0
ok that's just complete and utter bullshit coming from a person who has no experience in Linguistics and comparative mythologies.
I genuinely don't even know where to start.
>Researcher wrote that all what is known about norse mythology from descriptions, archaelogical finds, place names etc, differs vitally compared to Edda's mythology.
What researcher? Can you provide me with a link to the article?
>This leads to conclusion: old pagan religion was in viking age have origins in christianity, .
No, it does not. You literally provided zero (0) arguments to substantiate your claim.
>Filologists demonstraded on linquistic basis, that none of poems in Edda cannot be older than 9th century
No way! These 'philologists' really cracked the mystery. It is as if we didn't know that Eddas were COMPILED/COLLECTED (not written) in the 12th century by multiple people across Scandinavia (which was already a christian land). I'd also love to see how they determined the age of the Eddas based solely on 'linguistics'.
>Poems cannot be reconstructed to older language forms, because poem rule would be ruined.
word salad
>Another thing explains, that poems are no older than viking age:
Mate, these 'poems' were not written by pagan Norsemen. They were written by christian scandinavians. These Eddas are collections of folk oral tradition. It's not some pagan bible or whatever you imagine it to be.
>There are lots of loan words from latin, aglosaxon and iiri.
Wow, no way bruv, you really trying to tell us languages change, interact with each other and inherit vocabulary/syntax from one another? That's mad, bro! Who would've thought Scandinavians had Anglo-Saxon or Latin loanwords (but considering the quality of your post I can already assume that a lot of those 'loanwords' are cognates. If you even know what a cognate is.) Just wait until you learn where Scandinavians got their runes from, it will blow your mind!
>Poems' topics are mainly loans
Unverifiable word salad. If anything, Christianity is a mixture of pagan sumerian tradition (half of biblical myths are identical to Sumerian/Mesopotamian myths, almost word for word) and local (Rome/Greece/Egypt) pagan cults. Christianity is a mixture of pagan cults. I know this will probably anger you but that's literally a historical fact.
>Edda doesn't show skandinavian paganism
That's probably the most brilliant piece of literary analysis I've ever seen in my entire life.
>but is based mainly on christian tradition
That's exactly the opposite. Christianity inherited A LOT of indo-european pagan elements. Otherwise it wouldn't have survived in Europe. If you were to compare it with the original jewish desert cult from which your christianity arose, modern christianity is nothing like that.
I honestly can't tell if this post is a troll or if this is what you genuinely believe.
Bookmarks