PDA

View Full Version : Part II. Match the Greek results to their respective regions.


Sikeliot
11-19-2017, 06:24 PM
1 Cyclades
1 Dodecanese
1 Chios
1 Cretan
1 Macedonia
1 Peloponnese



PERSON 1:

Using 1 population approximation:
1 Greek_Athens_ @ 5.026800
2 Greek_ @ 5.108053
3 Azov_Greek_ @ 6.065258
4 Cretan_ @ 6.234271
5 Italian_South_ @ 6.666663
6 Greek_Macedonia_ @ 6.728625
7 Central_Greek_ @ 7.538509
8 Romanian_Jew_ @ 7.624194
9 Greek_Phokaia_ @ 7.782112
10 Greek_Smyrna_ @ 7.851634
11 Crimean_Tatar_Mountain_ @ 8.279331
12 Crimean_Tatar_Coast_ @ 8.354963
13 Ashkenazi_ @ 8.864932
14 Turk_Balikesir_ @ 9.311934
15 Greek_Islands_ @ 9.342924
16 Ashkenazi_Jew_ @ 9.640083
17 Greek_Peloponnesos_ @ 10.084834
18 Sicilian_East_ @ 10.302296
19 Sicilian_Center_ @ 10.327477
20 Turk_Istanbul_ @ 10.330331



PERSON 2:

Using 1 population approximation:
1 Cretan_ @ 5.865150
2 Greek_Smyrna_ @ 7.022455
3 Sicilian_West_ @ 7.477104
4 French_Jew_ @ 7.510386
5 Ashkenazi_Jew_ @ 7.842856
6 Sicilian_Agrigento_ @ 7.860495
7 Sicilian_East_ @ 7.925326
8 Turk_Balikesir_ @ 8.631249
9 Sephardic_Jew_ @ 8.695009
10 Sicilian_Siracusa_ @ 8.886223
11 Romanian_Jew_ @ 9.057708
12 Sicilian_Trapani_ @ 9.209101
13 Maltese_ @ 9.366005
14 Turk_Jew_ @ 9.436999
15 Greek_Islands_ @ 9.564956
16 Italian_Jew_ @ 9.595266
17 Italian_South_ @ 9.696585
18 Ashkenazi_ @ 9.834040
19 Greek_Athens_ @ 10.444874
20 Syrian_Jew_ @ 10.720083


PERSON 3:

Using 1 population approximation:
1 Greek_Thessaloniki_ @ 2.491217
2 Greek_Thessaly_ @ 3.035055
3 Greek_Peloponnesos_ @ 3.146316
4 Albanian_Tirana_ @ 3.366410
5 Greek_Northwest_ @ 3.666250
6 Kosovar_ @ 4.809416
7 Central_Greek_ @ 5.066205
8 Greek_ @ 7.339186
9 Greek_Macedonia_ @ 8.041560
10 Greek_Athens_ @ 8.397893
11 Ashkenazi_ @ 8.514470
12 Gagauz_ @ 9.287889
13 Crimean_Tatar_Mountain_ @ 9.584191
14 Bulgarian_ @ 10.227950
15 Ashkenazi_Jew_ @ 10.235954
16 Romanian_Jew_ @ 10.641794
17 Italian_South_ @ 10.766289
18 Greek_Phokaia_ @ 10.817068
19 Sicilian_Siracusa_ @ 10.866802
20 Romanian_ @ 10.902764


PERSON 4:

Using 1 population approximation:
1 Sicilian_West_ @ 3.014183
2 Ashkenazi_Jew_ @ 3.851106
3 Sicilian_Siracusa_ @ 3.931549
4 Sicilian_East_ @ 4.385035
5 Sicilian_Agrigento_ @ 4.579704
6 Sicilian_Trapani_ @ 4.710043
7 Maltese_ @ 5.882181
8 Ashkenazi_ @ 5.883376
9 French_Jew_ @ 6.292793
10 Romanian_Jew_ @ 6.453343
11 Cretan_ @ 6.615807
12 Sicilian_Center_ @ 7.415609
13 Italian_South_ @ 7.742931
14 Italian_Abruzzo_ @ 7.883684
15 Greek_Athens_ @ 8.406292
16 Greek_Smyrna_ @ 8.989958
17 Sephardic_Jew_ @ 9.080424
18 Italian_Jew_ @ 9.108439
19 Greek_ @ 9.149619
20 Turk_Jew_ @ 9.248892



PERSON 5:

Using 1 population approximation:
1 Greek_Northwest_ @ 4.147176
2 Kosovar_ @ 4.296228
3 Greek_Thessaly_ @ 4.595067
4 Greek_Thessaloniki_ @ 4.733416
5 Albanian_Tirana_ @ 5.157622
6 Greek_Peloponnesos_ @ 5.305248
7 Central_Greek_ @ 8.000516
8 Bulgarian_ @ 8.890624
9 Italian_North_ @ 9.360371
10 Gagauz_ @ 9.857729
11 Romanian_ @ 9.930850
12 Macedonian_ @ 10.384504
13 Greek_ @ 10.572139
14 Ashkenazi_ @ 10.618584
15 Greek_Macedonia_ @ 10.915372
16 Italian_Tuscan_ @ 11.489253
17 Greek_Athens_ @ 11.657059
18 Crimean_Tatar_Mountain_ @ 11.892014
19 Ashkenazi_Jew_ @ 11.915328
20 Italian_Piedmont_ @ 12.458850


PERSON 6:

Using 1 population approximation:
1 Greek_ @ 4.112974
2 Greek_Macedonia_ @ 4.823229
3 Greek_Athens_ @ 5.522068
4 Cretan_ @ 6.619571
5 Azov_Greek_ @ 6.857995
6 Central_Greek_ @ 6.881587
7 Italian_South_ @ 7.188241
8 Greek_Phokaia_ @ 7.196832
9 Romanian_Jew_ @ 7.200843
10 Crimean_Tatar_Mountain_ @ 7.690177
11 Ashkenazi_ @ 7.695239
12 Greek_Peloponnesos_ @ 8.122323
13 Ashkenazi_Jew_ @ 8.494423
14 Greek_Thessaloniki_ @ 9.033640
15 Crimean_Tatar_Coast_ @ 9.421849
16 Turk_Balikesir_ @ 9.484832
17 Greek_Thessaly_ @ 9.679854
18 Sicilian_East_ @ 9.809369
19 Albanian_Tirana_ @ 10.027080
20 Sicilian_Siracusa_ @ 10.047124
Ancap
11-19-2017, 07:50 PM
I can't see your PM nor can I post you a visitor message

https://image.prntscr.com/image/8czL98_qSZWac4KyZUkQSQ.png
Sikeliot
11-19-2017, 07:52 PM
I can't see your PM nor can I post you a visitor message

https://image.prntscr.com/image/8czL98_qSZWac4KyZUkQSQ.png

Try the message now.
Bobby Martnen
11-19-2017, 08:15 PM
Person 1: Peloponnese
Person 2: Crete
Person 3: Macedonia
Person 4: Dodecanese
Person 5: Cyclades
Person 6: Chios

(not so sure about the last 2)
Please try mine: https://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?227687-Classify-woman-from-the-1900s-please
kleenex
11-19-2017, 10:12 PM
1. Cyclades (should cluster with Athenians since fairly close in proximity).
2.Dodacanese (relatively East shifted)
3.Peloponnese (I often come up close to Macedonians, NW Greeks, Thessalians so this makes sense).
4. Chios (A lot of Sicilian which would make sense for Chios).
5. Macedonia (most Northern shifted)
6. ? (Not sure about this since it's pretty Central/North shifted) Could it be Cretan. I'm sure there are North shifted Cretans.
What calculator is this please? Thanks
Sikeliot
11-19-2017, 10:21 PM
1. Cyclades (should cluster with Athenians since fairly close in proximity).
2.Dodacanese (relatively East shifted)
3.Peloponnese (I often come up close to Macedonians, NW Greeks, Thessalians so this makes sense).
4. Chios (A lot of Sicilian which would make sense for Chios).
5. Macedonia (most Northern shifted)
6. ? (Not sure about this since it's pretty Central/North shifted) Could it be Cretan. I'm sure there are North shifted Cretans.
What calculator is this please? Thanks



MDLP K23.

Some of these are close. What I notice is of the results, both #2 and #4 are very close to some Sicilian regions. This would give them away as islanders but the question is which. I will tell you the answers later.
Tauromachos
11-19-2017, 10:25 PM
MDLP K23.

Some of these are close. What I notice is of the results, both #2 and #4 are very close to some Sicilian regions. This would give them away as islanders but the question is which. I will tell you the answers later.

2 Cretan
4 Dodecanese
Sikeliot
11-19-2017, 10:27 PM
2 Cretan
4 Dodecanese

I'll give a hint. The Cretan and person from Chios are both shifting north and away from Sicily toward the mainland, while the Dodecanese and Cyclades results show more affinity to Sicily.

I have a number of Chios, a few Cyclades, and some Crete results showing this tendency, but all of the Dodecanese are Sicilian-like.
Sikeliot
11-19-2017, 10:30 PM
What I also notice is that many of the southern islanders get Sicilian West on this calculator, a Palermitan sample, over the Messina-based Sicily East. This might hint at the Levantine connection.
Tauromachos
11-19-2017, 10:30 PM
I'll give a hint. The Cretan and person from Chios are both shifting north and away from Sicily toward the mainland, while the Dodecanese and Cyclades results show more affinity to Sicily.

I have a number of Chios, a few Cyclades, and some Crete results showing this tendency, but all of the Dodecanese are Sicilian-like.

2 Cyclades
4 Dodecanese
Sikeliot
11-19-2017, 10:36 PM
2 Cyclades
4 Dodecanese

Flip these two around.

What is interesting is that we see some Cretans being closer to mainland and less so to Sicily, even though there are definitely Sicilian-Like Cretans, as we can see in any professional study, the two populations are considered close.

The other possibility is that there are Sicilians similar to #6 above (Cretan) but since I post mostly people from Palermo, I am not seeing them.
kleenex
11-19-2017, 10:49 PM
Could you reveal the results?
Tauromachos
11-19-2017, 10:52 PM
Could you reveal the results?

6 must be a Mainlander
Everything seem correct there as it has to be for Mainland tribesman.
Macedonian Greek seems close enough for Mainland tribesman and Albanian Tirano also pops up
though not realy close :)

5 is probably Macedonian than.
kleenex
11-19-2017, 10:55 PM
Flip these two around.

What is interesting is that we see some Cretans being closer to mainland and less so to Sicily, even though there are definitely Sicilian-Like Cretans, as we can see in any professional study, the two populations are considered close.

The other possibility is that there are Sicilians similar to #6 above (Cretan) but since I post mostly people from Palermo, I am not seeing them.

I can understand why/how Cretans are close to mainland Greece (based on history and phenotypes) but I"m surprised about the Cyclades result. What confuses me about this calculator is why I have Siracusa as my number one population and NW Greece (quite close) as two. The Peloponnesian sample you've presented doesn't even have Siracusa in the top 10. Seems that it's a bit out of balance. Any explanations?
Tauromachos
11-19-2017, 11:01 PM
I can understand why/how Cretans are close to mainland Greece (based on history and phenotypes) but I"m surprised about the Cyclades result. What confuses me about this calculator is why I have Siracusa as my number one population and NW Greece (quite close) as two. The Peloponnesian sample you've presented doesn't even have Siracusa in the top 10. Seems that it's a bit out of balance. Any explanations?

In general this is what i tried to explain often.

All these samples represent individuals from these particular regions.

They are not necessarily representative for the region as a whole.
I seriously doubt that every Cyclades Islander gets the result shown here but of course its possible without a problem in the
individual case.
kleenex
11-19-2017, 11:10 PM
In general this is what i tried to explain often.

All these samples represent individuals from these particular regions.

They are not necessarily representative for the region as a whole.
I seriously doubt that every Cyclades Islander gets the result shown here but of course its possible without a problem in the
individual case.

I agree but I do think that some of these calculators are pretty flawed. I guess it attests to the randomness of this sort of thing when it comes to particular samples.
Tauromachos
11-19-2017, 11:13 PM
I agree but I do think that some of these calculators are pretty flawed. I guess it attests to the randomness of this sort of thing when it comes to particular samples.

This on top of that.

Leave alone that such a genetic science to go calculator can never substitute the analysis and
work done by a human scientist.
Sikeliot
11-20-2017, 01:00 PM
6 must be a Mainlander
Everything seem correct there as it has to be for Mainland tribesman.
Macedonian Greek seems close enough for Mainland tribesman and Albanian Tirano also pops up
though not realy close :)

5 is probably Macedonian than.

6 is Cretan.
Tauromachos
11-20-2017, 10:10 PM
1 Peloponese
2 Cyclades
3 Chios
4 Dodecanese
5 Macedonia
6 Cretan