Rare haplogroups for ethnicity.

[Abti]

My subclade is very rare, usually people get df27 or u152

I think you and our member rothaer have the same subclade. He is German, Eastern German but also R-S1194. R-S1194 overall is a relatively rarer Euro clade sibling of R-U106 and R-P312, nice.

[Touijer]

I know one or two, me. I am J2a-L26 from Ethiopia. With closer links to southernmost Arab countries. That are Saudi Arabia, Oman & Yemen.

I know another one which is R1b1-P25.1 in Somalia.

Both having a frequency next to none or 0.5% of their countries.

I would have expected J1, J2 is definitely surprising

[gixajo]

Thanks. did I run it correctly? Attachment 123834

Attachment 123840

Well, R1a-Z2125 with cladefinder and M417 with Morley´s...here we go again... did you use MyHeritage raw data?

That is cool. Croats and Serbs have iranian links according to some historians

I was predicted Z2125 using MH raw data and if I remember well a Croat woman´s male relative received the same prediction, and no one of us were actually Z2125.

I am Ra-Z280 (Z91) and I don´t remember well if that Croat man was R1a-Z282 or also Z280...

[kingmob]

Use yseq cladefinder.

[gixajo]

Well, my haplogroup is quite rare for my ethnicity.

I am R1a-Z280>YP5000>BY27340>FTA64118.



And as far as I know, most of the R1a in Spain use to be Z93.

I'm not lying: I would have liked to be R1a-Z2125

[Abti]

Use yseq cladefinder.

J2a-M67

[Abti]

Well, my haplogroup is quite rare for my ethnicity.

I am R1a-Z280>YP5000>BY27340>FTA64118.



And as far as I know, most of the R1a in Spain was Z93.

I'm not lying: I would have liked to be R1a-Z2125

Knew personally a Spaniard who was R-Y6 it was pretty weird. I think it was mostly due to the Muslim conquest of Andalusia.

[gixajo]

Knew personally a Spaniard who was R-Y6 it was pretty weird. I think it was mostly due to the Muslim conquest of Andalusia.

Maybe R-Y6 is more related with gypsy acestry.

[kingmob]

haplogroups have nothing to do with a specific ethnic group


speaking of r1a, there's indeed a high prevalence among altaic and kyrgyz people







likewise r1b





high frequency among turkmens, bashkir and chad peoples

What nonsense.

We are not referring to the modern distribution of these haplogroups but to their neolithic/chalcolithic spread that is associated with certain languages.

R1a/R1b are the Indo-European carriers, R1a is roughly related to the Corded Ware expansion and R1b(m269) to Yamnaya/Catacomb expansion.

Nothing to do with Altay, East Asia, Africa or what have you.

The modern spread shows how successful these paternal lineages were in asserting their reproduction.

[kingmob]

Furthermore, the Chad R1b is exclusively of the V88 variety which has nothing to do with the PIE m269, it's just indicative of the Euro HG migration in that particular region.

The Bashkirs and Turkmens' R1b is of the L584 nomeclature which is the vector of Yamnaya/Catacomb Caucasus route, the route that would eventually form the proto-Armenic speakers in the South Caucasus region and the surrounding areas.

One needs to be educated before making ignoramuses claims, delusions and copium are easy to be shot down.