The Controversial Origins Of Haplogroup J and R

[PrimarisOrion]

The population history of J is too complicated but R1a is a more recent phenomenon. Haplogroup J is not semitic in origin, they spoke language isolates.





10,000 years of bleaching the middle east.

[Kess]

Haplogroup J is not semitic in origin, they spoke language isolates.

Who says haplogroup J is Semitic?

[kingmob]

J is Irano-Caucasian, not semitic, wtf is this nonsense.

[nittionia]

My dad is J2b2 and he said "nittionia, it's caucasian and western asian"

[Melkiirs]

My dad is J2b2 and he said "nittionia, it's caucasian and western asian"

Were you ever able to figure your paternal lineage? Which country was your 2nd great grandfather on that line from?

[PrimarisOrion]

J is Irano-Caucasian, not semitic, wtf is this nonsense.

It isn't nonsense. Haplogroup J originates from the Caucuses, it is generally darker there now since many fair skinned men left long ago, in Georgia's case. Part of Iran is in the Caucuses.

It is mocking insecure cultural marxist mentally ill types who like to spread lies.

[PrimarisOrion]

My dad is J2b2 and he said "nittionia, it's caucasian and western asian"

This is a cope because your MENA dad wants you to be with another MENA guy, you should be looking for a European man now to rebel against your annoying big sensitive ego MENA dad.

[nittionia]

Were you ever able to figure your paternal lineage? Which country was your 2nd great grandfather on that line from?

He was born in the German Empire but never shared information about his family (they died when he was young). I haven't been able to find any records for him

[nittionia]

This is a cope because your MENA dad wants you to be with another MENA guy, you should be looking for a European man now to rebel against your annoying big sensitive ego MENA dad.

He's not MENA

[PrimarisOrion]

He's not MENA

I assumed he was because your ethnicity is a unicorn and I thought you didn't wanna mention it. My mistake.