What does Catalan sound like to you?

[brazuca]

I'm leaving Romanian aside, of course. Romanian is like the 'English' of the Romance languages, in the sense that the non-Romance element on its lexicon is way too heavy.

"Brazilian" is almost a language, a mixture of Portuguese / Galician archaic northern Portugal with heavy influences of native languages

[Prisoner Of Ice]

Somewhere between french and italian. Very interesting.

[Rudel]

I agree. I prefer to say it's a human, clear-throat version of French.

French is the most clear-throated Romance language. Its phonology has been dictated by God Himself

I think Languedocian is more central, but that might be French tropism.

[Empecinado]

Catalan sounds too nasal and pseudo-French, the Valencian variant instead sounds more sober and clean:

Men voice:


Women voice:

[Rudel]

Catalan sounds too nasal and pseudo-French, the Valencian variant instead sounds more sober and clean:

Valencian sounds like purely and simply like Castillan with random Catalan words thrown in.

[Empecinado]

Valencian sounds like purely and simply like Castillan with random Catalan words thrown in.

No, what do you mean already exists, it's called Churro and it's a dialect spoken in Castilian speaking areas with Valencian influence. For example, they speak Castilian but pronunciate the C as S like in Valencian, the O like in Valencian and and the S like in Valencian besides throwing many Catalan words.

I can't find any video, but it sounds like a native Valencian speaker speaking Castilian.

[Longbowman]

"Brazilian" is almost a language, a mixture of Portuguese / Galician archaic northern Portugal with heavy influences of native languages

As if Portuguese and Galician are separate languages.

[Rudel]

As if Portuguese and Galician are separate languages.

Galicians are the authentic Spaniards, hence the True Hebrews and Goths.

[Longbowman]

Galicians are the authentic Spaniards, hence the True Hebrews and Goths.

Yes, but their language is the same as Portuguese, even if their blood is truer.

[Empecinado]

Yes, but their language is the same as Portuguese, even if their blood is truer.

The languages are different, at written level are almost the same but at phonological level are clearly separate languages. A Galician can understand relatevely well northern Portuguese but no way southern Portuguese, because the phonology.