0.007107,-0.001786,-0.002847,-0.011001,-0.001514,0.031487,-0.005967,-0.029858,-0.0019,0.00352,0.003001,0.010606,0.000371,0,0.003012,-0.000838 Germanic:VK2020_NOR_South_IA_VK390,0.121791,0.125926,0.076555,0.06783,0.040931,0.029005,0.003995,0.006231,0,-0.00893,-0.005684,0.002997,-0.011596,-0.010735,0.027551,0.007955,-0.009779,0.006208,0.008799,0.013006,0.018967,-0.000495,0.001972,0.007953,0.001197 Germanic:VK2020_NOR_South_IA_VK391,0.12862,0.141159,0.080327,0.062662,0.047701,0.022311,0.012691,0.011076,-0.003068,-0.015672,-0.012666,-0.004496,-0.002081,-0.007707,0.019679,0.0118,0.004303,0.003547,-0.006159,0.001,0.006988,-0.002597,-0.010723,0.014098,0.011017 Germanic:VK2020_SWE_Oland_IA_VK522,0.130897,0.132019,0.073916,0.066861,0.050163,0.022311,-0.00188,0.006231,0.010226,-0.003645,-0.002111,0.002548,-0.002081,-0.00578,0.018458,0.010475,-0.006389,-0.001774,0.005279,0.007504,0.002995,0.005441,0.000246,0.020364,0.001078 Germanic:VK2020_SWE_Oland_IA_VK579,0.110408,0.123895,0.085229,0.070414,0.035083,0.02259,0.01034,0.005769,-0.003886,-0.012939,-0.006983,0.007343,-0.005054,0.006881,0.010858,0.005967,-0.023078,0.004307,0.00264,-0.001751,0.011605,0.008656,-0.008874,0.014701,-0.002155
for Anatolia these could be good:
Code:MA2200_Anatolia_MLBA.SG_3800_ybp,2.30,0.00,24.62,25.44,41.07,6.09,0.00,0.00,0.00,0.00,0.48,0.00,0.00 MA2203_Anatolia_MLBA.SG_3800_ybp,10.14,0.00,24.29,15.47,42.31,6.07,0.24,0.30,0.00,0.00,0.01,0.29,0.88 MA2205_Anatolia_MLBA.SG_3800_ybp,0.84,0.00,21.01,25.74,45.03,6.16,0.00,1.09,0.00,0.13,0.00,0.00,0.00 MA2206_Anatolia_MLBA.SG_3800_ybp,3.02,0.00,23.15,25.98,42.95,3.48,0.00,0.00,0.00,0.68,0.74,0.00,0.00
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 1,823/77 Given: 1,098/94 |
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 46,276/308 Given: 32,181/1 |
if paleo Balkan equals neolithic then all Europeans have it or we'd all look like fucking eskimos.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Bookmarks