PDA

View Full Version : Comparing my DNA.Land, Myheritage and AncestryDNA, K36 results


myouss
09-03-2017, 09:09 PM
AncestryDNA Results
https://i.gyazo.com/9b05d20ac08a1805bdd76d5c213831e3.png

MyHeritage Results
https://i.gyazo.com/5b88e3818f86c9909b8171b799efc4db.png

DNA.land Results
https://i.gyazo.com/9b601595228c7ab585885ad9143a6863.png

K36

Using 1 population approximation:
1 Uyghur @ 29.614842
2 Yizu_SW_China @ 29.918003
3 Turkish_Anatolia @ 31.700328
4 Naxi-SW-China @ 31.917214
5 Miaozu_SE-China @ 32.156586
6 Turkmen_Uzbekistan @ 32.22188
7 Tatar_Crimea_Coast @ 32.346811
8 Turkey_average @ 32.564747
9 Uzbek @ 32.679325
10 Turkmen @ 32.710953
11 Hazara_PAK @ 32.86662
12 Greek_Azov @ 33.082091
13 Azeri_Igdir @ 33.242249
14 Tatar_Crimea_Steppe @ 33.556704
15 Ashkenazi_Eastern_Euro @ 33.648866
16 Tujia_South-china @ 33.725726
17 Azeri @ 33.801818
18 BLG_Turk @ 33.909434
19 Askhenazi @ 34.132735
20 Azeri_Jews @ 34.599814
337 iterations.

Using 2 populations approximation:
1 Tujia_South-china+Azeri_Jews @ 9.715911
2 Han_China+Azeri_Jews @ 9.764946
3 Tujia_South-china+Assyrian @ 10.067032
4 Han_China+Assyrian @ 10.114365
5 She_South-China+Azeri_Jews @ 10.306698
6 Tujia_South-china+Iraqi_Jews @ 10.365889
7 Han_China+Iraqi_Jews @ 10.411864
8 Miaozu_SE-China+Azeri_Jews @ 10.415085
9 Yizu_SW_China+Azeri_Jews @ 10.584547
10 She_South-China+Assyrian @ 10.638338
11 Miaozu_SE-China+Assyrian @ 10.74338
12 Tujia_South-china+Caucasus_Jews @ 10.835299
13 Han_China+Caucasus_Jews @ 10.87929
14 Yizu_SW_China+Assyrian @ 10.907742
15 She_South-China+Iraqi_Jews @ 10.921573
16 Han_China+Turkish_Anatolia @ 10.937271
17 Han_China+Azeri_Igdir @ 10.98057
18 Miaozu_SE-China+Iraqi_Jews @ 11.023917
19 Tujia_South-china+Kurd @ 11.03281
20 Han_China+Kurd @ 11.076017
56953 iterations.

Using 3 populations approximation:
1 50% Azeri_Jews +25% Han_China +25% Yizu_SW_China @ 7.331011
2 50% Azeri_Jews +25% She_South-China +25% Yizu_SW_China @ 7.729996
3 50% Assyrian +25% Han_China +25% Yizu_SW_China @ 7.790375
4 50% Assyrian +25% She_South-China +25% Yizu_SW_China @ 8.166949
5 50% Iraqi_Jews +25% Han_China +25% Yizu_SW_China @ 8.172911
6 50% Azeri_Jews +25% Han_China +25% Naxi-SW-China @ 8.182823
7 50% Azeri_Jews +25% Yizu_SW_China +25% Tujia_South-china @ 8.401747
8 50% Iraqi_Jews +25% She_South-China +25% Yizu_SW_China @ 8.532619
9 50% Assyrian +25% Han_China +25% Naxi-SW-China @ 8.596791
10 50% Azeri_Jews +25% She_South-China +25% Naxi-SW-China @ 8.701272
11 50% Caucasus_Jews +25% Han_China +25% Yizu_SW_China @ 8.760867
12 50% Assyrian +25% Yizu_SW_China +25% Tujia_South-china @ 8.805428
13 50% Azeri_Jews +25% Miaozu_SE-China +25% Yizu_SW_China @ 8.826648
14 50% Iraqi_Jews +25% Han_China +25% Naxi-SW-China @ 8.944906
15 50% Han_China +25% Turkmen +25% Samaritan @ 9.004184
16 50% Kurd +25% Han_China +25% Yizu_SW_China @ 9.004499
17 50% Azeri_Jews +25% Dai_South-China +25% Naxi-SW-China @ 9.058355
18 50% Han_China +25% Samaritan +25% Azeri @ 9.065315
19 50% Assyrian +25% She_South-China +25% Naxi-SW-China @ 9.091663
20 50% Caucasus_Jews +25% She_South-China +25% Yizu_SW_China @ 9.097357
13175008 iterations.

Using 4 populations approximation:
1 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Samaritan+Azeri @ 6.531163
2 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Levant+Kurd @ 6.569446
3 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Samaritan+Kurd @ 6.587274
4 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Levant+Azeri @ 6.593393
5 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Iran+Samaritan @ 6.65552
6 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Palestina+Kurd @ 6.717767
7 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Iran+Levant @ 6.721322
8 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Azeri+Iraqi_Jews @ 6.784175
9 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Kurd+Iraqi_Jews @ 6.793223
10 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Palestina+Azeri @ 6.86619
11 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Iran+Palestina @ 6.977185
12 She_South-China+Yizu_SW_China+Samaritan+Azeri @ 6.989927
13 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Jordan+Kurd @ 6.991123
14 She_South-China+Yizu_SW_China+Levant+Kurd @ 7.012139
15 She_South-China+Yizu_SW_China+Samaritan+Kurd @ 7.028605
16 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Iran+Cyprus @ 7.033768
17 She_South-China+Yizu_SW_China+Levant+Azeri @ 7.048346
18 She_South-China+Yizu_SW_China+Iran+Samaritan @ 7.091147
19 She_South-China+Yizu_SW_China+Palestina+Kurd @ 7.152116
20 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Iran+Iraqi_Jews @ 7.153112
21 She_South-China+Yizu_SW_China+Iran+Levant @ 7.153178
22 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Azeri_Igdir+Iraqi_Jews @ 7.162686
23 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Turkey_average+Iraqi_Jews @ 7.179514
24 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Assyrian+Kurd @ 7.18191
25 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Jordan+Armenian @ 7.196267
26 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Jordan+Azeri @ 7.209854
27 She_South-China+Yizu_SW_China+Kurd+Iraqi_Jews @ 7.22198
28 She_South-China+Yizu_SW_China+Azeri+Iraqi_Jews @ 7.226896
29 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Turkish_Anatolia+Iraqi_Jew s @ 7.251707
30 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Assyrian+Azeri @ 7.252162
31 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Azeri+Cyprus @ 7.274072
32 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Levant+Azeri_Igdir @ 7.282717
33 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Palestina+Armenian @ 7.288656
34 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Kurd+Cyprus @ 7.29372
35 She_South-China+Yizu_SW_China+Palestina+Azeri @ 7.304985
36 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Samaritan+Azeri_Dagestan @ 7.315184
37 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Azeri_Jews+Azeri_Jews @ 7.331011
38 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Iraqi_Jews+Azeri_Jews @ 7.332351
39 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Levant+Armenian @ 7.345904
40 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Iran+Assyrian @ 7.3532

..and here's WeGene for fun
https://i.gyazo.com/cb3a80a60331375cf446fc015545fb4b.png

Not sure how accurate this is, but haplogroups according to WeGene:
Paternal: R1b1a1a2a
Maternal: L1'2'3'4'5'6 (I view this as impossible)

For me I find the results all wildly different from one another, don't really know what is reliable. Thinking about whether it is worth getting a 23andme test done to see if results differ.
Loki
09-03-2017, 10:57 PM
Interesting, you look like some sort of Turkic-Chinese mix in the reports.
Yehiel
09-03-2017, 11:04 PM
Im kinda in the same boat, I get crazy different results with every test I take and I have been debating on whether I should get one with AncestryDNA

But I already know what I am so I dont think its worth.
myouss
09-04-2017, 06:13 AM
My mother comes from Hunan in China, my father from Qamishli (crossroad town in Syria, kilometres from Turkey and Iraq). They previously lived in Azekh/Bet Zabday (modern day İdil in Turkey), which was a

The results for the Chinese side on GEDmatch lined up with what I'd expect, Tujia/Han, Tujia people being very common in Hunan where she is from even though she always identified as simply Chinese. She is rumoured to have a Russian great-grandparent, and some of the tests seem to possibly reflect that as a Central Asian/former USSR.

As for my fathers side, we identify as Syriac/Aramean/Assyrian (changes all the time), it's a pretty endogamous group and the lack of Arabian admixture with the surrounding countries seems to evidence that but I'm still intrigued by the amount of Caucasus/Central Asian that comes up.

On the other hand, I may be wrong, but a Caucasus Jewish ethnic similarity may be explained by historical facts, such as ~2000 years ago there not being a split between these religious groups.
zhaoyun
09-09-2017, 05:29 PM
Do you look Uighur?
Iloko
09-09-2017, 05:42 PM
I wonder what the 18% Asia Central on Ancestry.com means
Governor
09-09-2017, 06:36 PM
Do you look Uighur?

Imo, some Uighurs look East Asian+Irano-Afghan/MENA mix but Kazakhs and Kyrgyz people look more East Asian/Mongoloid.
Lucas
09-09-2017, 08:04 PM
AncestryDNA Results


K36

Using 1 population approximation:
1 Uyghur @ 29.614842
2 Yizu_SW_China @ 29.918003
3 Turkish_Anatolia @ 31.700328
4 Naxi-SW-China @ 31.917214
5 Miaozu_SE-China @ 32.156586
6 Turkmen_Uzbekistan @ 32.22188
7 Tatar_Crimea_Coast @ 32.346811
8 Turkey_average @ 32.564747
9 Uzbek @ 32.679325
10 Turkmen @ 32.710953
11 Hazara_PAK @ 32.86662
12 Greek_Azov @ 33.082091
13 Azeri_Igdir @ 33.242249
14 Tatar_Crimea_Steppe @ 33.556704
15 Ashkenazi_Eastern_Euro @ 33.648866
16 Tujia_South-china @ 33.725726
17 Azeri @ 33.801818
18 BLG_Turk @ 33.909434
19 Askhenazi @ 34.132735
20 Azeri_Jews @ 34.599814
337 iterations.

Using 2 populations approximation:
1 Tujia_South-china+Azeri_Jews @ 9.715911
2 Han_China+Azeri_Jews @ 9.764946
3 Tujia_South-china+Assyrian @ 10.067032
4 Han_China+Assyrian @ 10.114365
5 She_South-China+Azeri_Jews @ 10.306698
6 Tujia_South-china+Iraqi_Jews @ 10.365889
7 Han_China+Iraqi_Jews @ 10.411864
8 Miaozu_SE-China+Azeri_Jews @ 10.415085
9 Yizu_SW_China+Azeri_Jews @ 10.584547
10 She_South-China+Assyrian @ 10.638338
11 Miaozu_SE-China+Assyrian @ 10.74338
12 Tujia_South-china+Caucasus_Jews @ 10.835299
13 Han_China+Caucasus_Jews @ 10.87929
14 Yizu_SW_China+Assyrian @ 10.907742
15 She_South-China+Iraqi_Jews @ 10.921573
16 Han_China+Turkish_Anatolia @ 10.937271
17 Han_China+Azeri_Igdir @ 10.98057
18 Miaozu_SE-China+Iraqi_Jews @ 11.023917
19 Tujia_South-china+Kurd @ 11.03281
20 Han_China+Kurd @ 11.076017
56953 iterations.

Using 3 populations approximation:
1 50% Azeri_Jews +25% Han_China +25% Yizu_SW_China @ 7.331011
2 50% Azeri_Jews +25% She_South-China +25% Yizu_SW_China @ 7.729996
3 50% Assyrian +25% Han_China +25% Yizu_SW_China @ 7.790375
4 50% Assyrian +25% She_South-China +25% Yizu_SW_China @ 8.166949
5 50% Iraqi_Jews +25% Han_China +25% Yizu_SW_China @ 8.172911
6 50% Azeri_Jews +25% Han_China +25% Naxi-SW-China @ 8.182823
7 50% Azeri_Jews +25% Yizu_SW_China +25% Tujia_South-china @ 8.401747
8 50% Iraqi_Jews +25% She_South-China +25% Yizu_SW_China @ 8.532619
9 50% Assyrian +25% Han_China +25% Naxi-SW-China @ 8.596791
10 50% Azeri_Jews +25% She_South-China +25% Naxi-SW-China @ 8.701272
11 50% Caucasus_Jews +25% Han_China +25% Yizu_SW_China @ 8.760867
12 50% Assyrian +25% Yizu_SW_China +25% Tujia_South-china @ 8.805428
13 50% Azeri_Jews +25% Miaozu_SE-China +25% Yizu_SW_China @ 8.826648
14 50% Iraqi_Jews +25% Han_China +25% Naxi-SW-China @ 8.944906
15 50% Han_China +25% Turkmen +25% Samaritan @ 9.004184
16 50% Kurd +25% Han_China +25% Yizu_SW_China @ 9.004499
17 50% Azeri_Jews +25% Dai_South-China +25% Naxi-SW-China @ 9.058355
18 50% Han_China +25% Samaritan +25% Azeri @ 9.065315
19 50% Assyrian +25% She_South-China +25% Naxi-SW-China @ 9.091663
20 50% Caucasus_Jews +25% She_South-China +25% Yizu_SW_China @ 9.097357
13175008 iterations.

Using 4 populations approximation:
1 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Samaritan+Azeri @ 6.531163
2 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Levant+Kurd @ 6.569446
3 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Samaritan+Kurd @ 6.587274
4 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Levant+Azeri @ 6.593393
5 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Iran+Samaritan @ 6.65552
6 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Palestina+Kurd @ 6.717767
7 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Iran+Levant @ 6.721322
8 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Azeri+Iraqi_Jews @ 6.784175
9 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Kurd+Iraqi_Jews @ 6.793223
10 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Palestina+Azeri @ 6.86619
11 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Iran+Palestina @ 6.977185
12 She_South-China+Yizu_SW_China+Samaritan+Azeri @ 6.989927
13 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Jordan+Kurd @ 6.991123
14 She_South-China+Yizu_SW_China+Levant+Kurd @ 7.012139
15 She_South-China+Yizu_SW_China+Samaritan+Kurd @ 7.028605
16 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Iran+Cyprus @ 7.033768
17 She_South-China+Yizu_SW_China+Levant+Azeri @ 7.048346
18 She_South-China+Yizu_SW_China+Iran+Samaritan @ 7.091147
19 She_South-China+Yizu_SW_China+Palestina+Kurd @ 7.152116
20 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Iran+Iraqi_Jews @ 7.153112
21 She_South-China+Yizu_SW_China+Iran+Levant @ 7.153178
22 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Azeri_Igdir+Iraqi_Jews @ 7.162686
23 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Turkey_average+Iraqi_Jews @ 7.179514
24 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Assyrian+Kurd @ 7.18191
25 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Jordan+Armenian @ 7.196267
26 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Jordan+Azeri @ 7.209854
27 She_South-China+Yizu_SW_China+Kurd+Iraqi_Jews @ 7.22198
28 She_South-China+Yizu_SW_China+Azeri+Iraqi_Jews @ 7.226896
29 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Turkish_Anatolia+Iraqi_Jew s @ 7.251707
30 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Assyrian+Azeri @ 7.252162
31 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Azeri+Cyprus @ 7.274072
32 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Levant+Azeri_Igdir @ 7.282717
33 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Palestina+Armenian @ 7.288656
34 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Kurd+Cyprus @ 7.29372
35 She_South-China+Yizu_SW_China+Palestina+Azeri @ 7.304985
36 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Samaritan+Azeri_Dagestan @ 7.315184
37 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Azeri_Jews+Azeri_Jews @ 7.331011
38 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Iraqi_Jews+Azeri_Jews @ 7.332351
39 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Levant+Armenian @ 7.345904
40 Han_China+Yizu_SW_China+Iran+Assyrian @ 7.3532


Can you post your K36 components breakdown also?
zhaoyun
09-10-2017, 02:07 AM
Imo, some Uighurs look East Asian+Irano-Afghan/MENA mix but Kazakhs and Kyrgyz people look more East Asian/Mongoloid.

It's interesting because Uyghurs are actually very diverse. In North Xinjiang, they look more Mongol shifted, and admixed with Kazakhs, and maybe some ancient Han blood. In the South, they are more Iranid and somewhat Europid looking..
myouss
09-11-2017, 03:50 AM
I'm a pretty social person, work in retail, the topic of where I'm from has come up many times and I frequently just refer to myself as Mr Worldwide AKA Pitbull, as I've had guesses in literally every continent. I have grown a thick beard recently which has skewed guesses to more Mediterranean though.

My maternal grandpa is from Beijing, family rumour is that his grandma was from Russia/Soviet Union, which may account for some Central Asian but I'm really not sure about this. Kinda buried family secret as she may have been a concubine etc, his grandfather was well-off and had 3 or so wives/partners, him descending from one of those apparently. My maternal grandmother was from Hunan, south China, thought to be purely Han Chinese (although Gedmatch says Tujia which is native to Hunan, very possibly true).

If I were to guess where I'm most frequently thought to come from, probably Mauritius/Seychelle, although I have to stress I really do get a crazy spread.

I have a lot of friends, including people from Xinjiang etc and I've never been guessed as an Uyghur, there are plenty of Afghans in Australia and I've never been picked as an Afghan (Hazara or Pashtun). I look too different to both of these groups. Han Chinese people don't pick me as being Chinese unless I tell them (I have surprised every Chinese customer by speaking Mandarin with them without fail), likewise with Syrian/Lebanese/Levant group.

K36 Components Breakdown:

Population
Amerindian -
Arabian 5.59
Armenian 4.99
Basque -
Central_African -
Central_Euro -
East_African -
East_Asian 14.71
East_Balkan 1.10
East_Central_Asian 5.63
East_Central_Euro -
East_Med 9.47
Eastern_Euro 0.74
Fennoscandian -
French -
Iberian -
Indo-Chinese 6.30
Italian 3.62
Malayan -
Near_Eastern 8.98
North_African -
North_Atlantic -
North_Caucasian 4.76
North_Sea -
Northeast_African -
Oceanian -
Omotic -
Pygmy -
Siberian -
South_Asian -
South_Central_Asian 5.91
South_Chinese 22.06
Volga-Ural -
West_African -
West_Caucasian 3.80
West_Med 2.34