0
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 2,424/50 Given: 1,253/42 |
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 21,221/1,208 Given: 11,152/1,822 |
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 2,424/50 Given: 1,253/42 |
I have no problem with people disagreeing with the study, however there has to be a valid reason to discredit this specific academic study. For instance , they have made it clear which eye colours goes with which category as mentioned below :
"1: blue (equivalent to 1 and 2 in Fitzpatrick classification); 2: intermediate (equivalent to 3 in Fitzpatrick classification) where intermediate is combination of green, blue/green, brown/green pigments and 3: brown (equivalent to 4 and 5 in Fitzpatrick classification)."
They also mentioned this ;
"Eye and skin digital images were independently inspected by two different investigators under uniform environmental conditions. In order to avoid discrepancies, a further detailed analysis of all photographs was performed until consensus assignment of phenotype took place."
With all due respect, using Coon as the criterion against this study is quite distasteful. If anything we can use the studies aforementioned by myself.
Again, I'm not saying that people can't disagree, however there has to be a legit reason to discredit the study. Is there fault in the study? Etc
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 21,221/1,208 Given: 11,152/1,822 |
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 1,208/0 Given: 2,232/0 |
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 2,424/50 Given: 1,253/42 |
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 2,424/50 Given: 1,253/42 |
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 176/2 Given: 186/0 |
tbh 15% is way too high even if it was a combination of green/blue and all that in one category. I'd believe it if was small, isolated and super closed off communities but as a whole no way.
Full disclosure I actually do know one Pakistani Punjabi guy personally who has green eyes but I know a ton of Punjabi Pakistanis and I'm going to be real as a whole there's no way 15% of them even have green eyes much less blue. Many of my childhood friends and acquaintances themselves are of this background so I've had a ton of exposure and I know.
I think the methodology in this study is faulty because it really doesn't add up for any of these groups really.
Last edited by Ketchup; 05-23-2024 at 02:01 PM.
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 1,434/11 Given: 1,359/4 |
C is medium beige skin, not "light brown", the fuck.
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 12,788/225 Given: 32,362/230 |
I see some keep on mentioning the Indians they see in their countries to compare with, but Khyber Pakhtunkhwa is not South Asian, it's southcentral Asian, bordering northern Afghanistan and Tajikistan.
btw, seeing travel vlogs from the area and from Gilgit-Baltistan I am not surprised by the findings of the study in the OP regarding Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. then about Punjab I don't know at the moment, I didn't look at that area at all but I've seen even dark(er) skinned NW Indians with blue and hazel eyes in some documentaries
There are currently 2 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 2 guests)
Bookmarks