Y-DNA distribution among ethnic Hungarians

[Scarface F]

Very good.

Here is the Hungarian paternal haplogroup of my brother-in-law (Hungarian father and French mother)
I-S17250
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_nH7...ventureHunters

It's Slavic in origin

[Ugo]

Southern guys.

[Universe]

You can ignore you share the same direct grandfather with other R1a’s, that you share 1,8% of your genome

Shared grandfather = 1.8% of the genome? How?

Of course culturally you share a lot with Spaniards then Slavs

Genetically too. Can't tell if you're trying to troll with this Y-dna thing (here and in other threads too), or you're just a moron.

She is close to the Europeans in her part of Europe but of course if we're talking about other races she will be closer to any native European than to those peoples. What you're spewing is the same bullshit a dipshit called Rethel used to promote. I'm Russian and can find other Russian men with very similar autosomal results but different haplgroups (N, I2, etc.). And I'm not even talking about the ethno-cultural aspect which is at the center of ethnic identity.

I thought he could be Rethel but then I remembered Rethel's English was much worse.

[Flashball]

It's Slavic in origin

Here are the paternal and maternal haplogroups of his matches which are indicated as 4/4 from Hungary
G-L1264 + H
R-L48 + H2a5
U5b2a (maternal haplogroup)
H6a1a (maternal haplogroup)
Y1 (maternal haplogroup)
F1b1 (maternal haplogroup)
R-L23 + U1b
I-M223 + U5a1
R-M417 + J1c
R-CTS3402 + H15a1
N1a1a (maternal haplogroup)
HV1a (maternal haplogroup)
HV1a1 (maternal haplogroup)

[Katarzyna]

It's Slavic in origin

I2a men are the best! One of my favourite haplogroups for men.
I really thank the early I2a men (Cucuteni-Trypilla) for entering our bloodline, so we don’t look like the Balts (north eastern phenotypes)

[gixajo]

Very good.

Here is the Hungarian paternal haplogroup of my brother-in-law (Hungarian father and French mother)
I-S17250
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_nH7...ventureHunters

There is an ancient individual (just medieval) with the previous subclade (I-Y3120) in the paper The genetic history of the Southern Arc: A bridge between West Asia and Europe found in Turkey but of obvious European origins and for this labelled as "outlier" (dated around 1200 years before present).

Turkey_Byzantine_oEuropean:I10430,0.132035,0.137096,0.064488,0.037791,0.04647,0.010877,0.009635,0.019615,-0.005113,-0.012757,0.001786,-0.006594,0.012042,0.017891,-0.011265,0.000398,0.008866,-0.004434,-0.002765,-0.003377,-0.007112,-0.004204,0.007148,-0.005302,-0.00479

And seems to be quite slavic:

Spoiler!

Distance to: Turkey_Byzantine_oEuropean:I10430
0.02548801 Ukrainian_Zakarpattia
0.02764561 Ukrainian_Lviv
0.02816135 Sorb_Niederlausitz
0.02975243 Croatian
0.03037100 Slovakian
0.03052766 Polish_Silesian
0.03155147 Polish
0.03208893 Slovenian
0.03215323 Hungarian
0.03359245 Czech
0.03446602 Russian_Belgorod
0.03536520 Ukrainian_Zhytomyr
0.03598781 Ukrainian_Rivne
0.03613780 Moldovan_o
0.03683589 Ukrainian_Chernihiv
0.03732237 Bosnian
0.03754513 Ukrainian_Sumy
0.03896059 Polish_Kashubian
0.03936374 Ukrainian_Dnipro
0.03972533 German_East
0.04014228 Russian_Voronez
0.04144570 Austrian
0.04182912 Russian_Orel
0.04271995 Cossack_Ukrainian
0.04359847 Russian_Smolensk

But it is a fairly modern individual and the I2 are usually considered diffusely Central-South European mesolithic in origin.

No ancient individuals in Yfull for the exact Ydna final clade of your brother in law : I-S17250

[Abti]

————

[Scarface F]

There is an ancient individual (just medieval) with the previous subclade (I-Y3120) in the paper The genetic history of the Southern Arc: A bridge between West Asia and Europe found in Turkey but of obvious European origins and for this labelled as "outlier" (dated around 1200 years before present).

Turkey_Byzantine_oEuropean:I10430,0.132035,0.137096,0.064488,0.037791,0.04647,0.010877,0.009635,0.019615,-0.005113,-0.012757,0.001786,-0.006594,0.012042,0.017891,-0.011265,0.000398,0.008866,-0.004434,-0.002765,-0.003377,-0.007112,-0.004204,0.007148,-0.005302,-0.00479

And seems to be quite slavic:

Spoiler!

Distance to: Turkey_Byzantine_oEuropean:I10430
0.02548801 Ukrainian_Zakarpattia
0.02764561 Ukrainian_Lviv
0.02816135 Sorb_Niederlausitz
0.02975243 Croatian
0.03037100 Slovakian
0.03052766 Polish_Silesian
0.03155147 Polish
0.03208893 Slovenian
0.03215323 Hungarian
0.03359245 Czech
0.03446602 Russian_Belgorod
0.03536520 Ukrainian_Zhytomyr
0.03598781 Ukrainian_Rivne
0.03613780 Moldovan_o
0.03683589 Ukrainian_Chernihiv
0.03732237 Bosnian
0.03754513 Ukrainian_Sumy
0.03896059 Polish_Kashubian
0.03936374 Ukrainian_Dnipro
0.03972533 German_East
0.04014228 Russian_Voronez
0.04144570 Austrian
0.04182912 Russian_Orel
0.04271995 Cossack_Ukrainian
0.04359847 Russian_Smolensk

But it is a fairly modern individual and the I2 are usually considered diffusely Central-South European mesolithic in origin.

No ancient individuals in Yfull for the exact Ydna final clade of your brother in law : I-S17250

No; his clade is Slavic. Neither is I2 of south-central European mesolithic. Scandinavian HGs were I2 and that is oldest haplogroup there.

Enough mystification of I2 origins, makes me irritated.

[Scarface F]

I2a men are the best! One of my favourite haplogroups for men.
I really thank the early I2a men (Cucuteni-Trypilla) for entering our bloodline, so we don’t look like the Balts (north eastern phenotypes)

Cucuteni Trypillia men wwre actually G2a - it is old idea I2 comes from there but it doesn't.

I2 is a WHG marker and specific Slavic haplogroup of I2 comes from western Europe and was probably Celtic before it took part in proto Slavic ethnogenesis.

[Ugo]

Bugger off. R1b won't make you closer to Europeans than to your Moroccan E1b breathen. Back to desert!

Together with you. If the EHG is below 40 - everything is in the desert .