PDA

View Full Version : K13 modern for Magyars



Jana
08-11-2020, 02:48 PM
Reflecting demographic history of Kingdom of Hungary.


Vlach:Romanian,24.37,24.49,17.09,11.28,18.04,2.14, 0.55,0.27,0.83,0.60,0.18,0.09,0.06
German:South_Dutch,44.59,22.22,15.74,6.01,7.37,1.4 7,1.05,0.20,0.84,0.24,0.02,0.09,0.16
German:West_German,43.14,22.44,14.78,6.85,8.54,0.8 6,0.94,0.13,0.40,0.60,0.64,0.47,0.22
Armenian,2.79,0.85,13.02,38.87,34.79,5.23,3.41,0.4 3,0.03,0.05,0.44,0.04,0.05
South_Slav:Croat,28.03,32.78,14.98,7.92,12.34,1.46 ,0.46,0.31,0.55,0.55,0.41,0.10,0.11
Gypsy,9.73,9.53,12.55,16.84,18.44,2.86,26.43,1.28, 0.92,0.27,0.61,0.45,0.09
South_Slav:Serb,24.91,29.30,17.19,9.07,15.58,1.62, 0.52,0.29,0 .67,0.47,0.31,0.09,0.05
South_Slav:Slovenian,29.8778571429,33.85,15.34,7.0 314285714,9.9878571429,1.3564285714,0.7821428571,0 .265,0.4478571429,0.5314285714,0.2942857143,0.1414 285714,0.1157142857
West_Slav:Czech,33.53,37.14,12.43,5.94,7,0.9,1.18, 0.14,0.66,0.59,0.26,0.19,0.13
West_Slav:Slovak,30.84,37.1846153846,12.9876923077 ,6.2976923077,8.0007692308,1.0869230769,1.02769230 77,0.3915384615,0.5769230769,0.7338461538,0.530769 2308,0.1461538462,0.2138461538
East_Slav:Ukrainian_Ivano_Frankivsk,26.18,38.44,13 .89,5.43,11.20,1.12,1.13,0.20,1.35,0.50,0.20,0.16, 0.21
West_Slav:South_Polish,30.66,42.03,11.08,6.56,6.22 ,0.35,1.02,0.45,0.97,0.07,0.25,0.12,0.22
Jew:Ashkenazi,15.32,10.16,18.44,10.29,34.61,5.98,1 .04,0.79,0.97,0.46,0.29,1.15,0.50
Turkic:Crimean_Tatar,13.17,20.04,7.55,16.36,8.88,1 .83,3.23,10.25,16.40,1.28,0.47,0.27,0.21
Uralic:Mari,13.18,42.21,1.21,6.31,0.63,0.45,4.35,0 .87,26.26,3.33,0.38,0.15,0.67

Jana
08-11-2020, 02:49 PM
Some Hungarians I ran:

Target: Stears
Distance: 0.8270% / 0.82699096

48.6 West_Slav
17.6 German
14.0 South_Slav
12.2 Armenian
5.0 Uralic
2.6 Gypsy

Target: Chris
Distance: 2.1330% / 2.13296832

59.8 South_Slav
21.0 West_Slav
11.6 Vlach
4.0 Armenian
2.8 Turkic
0.8 Jew

Target: Dunai
Distance: 0.8491% / 0.84906248

47.6 German
33.4 West_Slav
5.6 East_Slav
5.4 Turkic
4.4 Jew
3.4 Uralic
0.2 South_Slav

Target: Egyvalaki
Distance: 2.0566% / 2.05655807

79.0 German
10.6 Jew
9.0 West_Slav
0.8 Gypsy
0.6 East_Slav

Target: Blanka
Distance: 4.5982% / 4.59818854

69.0 East_Slav
30.8 German
0.2 Jew

Target: Lehel
Distance: 3.1387% / 3.13871518

64.4 East_Slav
21.4 German
14.2 Jew

Target: Videx
Distance: 2.7763% / 2.77625326

52.0 West_Slav
39.4 German
6.2 Armenian
2.4 Uralic

Dušan
08-11-2020, 03:04 PM
Distance to: Dušan
6.32022943 South_Slav:Serb
6.98896273 South_Slav:Croat
8.32065502 East_Slav:Ukrainian_Ivano_Frankivsk
8.86136875 South_Slav:Slovenian
11.57316292 Vlach:Romanian
11.95779615 West_Slav:Slovak
14.63066984 West_Slav:Czech
15.49040348 West_Slav:South_Polish
24.45166048 German:West_German
25.93026803 German:South_Dutch
28.36670231 Turkic:Crimean_Tatar
33.45134377 Jew:Ashkenazi
35.10591403 Uralic:Mari
39.47075373 Gypsy
54.36895989 Armenian

Target: Dušan
Distance: 4.3329% / 4.33291469
64.4 South_Slav
31.2 East_Slav
4.2 Uralic
0.2 Armenian

Target: Dušan
Distance: 4.3329% / 4.33291469
64.4 Serb
31.2 Ukrainian_Ivano_Frankivsk
4.2 Mari
0.2 Armenian

Blondie
08-11-2020, 03:04 PM
Well now you debunked Turul's turkic propaganda.

Kökény
08-11-2020, 03:09 PM
Target: Kökény
Distance: 0.9558% / 0.95577984

40.4 German
28.6 South_Slav
12.4 Turkic
11.8 Jew
6.0 West_Slav
0.8 Armenian

gixajo
08-11-2020, 03:20 PM
Here you have the Hungarians or with some hungarian ancestry I found, (I have not been very exhaustive in the search could have more):

Videx(hungarian),34.53,32.27,11.16,10.11,9.26,0.56 ,0.,0,1.91,0,0.21,0,0
Lehel(hungarian),28.67,30.91,14.58,4.43,13.97,2.65 ,0,0,0.88,2.47,0.52,0,0
IrisSelene(romanian/hungarian),21.24,31.64,14.66,14.77,14.81,0,0,0,2.1 3,0.75,0,0,0
MrG_dad(hungarian),32.43,27.66,13.86,7.22,9.96,3.1 3,2.23,0,2.01,1.37,0.78,0,0
Blanka(hungarian),32.94,34.10,13.80,2.40,11.77,3.2 2,0,0,0.63,0.75,0,0,0.39
Dunai(hungarian),34.33,29.96,12.79,7.17,8.96,1.04, 0.78,1.15,2.62,0.4,0.79,0,0
Maestro(Hungarian+Albanian), 23.11,26.42,19.76,10.88,16.36,0.86,0,0,1.38,0.93,0 .30,0,0
Kökény(Hungarian),29.96,23.72,14.70,9.34,13.97,1.3 9,1.17,1.69,2.65,0.34,1.07,0,0
someonenotyou(hungarian),30.76,27.21,18.15,10.13,9 .41,0.21,2.25,0,1.79,0,0,0,0.09
imre_mother(hungarian),30.83,29.80,15.23,5.20,12.9 2,0,1.50,1.00,3.25,0.06,0,0.21,0
Stears(hungarian),28.18,31.44,12.48,11.01,10.49,0. 86,2.15,0.23,2.03,0.67,0.00,0.46,0.00
Chris(hungarian),24.99,30.21,15.43,10.48,15.40,0.3 0,0.00,1.62,1.24,0.00,0.00,0.00,0.34
Oszkar(Hungarian-Brit),38.05,31.06,12.90,5.27,7.79,3.22,0.00,0.00,1 .38,0.09,0.25,0.00,0.00
Benyzero(hungarian),31.92,32.14,16.99,4.66,11.60,0 ,0.55,0,1.15,0.28,0,0,0.72
magicalM(hungarian),35.94,29.65,14.54,10.62,5.40,0 ,1.95,0.99,0,0,0,0.55,0.34

And here from Balkans and around Hungary:


Daos777(hohol-from-moldova),24.52,41.27,11.39,8.59,7.3,1.12,1.34,0.42 ,1.51,1.82,0.72,0,0
nuti(slovak),29.55,39.54,12.70,7.42,4.76,2.89,0.84 ,0.19,1.34,0.33,0.06,0.37,0
Ford(serb),26.15,32.13,16.95,7.71,14.16,0.64,0.00, 0.00,2.07,0.01,0.17,0.00,0.00
Andre(romanian),24.25,27.07,15.53,7.60,18.35,3.24, 0.94,0.51, 1.64,0.32,0.16,0,0.39
Daco-Celtic(Romanian+Irish),40.75,19.59,15.69,9.31,12.1 8,0,0.86,0,0.46,1.06,0.11,0,0
Vlatko_vukovic(bosniak),24.45,35.38,15.36,8.24,11. 97,2.10,0,0,1.61,0.89,0,0,0
Commonsense(serb),24.67,28.68,17.62,11.85,13.95,0, 1.51,0,0.29,0.57,0.87,0,0
Thrax(greek),20.07,15.01,18.33,15.1,28.37,1.82,0,0 .41,0.04,0.15,0.7,0,0
HellLander87(greek),21.45,17.91,20.21,8.61,27.09,2 .54,1.47,0.72,0,0,0,0,0
vbn(serb),22.35,32.03,20.01,6.62,14.66,1.41,0,0,1. 50,0,1.41,0,0
Pagane(bulgarian),23.55,23,13.20,15.61,18.26,4.30, 1,0,0,0,0,0,0
Feiichy(croat),29.78,32.35,15.85,11.11,9.43,0.00,0 .00,0.5 2,0.96,0.00,0.00,0.00,0.00
Feiichy_Father(croat),28.42,31.99,15.48,8.37,12.10 ,0.00,0 .00,1.59,0.53,1.00,0.00,0.37,0.16
Feiichy_Mother(croat),28.72,31.08,15.50,9.98,9.71, 2.93,1. 15,0,0.40,0.35,0,0.15,0
paradox(greek+aromanian),16.28,20.79,17.00,13.71,2 6.01,3.35,1.09,0, 0.63,0.60,0.54,0,0
Hrvoje(croat+slovene),30.76,31.67,13.45,11.3,9.21, 1.37,0.1 4,0.00, 0.00,1.37,0.44,0.00,0.25
paradox_dad(aromanian),25.95,23.56,16.11,9.72,19.3 5,3.09,0,0, 1.20,0.27,0.53,0.21,0
Kaspias(balkanturk),15.55,20.37,12.29,14.91,21.00, 3.25,2.06,1.16,7.57,0.70,0.53,0,0.61
Bosniensis,25.11,28.79,16.52,8.96,15.27,1.41,1.97, 0.99,0.00,0.00,0.33,0.65,0.00
Decius(Serb),23.13,30.06,19.05,12.53,10.34,3.42,0. 00,0.19,0.74,0.18,0.37,0.00,0.00
Knez01(croat),18.98,34.13,19.52,9,13.9,2.53,0,0,0, 1.39,0.54,0,0
Kelmendasi(albanian),18.38,20.62,24.43,8.43,24.38, 3.54,0,0.09,0,0,0.15,0,0
Illyrian_warrior(albanian),23.41,16.49,20.85,11.75 ,24.49,1.7,0,0.01,0.59,0.71,0,0,0
Kostej(slovak),26.77,38.93,11.32,6.58,9.12,3.94,0. 4,0,1.05,1.08,0.53,0,0.28
Vale(Macedonian),20.54,22.38,18.40,10.38,21.89,4.3 4,0.00,0.00,0.17,1.16,0.74,0.00,0.00
Bained(bulgarian),25.67,21.25,18.04,8.82,22.31,2.3 0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0
Morlak(serb),23.82,28.32,18.12,10.65,15.14,0.89,0. 45,1.79,0,0,0.06,0.18,0.58
Ogi(montenegrin),22.56,25.93,19.3,9.35,19.29,2.44, 0,0.19,0.38,0.41,0,0,0
Deniz_mother(balkan_turk),20.45,22.68,13.98,14.7,1 6.89,3.43,0.77,2.68,2.91,0.51,0,1,0
Deniz_father(balkan_turk),14.22,25.08,14.69,16.55, 20.91,1.36,0,0,5.15,0,0.83,0,1.2
Deniz_grandpa(balkan_turk),21.22,22.84,14.09,12.95 ,19.33,1.04,2.25,2.56,2.24,0.25,0.13,0,1.09
Dibran(albanian),17.72,16.7,27.14,11.55,26.18,0.71 ,0,0,0,0,0,0,0
Drawing_slim(albanian),24.43,15.82,20.82,13.49,21. 08,4.13,0,0,0,0,0.23,0,0
Pjeter_Pan(albanian),25.27,16,21.70,11.02,22.46,2. 40,0.86,0,0,0,0.28,0,0
Nilotik(albanian),21.76,19.4,22.31,12.35,20.66,1.3 9,0,0.04,1.7,0.11,0.26,0,0
Pan(greek),19.50,19.80,17.71,13.98,26.13,1.27,0,0, 0,0,1.31,0,0
Geni(albanian),23.31,13.52,21.33,11.99,26.22,2.62, 0,0.19,0,0.74,0.44,0,0
Ljubic(croat),25.15,31.44,16.47,7.21,16.77,1.75,0, 0,0.68,0.29,0,0.02,0.22
Bessarion(croat),32.03,29.73,12.69,9.03,12.57,0,0, 0,0,1.27,0,0,0
Aye's_father(serb),24.12,31.47,17.07,9.07,15.22,0. 64,0.66,0.27,0,1.16,0.05,0,0.27
Ikol(serb),27.26,28.39,19.07,7.34,13.43,1.92,0,0.6 8,0,1.05,0.49,0.37,0
Fellow(Romanian),28.06,24.76,17.53,6.52,18.76,0,0. 10,0,1.37, 1.36,0.22,0,1.32
Max_soldo(croat),25.91,37.56,13.55,6.66,11.86,2.05 ,0.47,0.64,0.56,0.73,0.00,0.00,0.01
Westcoast(croat),23.75,35.70,15.49,7.60,12.23,2.32 ,0.00,0.81,0.92,0.5,0.26,0.00,0.43
Pagane_brother(bulgarian),20.20,21.76,15.76,17.16, 18.52,4.31,1.43,0,0,0,0,0,0
Pagane_mother(bulgarian),20.77,19.78,15.16,17.40,2 2.58,2.59,0,0,0,0,0,0,0
Kayra(balkan_turk/bosniak),25.96,18.75,13.86,12.63,15.78,2.88,1.32,3 .22,5.37,0,0.23,0,0
Karol_friend(Czech),33.63,39.21,9.34,5.61,8.97,1.1 3,0,0,0,1.39,0.17,0.50,0
Incelslayer(romanian),26.6,35.89,17.78,7.14,10.15, 0,0,1.1,1.26,0,0,0,0.08
IceT(albanian),25.02,17.76,21.65,9.75,21.72,2.22,0 .86,0.20,0.40,0.05,0.37,0,0
Nurzat(romanian/rusyn),25.10,30.93,16.34,10.95,11.35,0.08,1.20,1.0 1,1.30,0.74,0.64,0,0.36
Vojnik(macedonian),24.01,22.65,17.24,11.73,19.19,4 .35,0.01,0,0,0.72,0,0.05,0.06
Ph2ter_wife(croat),32.29,33.74,12.26,9.91,7.07,0.4 6 ,1.82,1.1,0,1.16,0,0,0.19
ph2ter_father(croat),31.82,33.99,12.8,6.12,9.84,1. 78,1.06,1.15,0.1,1.05,0.3,0,0
ph2ter_son(croat),31.96,33.97,12.11,8.87,7.22,2.1, 0.79,1.4,0,1.06,0,0,0.51
Moje_ime(serb),29.36,27.81,14.61,9.55,16.07,1.14,0 ,0,0,0.45,0.52,0.50,0
*****(macedonian),21.33,21.02,18.48,10.97,22.04,4. 72,0,0,0,1.06,0.25,0.12,0
Zmey(moldovan),22.18,33.94,14.38,9.99,13.86,3.05,0 ,1.21,0,0.91,0.49,0,0
Emziepiex3(serb),28.94,26.74,15.96,10.01,16.78,0.2 7,0,0,0.22,0.48,0.44,0,0.16
Kleenex(greek),21.82,14.78,19.44,13.26,26.7,3.35,0 ,0,0,0.64,0,0,0
Freeroostah(greek),18.30,19.67,20.55,13.26,22.68,4 .74,0,0,0.09,0,0,0.39,0.33
Kouros(greek),17.7,17.26,22.2,17.92,20.45,3.54,0,0 .61,0,0.26,0,0,0.05
Thracian(balkan_turk),19.94,16.83,13.89,16.36,21.6 8,3.87,3.67,0,3.02,0.39,0.34,0,0
Tschaikisten(serb),26.47,32.16,15.65,10.31,11.56,2 .11,0.39,0,0.26,0.71,0,0.1,0.27
Dick(serb),27.06,32.10,11.57,6.98,18.62,2.91,0,0.6 0,0.08,0,0.08,0,0
Carpatz(romanian),22.59,28.44,19.80,7.19,15.77,3.3 4,0.34,1.38,1.16,0,0,0,0
Ion Basescul_23andme+LivingDNA,25.42,29.37,15.04,9.99, 12.91,1.53,0.69,1.84,2.84,0,0.37,0,0
Ion Basescul_brother_MyHeritage,22.66,31.41,14.52,12.9 9,11.97,1.64,1.35,0.93,2.18,0,0.22,0.13,0
Ion Basescul_dad_MyHeritage,25.29,31.05,13.37,12.25,11 .53,0.22,1.90,0,2.14,0.95,0.07,0.92,0.30
Ion Basescul_mom_MyHeritage,21.57,34.87,15.27,11.01,11 .72,1.02,0.74,2.03,1.44,0.21,0.13,0,0
Xripkan(greek),17.76,16.46,19.83,13.60,27.25,2.46, 1.07,0,0.57,0,1,0,0
Deniz(balkan_turk),17.96,24,13.09,15.85,20.15,2.49 ,0.51,0,4.66,0,0,1.29,0
Karakartal(balkan_turk),15.53,15.92,15.36,17.97,23 .45,4.04,1.20,0.82,4.08,0.44,1.20,0,0
Impaler(romanian),23.34,17.78,13.31,12.51,21.55,1. 59,5.91,1,1.72,0,0,0,1.29
Egyvalaki(Hungarian),39.39,22.67,14.29,6.00,12.15, 1.06,1.95,0.09,0,0.86,1.03,0.54,0
Coolguy1(greek),17.66,17.79,18.12,14.32,27.04,3.22 ,0.53,0.37,0.41,0.53,0,0,0
Karol_father(slovak),31.35,38.97,11.14,4.70,9.29,1 .40,0.91,0,0.30,0.78,0.77,0.13,0.26
DRUM(albanian),20.43,16.13,22.36,11.89,24.22,3.81, 0,0,0,1.10,0.06,0,0
Ylla(albanian),20.55,16.35,23.29,10.15,27.5,1.21,0 ,0.18,0.16,0,0.23,0,0
Mortimer(romani/serb),17.28,16.28,16.32,15.39,15.58,2.72,13.21,2.0 8,0,0,1.15,0,0

Turul Karom
08-11-2020, 03:24 PM
Well now you debunked Turul's turkic propaganda.

https://i.imgur.com/GOm2SnR.jpg

Also, even more new data:

https://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?329085-New-Xiongnu-data-indicates-the-Turkic-origin-and-relativity-with-Hungarians

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00439-020-02209-4?fbclid=IwAR2aJ0SKI7WnF1U0ehOAqEqms4MjAPdy93rFcbP 6inmrZSP6bhfk6LNSbnA

https://i.imgur.com/2tRA4WF.jpg

gixajo
08-11-2020, 03:24 PM
I save all of them and you some work:

https://i.imgur.com/uEbh0OS.png

Turul Karom
08-11-2020, 03:30 PM
I save all of them and you some work:

Are these all G25 coordinates? Where does one get the K13 modern inputs?

gixajo
08-11-2020, 03:42 PM
Are these all G25 coordinates? Where does one get the K13 modern inputs?

They are K13 coordinates used in Vahaduo, not G25 coordinates.

You can get your K13 coordinates trhough your results in Gedmatch for Eurogenes K13, copying every coordinate of the first results table after your name, and separating every coordinate with a comma (,), and using points(.) to separate decimal and non decimal parts of every coordinate percentage (usual english decimal notation).

Kyp
08-11-2020, 03:44 PM
Target: MotherKyp(SouthGerman)
Distance: 2.6423% / 2.64230292
77.6 German
22.4 West_Slav


I like those k13 calcs

Dunai
08-11-2020, 03:53 PM
Some Hungarians are getting very large distances to my surprise. I would also suggest adding some other populations that had some type of impact on Modern Hungarians: Ossetians for covering the Jász, Greeks, Italians, Austrians or South Germans to the German group, Walloons or East French to French group and maybe even a population for Cumans, even though from the only genetic study I found about them says that they were closest to modern Finnish, Komi and Turkic people, which is pretty ambiguous.

17571imre
08-11-2020, 04:17 PM
My mother 34 German and more then 10% jewish the balance on this model is really off for my mother. Ill post my results when im home or maybe someone can also run my coordinates.

Luke35
08-11-2020, 04:39 PM
My mother 34 German and more then 10% jewish the balance on this model is really off for my mother. Ill post my results when im home or maybe someone can also run my coordinates.


I don't have yours Imre, I'll keep looking, but here is your mom at 0.25x..

0.25x might be more reasonable with this model. Here I use my dad's GEDmatch theoretical kit, which is not nearly as good as his G25 theoretical kit. On G25 he is a bit less German and a bit more West Slavic.

Target: imre_mother(hungarian)
Distance: 3.4312% / 3.43120287 | ADC: 0.25x
30.2 South_Slav
26.8 German
21.0 East_Slav
17.6 South_Slav
3.2 Uralic
1.2 Jew

Target: MrG_dad(hungarian)
Distance: 2.4411% / 2.44110774 | ADC: 0.25x
37.4 German
32.0 South_Slav
22.0 South_Slav
3.8 Gypsy
2.8 Uralic
2.0 Turkic

-------------------------------

Hungarian average:

Target: Hungarian
Distance: 1.5031% / 1.50305561 | ADC: 0.25x
49.4 South_Slav
31.0 West_Slav
18.2 German
1.4 Turkic

Turul Karom
08-11-2020, 04:45 PM
Target: TurulKarom
Distance: 4.4237% / 4.42372747 | ADC: 0.5x
84.6 German
7.4 South_Slav
5.6 Turkic
2.4 West_Slav


Target: TurulKarom
Distance: 1.4704% / 1.47036078 | ADC: 0.25x
71.8 German_West
10.6 Turk_Stara-Zagora
9.0 Austrian
5.0 Lezgin
3.4 Pomak_Central-Macedonia
0.2 Nogay

Turul Karom
08-11-2020, 04:47 PM
Double post. Enjoy a video!


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hiAxM1nN07s

Scandal
08-11-2020, 04:52 PM
https://media.tenor.com/images/806e5bc924885b00c0a00682bf874a22/tenor.gif

Scandal
08-11-2020, 04:55 PM
Target: Universe
Distance: 4.6819% / 4.68186395
68.2 East_Slav
23.8 West_Slav
5.0 West_Slav
3.0 Jew

Jana
08-11-2020, 05:47 PM
Try these too (smaller update)


Vlach:Romania_Maramures,23.92,30.36,17.05,8.43,15. 11,1.77,1.22,0.78,0.69,0.01,0.52,0.13,0.00
Vlach:Romania_Crisana,26.04,27.78,16.80,7.48,16.43 ,1.66,0.61,1.03,1.02,0.47,0.46,0.07,0.14
Vlach:Romania_Banat,21.33,26.23,17.90,10.94,18.38, 2.13,0.66,0.51,1.02,0.52,0.14,0.10,0.14
Vlach:Romania_Moldavia_average,23.92,27.62,16.56,9 .91,16.68,1.51,0.58,0.43,1.36,0.63,0.46,0.16,0.16
Vlach:Romania_Transylvania,23.89,26.03,17.75,9.96, 17.32,1.57,0.63,0.65,1.03,0.56,0.44,0.06,0.12
German:West_German,43.14,22.44,14.78,6.85,8.54,0.8 6,0.94,0.13,0.40,0.60,0.64,0.47,0.22
German:Swiss_German,40.15,22.01,17.27,6.58,10.31,1 .90,0.08,0.28,0.25,0.52,0.29,0.29,0.09
German:Austrian,37.21,29.87,14.58,7.23,8.23,1.56,0 .78,0.07,0.16,0.12,0.11,0.07,0.00
German:South_Dutch,44.59,22.22,15.74,6.01,7.37,1.4 7,1.05,0.20,0.84,0.24,0.02,0.09,0.16
German:West_German,43.14,22.44,14.78,6.85,8.54,0.8 6,0.94,0.13,0.40,0.60,0.64,0.47,0.22
Armenian,2.79,0.85,13.02,38.87,34.79,5.23,3.41,0.4 3,0.03,0.05,0.44,0.04,0.05
South_Slav:Croat,28.03,32.78,14.98,7.92,12.34,1.46 ,0.46,0.31,0.55,0.55,0.41,0.10,0.11
Gypsy,9.73,9.53,12.55,16.84,18.44,2.86,26.43,1.28, 0.92,0.27,0.61,0.45,0.09
South_Slav:Serb,24.91,29.30,17.19,9.07,15.58,1.62, 0.52,0.29,0 .67,0.47,0.31,0.09,0.05
South_Slav:Slovenian,29.8778571429,33.85,15.34,7.0 314285714,9.9878571429,1.3564285714,0.7821428571,0 .265,0.4478571429,0.5314285714,0.2942857143,0.1414 285714,0.1157142857
West_Slav:Czech,33.53,37.14,12.43,5.94,7,0.9,1.18, 0.14,0.66,0.59,0.26,0.19,0.13
West_Slav:Slovak,30.84,37.1846153846,12.9876923077 ,6.2976923077,8.0007692308,1.0869230769,1.02769230 77,0.3915384615,0.5769230769,0.7338461538,0.530769 2308,0.1461538462,0.2138461538
East_Slav:Ukrainian_Ivano_Frankivsk,26.18,38.44,13 .89,5.43,11.20,1.12,1.13,0.20,1.35,0.50,0.20,0.16, 0.21
West_Slav:South_Polish,30.66,42.03,11.08,6.56,6.22 ,0.35,1.02,0.45,0.97,0.07,0.25,0.12,0.22
Jew:Ashkenazi,15.32,10.16,18.44,10.29,34.61,5.98,1 .04,0.79,0.97,0.46,0.29,1.15,0.50
Turkic:Crimean_Tatar,13.17,20.04,7.55,16.36,8.88,1 .83,3.23,10.25,16.40,1.28,0.47,0.27,0.21
Uralic:Mari,13.18,42.21,1.21,6.31,0.63,0.45,4.35,0 .87,26.26,3.33,0.38,0.15,0.67
Jász:North_Ossetian,6.39,11.93,7.27,48.78,14.62,1. 38,1.74,2.27,4.59,0.62,0.30,0.06,0.05
Jász:Ossetian,7.84,7.30,9.08,48.98,14.05,1.99,2.74 ,2.92,4.19,0.56,0.21,0.13,0.01
Italian:Lombardy,32.35,12.62,26.19,5.59,20.25,2.1, 0.32,0.13,0.06,0.02,0.16,0.1,0.11
Greek:GR_Peloponese,18.50375,15.75625,19.3175,12.9 6125,26.99875,3.585,1.23375,0.375,0.34375,0.205,0. 50875,0.2075,0.00125
French:French,42.60,17.48,19.50,4.96,10.33,2.82,1. 08,0.15,0.27,0.38,0.23,0.07,0.12
French:Swiss_French,37.79,20.53,19.52,7.90,10.97,1 .49,0.27,0.26,0.44,0.44,0.36,0.04,0.00
Magyar_conqueror:Tatar,18.88,34.62,5.85,11.66,3.85 ,0.90,2.68,3.12,15.56,2.00,0.28,0.13,0.46
Magyar_conqueror:Chuvash,14.88,43.07,2.02,8.74,1.2 9,0.85,2.28,2.66,20.08,2.77,0.44,0.55,0.36

Scandal
08-11-2020, 05:49 PM
Target: Universe
Distance: 4.6815% / 4.68152292
35.0 East_Slav
34.0 East_Slav
12.2 West_Slav
10.6 West_Slav
3.0 West_Slav
2.4 West_Slav
1.8 Jew
1.0 Jew

:shrug:

Jana
08-11-2020, 05:50 PM
Btw there are no Bashkirs in K13, and conquerors were closest to them and Volga Tatars. Therefore I picked Chuvash too because they are closest thing to Bashkirs. All those groups are Uralic-Turkic mix.

Jana
08-11-2020, 05:53 PM
Target: Universe
Distance: 4.6815% / 4.68152292
35.0 East_Slav
34.0 East_Slav
12.2 West_Slav
10.6 West_Slav
3.0 West_Slav
2.4 West_Slav
1.8 Jew
1.0 Jew

:shrug:

Why aren't those merged for you? I mean west slav etc (you get double)

Jana
08-11-2020, 05:55 PM
Target: Stears
Distance: 0.6464% / 0.64635387

42.0 West_Slav
17.0 German
15.8 East_Slav
6.8 Vlach
6.4 Jász
4.0 Armenian
3.4 Uralic
3.0 Gypsy
1.0 Greek
0.6 South_Slav

Distance to: Stears

5.17453380 South_Slav:Croat
6.14769519 South_Slav:Slovenian
8.51419403 South_Slav:Serb
8.52142528 West_Slav:Slovak
8.53262562 Vlach:Romania_Maramures
9.40228164 East_Slav:Ukrainian_Ivano_Frankivsk
9.45923358 Vlach:Romania_Crisana
9.62380382 Vlach:Romania_Moldavia_average
10.09907421 West_Slav:Czech
10.68493800 German:Austrian
11.29457835 Vlach:Romania_Transylvania
12.71178194 West_Slav:South_Polish
13.06991966 Vlach:Romania_Banat
16.66323798 French:Swiss_French
16.83710783 German:Swiss_German
18.32467462 German:West_German
18.32467462 German:West_German
19.46624514 Magyar_conqueror:Tatar
20.07499440 German:South_Dutch
22.29619923 French:French
25.96874756 Greek:GR_Peloponese
26.33527292 Italian:Lombardy
26.84133752 Turkic:Crimean_Tatar
29.11729898 Magyar_conqueror:Chuvash
34.46144222 Uralic:Mari

Scandal
08-11-2020, 05:56 PM
Why aren't those merged for you? I mean west slav etc (you get double)

Should they be merged? There are multiple "west_slav" source populations.

Jana
08-11-2020, 05:59 PM
Hrvoje results (he is genetically very similar to Hungarians)

Target: Hrvoje
Distance: 1.6026% / 1.60256826

40.6 West_Slav
38.2 German
11.4 South_Slav
9.8 Jász

Jana
08-11-2020, 05:59 PM
Should they be merged? There are multiple "west_slav" source populations.

They are but they have same name so in results you should get them all togheder.

Scandal
08-11-2020, 05:59 PM
Hrvoje results (he is genetically very similar to Hungarians)

Target: Hrvoje
Distance: 1.6026% / 1.60256826

40.6 West_Slav
38.2 German
11.4 South_Slav
9.8 Jász

Why does he have so much german admixture? Nor Croats neither Slovenes have mcuh on avarge.

Dušan
08-11-2020, 06:01 PM
Try these too (smaller update)


Vlach:Romania_Maramures,23.92,30.36,17.05,8.43,15. 11,1.77,1.22,0.78,0.69,0.01,0.52,0.13,0.00
Vlach:Romania_Crisana,26.04,27.78,16.80,7.48,16.43 ,1.66,0.61,1.03,1.02,0.47,0.46,0.07,0.14
Vlach:Romania_Banat,21.33,26.23,17.90,10.94,18.38, 2.13,0.66,0.51,1.02,0.52,0.14,0.10,0.14
Vlach:Romania_Moldavia_average,23.92,27.62,16.56,9 .91,16.68,1.51,0.58,0.43,1.36,0.63,0.46,0.16,0.16
Vlach:Romania_Transylvania,23.89,26.03,17.75,9.96, 17.32,1.57,0.63,0.65,1.03,0.56,0.44,0.06,0.12
German:West_German,43.14,22.44,14.78,6.85,8.54,0.8 6,0.94,0.13,0.40,0.60,0.64,0.47,0.22
German:Swiss_German,40.15,22.01,17.27,6.58,10.31,1 .90,0.08,0.28,0.25,0.52,0.29,0.29,0.09
German:Austrian,37.21,29.87,14.58,7.23,8.23,1.56,0 .78,0.07,0.16,0.12,0.11,0.07,0.00
German:South_Dutch,44.59,22.22,15.74,6.01,7.37,1.4 7,1.05,0.20,0.84,0.24,0.02,0.09,0.16
German:West_German,43.14,22.44,14.78,6.85,8.54,0.8 6,0.94,0.13,0.40,0.60,0.64,0.47,0.22
Armenian,2.79,0.85,13.02,38.87,34.79,5.23,3.41,0.4 3,0.03,0.05,0.44,0.04,0.05
South_Slav:Croat,28.03,32.78,14.98,7.92,12.34,1.46 ,0.46,0.31,0.55,0.55,0.41,0.10,0.11
Gypsy,9.73,9.53,12.55,16.84,18.44,2.86,26.43,1.28, 0.92,0.27,0.61,0.45,0.09
South_Slav:Serb,24.91,29.30,17.19,9.07,15.58,1.62, 0.52,0.29,0 .67,0.47,0.31,0.09,0.05
South_Slav:Slovenian,29.8778571429,33.85,15.34,7.0 314285714,9.9878571429,1.3564285714,0.7821428571,0 .265,0.4478571429,0.5314285714,0.2942857143,0.1414 285714,0.1157142857
West_Slav:Czech,33.53,37.14,12.43,5.94,7,0.9,1.18, 0.14,0.66,0.59,0.26,0.19,0.13
West_Slav:Slovak,30.84,37.1846153846,12.9876923077 ,6.2976923077,8.0007692308,1.0869230769,1.02769230 77,0.3915384615,0.5769230769,0.7338461538,0.530769 2308,0.1461538462,0.2138461538
East_Slav:Ukrainian_Ivano_Frankivsk,26.18,38.44,13 .89,5.43,11.20,1.12,1.13,0.20,1.35,0.50,0.20,0.16, 0.21
West_Slav:South_Polish,30.66,42.03,11.08,6.56,6.22 ,0.35,1.02,0.45,0.97,0.07,0.25,0.12,0.22
Jew:Ashkenazi,15.32,10.16,18.44,10.29,34.61,5.98,1 .04,0.79,0.97,0.46,0.29,1.15,0.50
Turkic:Crimean_Tatar,13.17,20.04,7.55,16.36,8.88,1 .83,3.23,10.25,16.40,1.28,0.47,0.27,0.21
Uralic:Mari,13.18,42.21,1.21,6.31,0.63,0.45,4.35,0 .87,26.26,3.33,0.38,0.15,0.67
Jász:North_Ossetian,6.39,11.93,7.27,48.78,14.62,1. 38,1.74,2.27,4.59,0.62,0.30,0.06,0.05
Jász:Ossetian,7.84,7.30,9.08,48.98,14.05,1.99,2.74 ,2.92,4.19,0.56,0.21,0.13,0.01
Italian:Lombardy,32.35,12.62,26.19,5.59,20.25,2.1, 0.32,0.13,0.06,0.02,0.16,0.1,0.11
Greek:GR_Peloponese,18.50375,15.75625,19.3175,12.9 6125,26.99875,3.585,1.23375,0.375,0.34375,0.205,0. 50875,0.2075,0.00125
French:French,42.60,17.48,19.50,4.96,10.33,2.82,1. 08,0.15,0.27,0.38,0.23,0.07,0.12
French:Swiss_French,37.79,20.53,19.52,7.90,10.97,1 .49,0.27,0.26,0.44,0.44,0.36,0.04,0.00
Magyar_conqueror:Tatar,18.88,34.62,5.85,11.66,3.85 ,0.90,2.68,3.12,15.56,2.00,0.28,0.13,0.46
Magyar_conqueror:Chuvash,14.88,43.07,2.02,8.74,1.2 9,0.85,2.28,2.66,20.08,2.77,0.44,0.55,0.36

Seems that I have more Uralo-Magyar precentage than most Hungarian users here.:cool:

Target: Dušan
Distance: 3.8271% / 3.82711665
74.4 Vlach
21.4 East_Slav
3.8 Magyar_conqueror
0.4 Uralic

Distance to: Dušan
4.99979000 Vlach:Romania_Maramures
6.32022943 South_Slav:Serb
6.98896273 South_Slav:Croat
8.04169136 Vlach:Romania_Moldavia_average
8.32065502 East_Slav:Ukrainian_Ivano_Frankivsk
8.34790393 Vlach:Romania_Crisana
8.86136875 South_Slav:Slovenian
9.46428550 Vlach:Romania_Transylvania
10.06253447 Vlach:Romania_Banat
11.95779615 West_Slav:Slovak
14.63066984 West_Slav:Czech
15.49040348 West_Slav:South_Polish
16.64068208 German:Austrian
20.52799308 French:Swiss_French
21.68561735 German:Swiss_German
21.77349076 Magyar_conqueror:Tatar
24.01018690 Greek:GR_Peloponese
24.45166048 German:West_German
24.45166048 German:West_German
25.93026803 German:South_Dutch

Jana
08-11-2020, 06:01 PM
Why does he have so much german admixture? Nor Croats neither Slovenes have mcuh on avarge.

His Slovenian half is highly Germanic, significantly more than average. He also has some German from his minor Czech ancestry I presume.
Also he belongs to proto Germanic haplogroup R1b U106.

Scandal
08-11-2020, 06:03 PM
They are but they have same name so in results you should get them all togheder.

I don't know why it happens, but it happens.

try it yourself please.

Universe,28.69,39.52,11.43,3.62,13.02,2.30,0,0,0.4 8,0,0.23,0.72,0

Turul Karom
08-11-2020, 06:20 PM
Target: TurulKarom
Distance: 2.8138% / 2.81379089 | ADC: 0.25x
91.0 German
6.2 Jász
2.8 Magyar_conqueror

Target: TurulKarom (2nd cycle)
Distance: 2.2568% / 2.25683342 | ADC: 0.25x
95.4 German
1.8 Turkic
1.4 Jász
1.4 Magyar_conqueror

Videx
08-11-2020, 06:21 PM
Distance to: Videx
6.22086811 German:Austrian
7.23325653 West_Slav:Czech
7.44282582 South_Slav:Slovenian
7.82317491 West_Slav:Slovak
8.64389380 South_Slav:Croat
11.58986195 West_Slav:South_Polish
11.96554219 East_Slav:Ukrainian_Ivano_Frankivsk
13.49101182 South_Slav:Serb
13.64252909 Vlach:Romania_Crisana
13.88353341 German:Swiss_German
13.89674782 Vlach:Romania_Maramures
14.11014529 German:West_German
14.11014529 German:West_German
14.85556798 Vlach:Romania_Moldavia_average
15.15047854 French:Swiss_French
15.71010821 German:South_Dutch
16.23452494 Vlach:Romania_Transylvania
18.55451697 Vlach:Romania_Banat
19.75454884 French:French
22.75741637 Magyar_conqueror:Tatar
27.63918776 Italian:Lombardy
30.53396756 Greek:GR_Peloponese
31.41580653 Turkic:Crimean_Tatar
31.65951990 Magyar_conqueror:Chuvash
36.96956451 Uralic:Mari

arget: Videx
Distance: 3.1675% / 3.16752372 | ADC: 0.25x
51.8 German
40.0 West_Slav
5.6 Jász
2.6 Magyar_conqueror

Target: Videx
Distance: 2.4876% / 2.48755364
50.6 West_Slav
40.4 German
5.4 Jász
1.8 Armenian
1.8 Magyar_conqueror

Jana
08-11-2020, 06:26 PM
I don't know why it happens, but it happens.

try it yourself please.

Universe,28.69,39.52,11.43,3.62,13.02,2.30,0,0,0.4 8,0,0.23,0.72,0

Target: Universe
Distance: 4.6815% / 4.68152292

69.0 East_Slav
28.2 West_Slav
2.8 Jew

Distance to: Universe

4.91745869 East_Slav:Ukrainian_Ivano_Frankivsk
6.96850527 West_Slav:Slovak
8.41940022 West_Slav:South_Polish
8.47866476 South_Slav:Slovenian
8.70425183 West_Slav:Czech
8.89762328 South_Slav:Croat
12.98465248 Vlach:Romania_Maramures
13.77135433 South_Slav:Serb
14.25008070 Vlach:Romania_Crisana
14.60569067 German:Austrian
15.69548661 Vlach:Romania_Moldavia_average
17.49601669 Vlach:Romania_Transylvania
18.88558445 Vlach:Romania_Banat
22.11125731 German:Swiss_German
23.08398146 French:Swiss_French
23.36395086 German:West_German
23.36395086 German:West_German
23.47250306 Magyar_conqueror:Tatar
24.71428534 German:South_Dutch
27.48619654 French:French
29.36130106 Magyar_conqueror:Chuvash
31.80808859 Italian:Lombardy
31.89149573 Greek:GR_Peloponese
34.43759138 Turkic:Crimean_Tatar
34.82223858 Uralic:Mari

Turul Karom
08-11-2020, 06:27 PM
Can posters post their closest to "zero" % result? Or is that what people are already doing? The lower the number, the more accurate the genetic predictions for population relations, yes?

I was able to get my numbers into the low 2% and 1.4%; adjusting the ADC seems to change in both directions.

Jana
08-11-2020, 06:32 PM
Can posters post their closest to "zero" % result? Or is that what people are already doing? The lower the number, the more accurate the genetic predictions for population relations, yes?

I was able to get my numbers into the low 2% and 1.4%; adjusting the ADC seems to change in both directions.

Lower the distance better the fit. Between 1-2 is ideal IMO, below 1 is already overfiting. ACD make sense if with 0 penalization you get super low fit/overfit, otherwise not really.
But this is just my opinion, I'm not an expert.

Jana
08-11-2020, 06:33 PM
Stears with 0.25X

Target: Stears
Distance: 1.5803% / 1.58027965 | ADC: 0.25x

54.8 South_Slav
15.8 West_Slav
13.8 German
7.8 Magyar_conqueror
5.8 Jász
2.0 Gypsy

Turul Karom
08-11-2020, 06:38 PM
Lower the distance better the fit. Between 1-2 is ideal IMO, below 1 is already overfiting. ACD make sense if with 0 penalization you get super low fit/overfit, otherwise not really.
But this is just my opinion, I'm not an expert.

Thoughts on my results and how to make them a better fit? Are these the only graves we have for these groups? I'd also like to get thoughts on the study link I posted on the first page, but that can be sent as a PM if you would like so as not to derail the thread.

Jana
08-11-2020, 06:44 PM
Thoughts on my results and how to make them a better fit? Are these the only graves we have for these groups? I'd also like to get thoughts on the study link I posted on the first page, but that can be sent as a PM if you would like so as not to derail the thread.

What do you get with no ACD adjustment? PS: distance below 1 is not overfit if there are not too many reference groups but just 4,5. Overfit is when you get close to 0 and 30 different pops.
Will check what you posted.

Luke35
08-11-2020, 06:45 PM
My dad's theoretical with code #2

Target: MrG_dad(hungarian)
Distance: 1.5992% / 1.59922339
45.8 West_Slav
34.6 French
8.8 Magyar_conqueror
4.6 Jew
3.8 Gypsy
2.4 Armenian

--------------------------------

Target: Hungarian
Distance: 0.7574% / 0.75744753
33.4 West_Slav
26.4 West_Slav
24.6 German
8.6 Jew
3.0 South_Slav
2.0 Armenian
2.0 Magyar_conqueror

Jana
08-11-2020, 06:46 PM
Well I don't dispute conquerors were mixed Turkic-Uralic in origin. But as you can see they left little to none trace in modern Magyars, some of you score little of it and some don't score it as all.

Benyzero
08-11-2020, 06:48 PM
I can't run it somehow

Jana
08-11-2020, 06:49 PM
I can't run it somehow

nevermind, found them

Turul Karom
08-11-2020, 06:52 PM
What do you get with no ACD adjustment? PS: distance below 1 is not overfit if there are not too many reference groups but just 4,5. Overfit is when you get close to 0 and 30 different pops.
Will check what you posted.

Target: TurulKarom
Distance: 1.8753% / 1.87525602
73.6 German
19.4 West_Slav
2.2 Jew
2.2 Magyar_conqueror
2.0 Jász
0.6 Armenian

Jana
08-11-2020, 06:52 PM
Target: Stearsolina
Distance: 2.2783% / 2.27833141

46.2 West_Slav
20.6 South_Slav
15.6 French
9.0 Italian
8.6 Jász

Distance to: Feiichy

4.75888632 South_Slav:Slovenian
5.06918139 South_Slav:Croat
7.82170429 West_Slav:Slovak
8.95312795 South_Slav:Serb
9.13118284 German:Austrian
9.17789191 Vlach:Romania_Maramures
9.17836042 West_Slav:Czech
9.61407822 East_Slav:Ukrainian_Ivano_Frankivsk
10.08961347 Vlach:Romania_Crisana
10.70809974 Vlach:Romania_Moldavia_average
12.05105390 Vlach:Romania_Transylvania
12.22842590 West_Slav:South_Polish
14.08852725 Vlach:Romania_Banat
15.26344981 French:Swiss_French
15.56884710 German:Swiss_German
17.31791269 German:West_German
17.31791269 German:West_German
18.85976140 German:South_Dutch
21.15118673 French:French
22.08214437 Magyar_conqueror:Tatar
25.60974033 Italian:Lombardy
27.23485038 Greek:GR_Peloponese
29.54670540 Turkic:Crimean_Tatar
31.37590317 Magyar_conqueror:Chuvash
36.85961747 Uralic:Mari

Jana
08-11-2020, 06:53 PM
Target: TurulKarom
Distance: 1.8753% / 1.87525602
73.6 German
19.4 West_Slav
2.2 Jew
2.2 Magyar_conqueror
2.0 Jász
0.6 Armenian

Very nice distance.

andre
08-11-2020, 06:54 PM
Target: Andre
Distance: 2.3785% / 2.37847478 | ADC: 0.25x
65.2 South_Slav
16.8 South_Slav
15.4 Jew
1.4 Uralic
1.2 East_Slav

Target: Andre
Distance: 0.7280% / 0.72800290
33.6 East_Slav
33.4 Jew
15.2 South_Slav
6.6 German
6.0 South_Slav
3.0 West_Slav
2.2 Uralic

Jana
08-11-2020, 06:54 PM
I can't run it somehow

Target: Benyzero
Distance: 2.2384% / 2.23836044

44.4 West_Slav
25.2 East_Slav
25.2 Italian
5.2 German

Distance to: Benyzero

4.58602525 South_Slav:Slovenian
5.82888497 South_Slav:Croat
7.80551508 West_Slav:Slovak
7.80636919 German:Austrian
8.55561804 West_Slav:Czech
9.22200629 East_Slav:Ukrainian_Ivano_Frankivsk
9.45131737 Vlach:Romania_Crisana
9.80118360 South_Slav:Serb
9.94914067 Vlach:Romania_Maramures
11.88139302 Vlach:Romania_Moldavia_average
12.91289278 Vlach:Romania_Transylvania
12.95497974 West_Slav:South_Polish
13.45810908 German:Swiss_German
13.78730576 French:Swiss_French
15.44541032 Vlach:Romania_Banat
15.53950450 German:West_German
15.53950450 German:West_German
16.82509733 German:South_Dutch
18.61287189 French:French
23.40269002 Italian:Lombardy
25.20326963 Magyar_conqueror:Tatar
27.83535611 Greek:GR_Peloponese
32.87985249 Turkic:Crimean_Tatar
33.65756379 Magyar_conqueror:Chuvash
36.87932076 Jew:Ashkenazi

Benyzero
08-11-2020, 06:57 PM
Target: Benyzero
Distance: 2.2384% / 2.23836044

44.4 West_Slav
25.2 East_Slav
25.2 Italian
5.2 German

Distance to: Benyzero

4.58602525 South_Slav:Slovenian
5.82888497 South_Slav:Croat
7.80551508 West_Slav:Slovak
7.80636919 German:Austrian
8.55561804 West_Slav:Czech
9.22200629 East_Slav:Ukrainian_Ivano_Frankivsk
9.45131737 Vlach:Romania_Crisana
9.80118360 South_Slav:Serb
9.94914067 Vlach:Romania_Maramures
11.88139302 Vlach:Romania_Moldavia_average
12.91289278 Vlach:Romania_Transylvania
12.95497974 West_Slav:South_Polish
13.45810908 German:Swiss_German
13.78730576 French:Swiss_French
15.44541032 Vlach:Romania_Banat
15.53950450 German:West_German
15.53950450 German:West_German
16.82509733 German:South_Dutch
18.61287189 French:French
23.40269002 Italian:Lombardy
27.83535611 Greek:GR_Peloponese
32.87985249 Turkic:Crimean_Tatar
36.87932076 Jew:Ashkenazi
38.47138807 Uralic:Mari
43.57839717 Gypsy

Buongiorno, Signora! Prego

Turul Karom
08-11-2020, 07:00 PM
Very nice distance.

What are your thoughts on the Jewish fits that some Hungarians have? I have no known Jewish ancestry, and it falls off when the ADC is raised to merely .25, but I have a theory.

My theory is that there is genetic overlap between the Turkic Khazar Khaganate tribes that joined the Hungarians (during move into Carpathian Basin), Khazar Jews (who converted), and modern Ashkenazis (who also potentially carry remnants of Khazar Turkic DNA).

This could be why Jewish falls off and Turkic appears more. That also doesn't interfere with the conqueror DNA.

Jana
08-11-2020, 07:05 PM
I forgot to add conqueror like averages when calculating for Stears, me, Hrvoje, Benji, Universe. For us nothing changed but for Stears it did, look how he scores impressive conqueror like admix:


Stears with 0.25X

Target: Stears
Distance: 1.5803% / 1.58027965 | ADC: 0.25x

54.8 South_Slav
15.8 West_Slav
13.8 German
7.8 Magyar_conqueror
5.8 Jász
2.0 Gypsy

Jana
08-11-2020, 07:09 PM
What are your thoughts on the Jewish fits that some Hungarians have? I have no known Jewish ancestry, and it falls off when the ADC is raised to merely .25, but I have a theory.

My theory is that there is genetic overlap between the Turkic Khazar Khaganate tribes that joined the Hungarians (during move into Carpathian Basin), Khazar Jews (who converted), and modern Ashkenazis (who also potentially carry remnants of Khazar Turkic DNA).

This could be why Jewish falls off and Turkic appears more. That also doesn't interfere with the conqueror DNA.

Ashkenazi Jews have little mongoloid admixture but genetically they are south Italian like population.
Lot of Jews lived in Hungary and lot little assimilated, but again calculator like this is just for fun.

someonenotyou
08-11-2020, 07:15 PM
First code
Target:
Distance: 405.4606% / 4.05460623
59.8 South_Slav
29.2 German
4.2 Gypsy
4.0 Turkic
2.8 Armenian

Second code

Target:
Distance: 288.3662% / 2.88366174
39.4 French
24.0 South_Slav
18.8 West_Slav
6.6 Italian
5.2 Jász
3.2 Gypsy
2.8 Uralic

The distances are huge.

Turul Karom
08-11-2020, 07:21 PM
Ashkenazi Jews have little mongoloid admixture but genetically they are south Italian like population.
Lot of Jews lived in Hungary and lot little assimilated, but again calculator like this is just for fun.

What I mean is the theory that Khazars played a role somehow in Jewish Europe is interesting. Netanyahu is R1a-Z93. I know some use it to bash Israel, but that is not the point I am making at all. I am looking at it from Khazar genetic input and ethnogenesis with Hungarians.

I know, and they are for fun and all, but these are real DNA kits with real results. The fun is seeing how a person compares themselves to the kits. I am hoping there will be more Hungarian conqueror kits to compare so there can be a list of all of them. I share DNA with the Hungarian grave KAROS III male.




The distances are huge.

There must have been an error. Why are your distances so large?

Luke35
08-11-2020, 07:32 PM
First code
Target:
Distance: 405.4606% / 4.05460623
59.8 South_Slav
29.2 German
4.2 Gypsy
4.0 Turkic
2.8 Armenian

Second code

Target:
Distance: 288.3662% / 2.88366174
39.4 French
24.0 South_Slav
18.8 West_Slav
6.6 Italian
5.2 Jász
3.2 Gypsy
2.8 Uralic

The distances are huge.

You used the regular vahaduo calc I believe. If you go to the K13 Vahaduo and wipe out the source, replace with new code.

Your results will still be the same, but with the normal distance instead.

Luke35
08-11-2020, 07:36 PM
Imre's mom (I believe he is not at his computer today).

Code # 2

Target: imre_mother(hungarian)
Distance: 2.2891% / 2.28912058
47.8 East_Slav
24.4 German
18.6 Italian
7.4 Uralic
1.8 Jew

Scandal
08-11-2020, 07:37 PM
whatever

Ion Basescul
08-11-2020, 07:55 PM
I get results in overfit territory even at 0.25X

Target: IonBasescul_23andme+LivingDNA
Distance: 0.6584% / 0.65841437
37.0 South_Slav
22.2 West_Slav
17.0 Vlach
11.8 Turkic
6.6 Italian
2.6 Jász
2.4 French
0.4 German

Target: IonBasescul_23andme+LivingDNA
Distance: 1.0045% / 1.00454850 | ADC: 0.25x
83.6 South_Slav
12.6 Turkic
3.8 German



Target: IonBasescul_23andme+LivingDNA
Distance: 1.7798% / 1.77982565 | ADC: 0.5x
90.8 South_Slav
8.8 Turkic
0.4 Vlach


<tbody>
Distance to:
IonBasescul_23andme+LivingDNA


4.49958887
South_Slav:Serb


4.54619621
Vlach:Romania_Maramures


5.14678540
Vlach:Romania_Moldavia_average


5.38013940
Vlach:Romania_Crisana


5.56979353
South_Slav:Croat


6.73227302
Vlach:Romania_Transylvania


8.11714757
South_Slav:Slovenian


8.44901178
Vlach:Romania_Banat


10.65376459
East_Slav:Ukrainian_Ivano_Frankivsk


11.85544780
West_Slav:Slovak


13.39391280
German:Austrian


13.89173495
West_Slav:Czech


16.33854951
West_Slav:South_Polish


16.37053145
French:Swiss_French


17.45059311
German:Swiss_German


20.02844727
German:West_German


20.02844727
German:West_German


20.29022178
Magyar_conqueror:Tatar


21.72066815
Greek:GR_Peloponese


21.74097514
German:South_Dutch


22.35696536
French:French


23.18030198
Italian:Lombardy


24.75758470
Turkic:Crimean_Tatar


30.23043665
Magyar_conqueror:Chuvash


31.30317875
Jew:Ashkenazi


</tbody>

someonenotyou
08-11-2020, 08:04 PM
You used the regular vahaduo calc I believe. If you go to the K13 Vahaduo and wipe out the source, replace with new code.

Your results will still be the same, but with the normal distance instead.

Target:
Distance: 2.8840% / 2.88404794
39.2 French
23.0 South_Slav
19.6 West_Slav
7.0 Italian
5.2 Jász
3.2 Gypsy
2.8 Uralic

Target:
Distance: 3.0032% / 3.00323192 | ADC: 0.25x
52.4 South_Slav
38.4 French
3.6 Jász
2.8 Magyar_conqueror
2.6 Gypsy
0.2 Vlach


Yup, that what it was

17571imre
08-11-2020, 08:11 PM
Target: mh
Distance: 0.7594% / 0.75935161
32.4 Vlach
23.0 German
17.6 West_Slav
17.4 Italian
5.0 Greek
3.6 East_Slav
1.0 Uralic

my results seem good but i score the same amount Germanic as my mother.

the results from Feiichy calculator with G25 made more sense for me because she scored almost no Germanic there and i 25%

Scandal
08-11-2020, 08:12 PM
I get results in overfit territory even at 0.25X

Target: IonBasescul_23andme+LivingDNA
Distance: 0.6584% / 0.65841437
37.0 South_Slav
22.2 West_Slav
17.0 Vlach
11.8 Turkic
6.6 Italian
2.6 Jász
2.4 French
0.4 German

Target: IonBasescul_23andme+LivingDNA
Distance: 1.0045% / 1.00454850 | ADC: 0.25x
83.6 South_Slav
12.6 Turkic
3.8 German



Target: IonBasescul_23andme+LivingDNA
Distance: 1.7798% / 1.77982565 | ADC: 0.5x
90.8 South_Slav
8.8 Turkic
0.4 Vlach


<tbody>
Distance to:
IonBasescul_23andme+LivingDNA


4.49958887
South_Slav:Serb


4.54619621
Vlach:Romania_Maramures


5.14678540
Vlach:Romania_Moldavia_average


5.38013940
Vlach:Romania_Crisana


5.56979353
South_Slav:Croat


6.73227302
Vlach:Romania_Transylvania


8.11714757
South_Slav:Slovenian


8.44901178
Vlach:Romania_Banat


10.65376459
East_Slav:Ukrainian_Ivano_Frankivsk


11.85544780
West_Slav:Slovak


13.39391280
German:Austrian


13.89173495
West_Slav:Czech


16.33854951
West_Slav:South_Polish


16.37053145
French:Swiss_French


17.45059311
German:Swiss_German


20.02844727
German:West_German


20.02844727
German:West_German


20.29022178
Magyar_conqueror:Tatar


21.72066815
Greek:GR_Peloponese


21.74097514
German:South_Dutch


22.35696536
French:French


23.18030198
Italian:Lombardy


24.75758470
Turkic:Crimean_Tatar


30.23043665
Magyar_conqueror:Chuvash


31.30317875
Jew:Ashkenazi


</tbody>

Why do you think that is overfit.

Jana
08-11-2020, 08:18 PM
how do you copy that distances in colored table like Ion did? I like how it looks, so please teach us.

Jana
08-11-2020, 08:20 PM
What I mean is the theory that Khazars played a role somehow in Jewish Europe is interesting. Netanyahu is R1a-Z93. I know some use it to bash Israel, but that is not the point I am making at all. I am looking at it from Khazar genetic input and ethnogenesis with Hungarians.

I know, and they are for fun and all, but these are real DNA kits with real results. The fun is seeing how a person compares themselves to the kits. I am hoping there will be more Hungarian conqueror kits to compare so there can be a list of all of them. I share DNA with the Hungarian grave KAROS III male.

There must have been an error. Why are your distances so large?

There are high R1a Z93 frequencies among Jewish Levites, that may be Khazar link.

Scandal
08-11-2020, 08:20 PM
how do you copy that distances in colored table like Ion did? I like how it looks, so please teach us.

quote him and you will see the code.

Scandal
08-11-2020, 08:23 PM
I think he wrote the html code somewhere else first than pasted it here, but IDk. Only he knows.

Ion Basescul
08-11-2020, 08:25 PM
Why do you think that is overfit.

This is the definition of overfitting:
"Overfitting is a modeling error that occurs when a function is too closely fit to a limited set of data points. Overfitting the model generally takes the form of making an overly complex model to explain idiosyncrasies in the data under study."

In our case, we have a model with 15 data points and my run picks 8 of them, which is quite a lot, in order to explain the relationship between my coordinates and the available data.

The below is basically what's happening. Think of the green line as my run at 0.25x to 0.5x, which somewhat accurately models me with few data points and acceptable distance, while without a pen it goes and picks bits from every reference population (the blue dots) in order to explain the relationship.
Some of them will have real connections, while others work as noise proxies in order to create the lowest possible fit, and this is where the overfit comes from.

https://i.imgur.com/MR0cXbO.png

Ion Basescul
08-11-2020, 08:37 PM
how do you copy that distances in colored table like Ion did? I like how it looks, so please teach us.


You need to go to "Settings" -> "General Settings" -> "Enhanced Interface"

https://i.imgur.com/rXvab7x.png

Then whenever you copy/paste, the editor will add a basic BB-code formatted alternative to whatever it is that you are pasting.

Jana
08-11-2020, 08:39 PM
You need to go to "Settings" -> "General Settings" -> "Enhanced Interface"

https://i.imgur.com/rXvab7x.png

Then whenever you copy/paste, the editor will add a basic BB-code formatted alternative to whatever it is that you are pasting.

Thanks a lot! :)

Chris596
08-11-2020, 08:47 PM
Great results everyone I like this thread. What exactly is a Jász? (genetically). This is what I get using the second model:

Target: Chris
Distance: 1.9660% / 1.96604244
73.4 Vlach
22.0 West_Slav
4.0 Jász
0.6 Armenian

someonenotyou
08-11-2020, 08:48 PM
Great results everyone I like this thread. What exactly is a Jász? (genetically). This is what I get using the second model:

Target: Chris
Distance: 1.9660% / 1.96604244
73.4 Vlach
22.0 West_Slav
4.0 Jász
0.6 Armenian

Ossetian. They are a iranic people.

Jana
08-11-2020, 08:49 PM
Great results everyone I like this thread. What exactly is a Jász? (genetically). This is what I get using the second model:

Target: Chris
Distance: 1.9660% / 1.96604244
73.4 Vlach
22.0 West_Slav
4.0 Jász
0.6 Armenian

Ossetian/north Ossetian, because both descent from Alans/Sarmatians, Iranic group.
Ossetian genetics is native Kavkaz though for the most part.

Turul Karom
08-11-2020, 10:02 PM
Great results everyone I like this thread. What exactly is a Jász? (genetically). This is what I get using the second model:

Target: Chris
Distance: 1.9660% / 1.96604244
73.4 Vlach
22.0 West_Slav
4.0 Jász
0.6 Armenian

What do you score for all of the ADC ranges? No need to post 2x. Also, try the other populations that were added a few pages in that includes Hungarian conqueror DNA. My guess is you will score around 6-8%.

Chris596
08-11-2020, 10:10 PM
What do you score for all of the ADC ranges? No need to post 2x. Also, try the other populations that were added a few pages in that includes Hungarian conqueror DNA. My guess is you will score around 6-8%.

Unfortunately I only get a small amount of it my friend. But I would like to see a similar thread with G25 :) That would be even more interesting (and accurate for sure)

Target: Chris
Distance: 2.1051% / 2.10511600 | ADC: 0.25x
66.0 Vlach
7.6 South_Slav
7.2 South_Slav
6.4 West_Slav
6.0 West_Slav
2.8 South_Slav
2.4 South_Slav
1.6 Jász

Target: Chris
Distance: 2.6590% / 2.65904838 | ADC: 0.5x
40.2 Vlach
22.4 South_Slav
16.6 South_Slav
10.0 South_Slav
9.4 South_Slav
1.4 Magyar_conqueror

Target: Chris
Distance: 3.2355% / 3.23549069 | ADC: 1x
51.8 South_Slav
48.2 South_Slav

Turul Karom
08-11-2020, 10:21 PM
Unfortunately I only get a small amount of it my friend. But I would like to see a similar thread with G25 :) That would be even more interesting (and accurate for sure)

Target: Chris
Distance: 2.1051% / 2.10511600 | ADC: 0.25x
66.0 Vlach
7.6 South_Slav
7.2 South_Slav
6.4 West_Slav
6.0 West_Slav
2.8 South_Slav
2.4 South_Slav
1.6 Jász

Target: Chris
Distance: 2.6590% / 2.65904838 | ADC: 0.5x
40.2 Vlach
22.4 South_Slav
16.6 South_Slav
10.0 South_Slav
9.4 South_Slav
1.4 Magyar_conqueror

Target: Chris
Distance: 3.2355% / 3.23549069 | ADC: 1x
51.8 South_Slav
48.2 South_Slav

Ah, well. I don't have G25, so I cannot participate.

There will always be more conqueror graves to find. We all know you have plenty of Central Asian autosomal heritage regardless.

What do you get as a population scores without the custom coordinates on the k13 modern on Vahaduo?

Thoughts on my results? You can see my populations on page 2, and the updated ones on page 5.

celticdragongod
08-11-2020, 11:01 PM
Distance to: CDG
8.49389781 German:South_Dutch
9.67407877 German:West_German
20.54154327 West_Slav:Czech
22.99541067 West_Slav:Slovak
23.09321419 South_Slav:Slovenian
25.15253665 South_Slav:Croat
25.64920856 West_Slav:South_Polish
28.34309440 East_Slav:Ukrainian_Ivano_Frankivsk
28.87022341 South_Slav:Serb
30.55120620 Vlach:Romanian
43.62327246 Turkic:Crimean_Tatar
49.30645090 Uralic:Mari
50.18197186 Jew:Ashkenazi
53.60769814 Gypsy
70.29039977 Armenian

Target: CDG
Distance: 849.3898% / 8.49389781 | ADC: 2x
100.0 German

Target: CDG
Distance: 849.3898% / 8.49389781 | ADC: 1x
100.0 German

Target: CDG
Distance: 849.3898% / 8.49389781 | ADC: 0.5x
100.0 German

Target: CDG
Distance: 848.6181% / 8.48618069 | ADC: 0.25x
99.4 German
0.6 West_Slav

Target: CDG
Distance: 847.8246% / 8.47824611
98.0 German
2.0 West_Slav

paradox
08-11-2020, 11:35 PM
My father's - V1

Target: Fatherk13
Distance: 1.2226% / 1.22259713
31.0South_Slav
27.2Jew
21.4Vlach
13.8German
4.8West_Slav
1.6Armenian
0.2Uralic

Target: Fatherk13
Distance: 2.0824% / 2.08239341 | ADC: 0.25x
80.2Vlach
8.8German
8.4Jew
2.6South_Slav
--------------------------------------------------------
My father's- V2

Target: Fatherk13
Distance: 1.1948% / 1.19481892
35.2South_Slav
30.4Jew
23.6German
5.2Vlach
2.0Armenian
1.6West_Slav
0.8Jász
0.6Greek
0.6Magyar_conqueror

Target: Fatherk13
Distance: 2.0052% / 2.00520438 | ADC: 0.25x
70.6Vlach
15.4Jew
14.0German

Scandal
08-12-2020, 03:54 AM
Great results everyone I like this thread. What exactly is a Jász? (genetically). This is what I get using the second model:

Target: Chris
Distance: 1.9660% / 1.96604244
73.4 Vlach
22.0 West_Slav
4.0 Jász
0.6 Armenian

They're kavkaz populations. Run it through vahaduo k13


Target: Jász_North_Ossetian
Distance: 2.0611% / 2.06110852
42.6 Kabardin
25.6 Chechen
22.0 Abhkasian
9.0 Ossetian
0.8 Evenki


Distance to: Jász_North_Ossetian
3.91379611 Adygei
4.41631068 Balkar
4.60420460 Kabardin
5.39937033 Ossetian
7.32718227 Chechen
8.59723793 Kumyk
9.44672430 Lezgin
11.99394847 Georgian
12.17453901 Tabassaran
13.88123554 Abhkasian
16.49552060 Georgian_imereti
16.92148043 Yagnobi
19.76136382 Turk_Meskhetian
20.50905410 Talysh
20.71074117 Azerbaijani_Iran
20.73745886 Azerbaijani_Turkey
21.21263774 Zaza
21.33146737 Kurdish
22.00085907 Kurd_Kurmanji_Turkey
22.04592479 Iran_Centraleast
22.04711546 Turkmen
22.13078625 Azeri
22.19683085 Turk_East
22.25927223 Nogay
22.88139200 Laz


Target: Jász:Ossetian
Distance: 3.5616% / 3.56164413
52.2 Balkar
20.8 Georgian_imereti
9.8 Tabassaran
8.0 Abhkasian
6.0 Balochi
2.2 French_Basque
0.6 Xibo
0.4 Oroqen



Distance to: Jász:Ossetian
5.68142588 Balkar
6.68384620 Adygei
7.57449008 Kabardin
10.35985039 Kumyk
10.37846810 Chechen
10.68881659 Georgian
12.47107854 Lezgin
12.77195756 Abhkasian
14.30643911 Tabassaran
14.61259731 Georgian_imereti
18.52480769 Turk_Meskhetian
18.83714681 Yagnobi
19.99915998 Azerbaijani_Iran
20.11950298 Azerbaijani_Turkey
20.34271614 Talysh
20.41393152 Zaza
20.50895170 Kurdish
21.31883440 Turk_East
21.34832546 Iran_Centraleast
21.39647635 Kurd_Kurmanji_Turkey
21.44189590 Azeri
21.59384403 Turkmen
21.61145761 Laz
21.96754424 Kurd_Iran
22.37361616 Lor_Iran

vbnetkhio
08-12-2020, 04:34 AM
They're kavkaz populations. Run it through vahaduo k13

these are just modern North Ossetians. we have ancient Alan samples too:


DA146_Russia_Alan.SG_1300_ybp,10.8,11.05,4.31,49.7 2,10.38,5.64,6,1.89,0,0.21,0,0,0
DA160_Russia_Alan.SG_1300_ybp,8.92,8.01,12.38,45.0 1,14.19,2.41,0.89,2.26,2.85,1.88,0.89,0,0.3
DA162_Russia_Alan.SG_1300_ybp,9.17,13.88,8.42,40.7 2,18.41,2.46,3.92,2.02,0.86,0.15,0,0,0
DA164_Russia_Alan.SG_850_ybp,6.53,17.85,12.8,36.99 ,15.99,0.46,3.68,0.06,2.6,2.74,0.3,0,0
DA243_Russia_Alan.SG_1050_ybp,11.83,17.51,7.22,39. 6,12.97,2.09,4.26,0.31,1.89,1.71,0.62,0,0

Alan_average,9.45,13.66,9.026,42.408,14.388,2.612, 3.75,1.308,1.64,1.338,0.362,0,0.06

Chris596
08-12-2020, 07:00 AM
Ah, well. I don't have G25, so I cannot participate.

There will always be more conqueror graves to find. We all know you have plenty of Central Asian autosomal heritage regardless.

What do you get as a population scores without the custom coordinates on the k13 modern on Vahaduo?

Thoughts on my results? You can see my populations on page 2, and the updated ones on page 5.

You clearly have old Magyar heritage and the standard Hungarian Slavic-Germanic genetics :) (I just lack the Germanic ancestry) I guess you are more Germanic than Slavic? And a bit of Caucasian too (possible Jassic ancestry in your case?) Nice results.

My K13 Modern Vahaduo results:


Target: Chris
Distance: 0.7131% / 0.71313703
43.0 Macedonian_Greece
31.0 South_Polish
11.2 Macedonian_East
6.2 Norwegian
2.8 Turk_Kardzhali-Alevi
2.0 Finnish
2.0 Southwest_Finnish
0.4 Estonian
0.4 French_Basque
0.4 She
0.2 Greek_Northern-Thrace
0.2 Tujia
0.2 Xibo

Target: Chris
Distance: 1.6911% / 1.69114564 | ADC: 0.25x
47.6 Serb_Croatia_Kordun&Banija
34.6 Romania_Moldavia_North
13.2 Croat_Croatia_Slavonia
3.4 Turk_Kardzhali-Alevi
0.6 She
0.6 Ukrainian_Belgorod

oszkar07
08-12-2020, 07:54 AM
Target: Oszkar
Distance: 2.8167% / 2.81670113 | ADC: 0.25x
60.2 West_Slav
39.8 German

Target: Oszkar
Distance: 2.7402% / 2.74016219
56.4 West_Slav
41.2 German
1.4 Uralic
1.0 Jew

With added populations.

Target: Oszkar
Distance: 2.7401% / 2.74008677
56.4 West_Slav
41.2 German
1.2 Uralic
1.0 Jew
0.2 Magyar_conqueror

Target: Oszkar
Distance: 2.9794% / 2.97944489 | ADC: 0.25x
67.4 German
32.0 West_Slav
0.6 Uralic

Lucas
08-12-2020, 03:10 PM
Anyway:)

Target: luk
Distance: 9.1169% / 9.11687159
92.6 West_Slav
7.4 Uralic

Dunai
08-12-2020, 05:02 PM
Does anyone beat me so far in Magyar Conqueror? :D

Target: Dunai
Distance: 0.8113% / 0.81130917
47.4 German
31.2 West_Slav
8.8 Vlach
6.4 Magyar_conqueror
3.4 Turkic
2.8 Jew

Jana
08-12-2020, 05:08 PM
Does anyone beat me so far in Magyar Conqueror? :D

Target: Dunai
Distance: 0.8113% / 0.81130917
47.4 German
31.2 West_Slav
8.8 Vlach
6.4 Magyar_conqueror
3.4 Turkic
2.8 Jew

You have most, plus combined with Turkic it's pretty high.

Dunai
08-12-2020, 07:12 PM
You have most, plus combined with Turkic it's pretty high.

Just an average Alföld guy, seems that the original Hungarian population did survive pretty well here compared to other regions, contrary to many contrarians.

Scandal
08-12-2020, 07:15 PM
Does anyone beat me so far in Magyar Conqueror? :D

Target: Dunai
Distance: 0.8113% / 0.81130917
47.4 German
31.2 West_Slav
8.8 Vlach
6.4 Magyar_conqueror
3.4 Turkic
2.8 Jew

Your amount of German surprise me more tbh. I remember you stated you were only 1/8 German by ancestry. Did you find a way to explain these high germanic results? Some of your hungarian ancestry must have been assimilated germans.

Jana
08-12-2020, 07:18 PM
Just an average Alföld guy, seems that the original Hungarian population did survive pretty well here compared to other regions, contrary to many contrarians.

I think you are above average even for Alfold. Universe is Alfoldi and scores zero. You get lot more than Chris too who is Alfold + Szekely.
But I agree inside modern Hungary this admixture logically survived the most there.

Scandal
08-12-2020, 07:32 PM
His german score is surely not "avarage alfoldi"

Luke35
08-12-2020, 07:39 PM
Your amount of German surprise me more tbh. I remember you stated you were only 1/8 German by ancestry. Did you find a way to explain these high germanic results? Some of your hungarian ancestry must have been assimilated germans.

This is the highest I've seen from him (German). He averages less than that I am sure (other calcs, commercial tests).

Let's see what he gets with his G25 coordinates..

Jana
08-12-2020, 07:41 PM
my friend (north hungarian)

Target: Blanka
Distance: 4.5050% / 4.50502328

53.0 East_Slav
23.8 West_Slav
23.2 French

Distance to: Blanka

6.39176359 South_Slav:Slovenian
7.07675476 West_Slav:Slovak
7.33098220 West_Slav:Czech
7.85788776 South_Slav:Croat
8.76073627 German:Austrian
8.96955406 East_Slav:Ukrainian_Ivano_Frankivsk
11.56518050 West_Slav:South_Polish
12.18402643 Vlach:Romania_Crisana
12.59432015 Vlach:Romania_Maramures
12.69772814 South_Slav:Serb
14.68875080 Vlach:Romania_Moldavia_average
15.23416555 German:Swiss_German
15.95600514 Vlach:Romania_Transylvania
16.57783762 French:Swiss_French
16.68521202 German:West_German
16.68521202 German:West_German
17.82086418 German:South_Dutch
18.23029347 Vlach:Romania_Banat
20.30771528 French:French
25.62220326 Magyar_conqueror:Tatar
26.45151413 Italian:Lombardy
30.35496788 Greek:GR_Peloponese
33.10875564 Magyar_conqueror:Chuvash
34.60578275 Turkic:Crimean_Tatar
38.01679103 Uralic:Mari

Scandal
08-12-2020, 07:43 PM
This is the highest I've seen from him (German). He averages less than that I am sure (other calcs, commercial tests).

Let's see what he gets with his G25 coordinates..

I've seen him score it on other calcs too. For example in the k13 andre thread that I created. He scored high amount of NW Euro on 23andme (as well as lots of Broadly euro). Iirc he was 40% NW euro&Broadly euro on 23andme. In any case his german is more than avarage alföldi which is like 10%.

Dunai
08-12-2020, 07:44 PM
Your amount of German surprise me more tbh. I remember you stated you were only 1/8 German by ancestry. Did you find a way to explain these high germanic results? Some of your hungarian ancestry must have been assimilated germans.

I did find two more German branches in my family tree, based on their surnames (Klein and Waldner), but only more far away, the early 19th and mid 19th century respectively. The rest all have Hungarian surnames, except one of my great-grandmothers (who was German) and three branches with possible Slovak or Czech surnames (Janík, Kubík and Čulik) dating to the mid 19th century. I'm also surprised I get so much German, while most of my ancestors were Hungarians which I can testify to the early 19th century.

Token
08-12-2020, 07:46 PM
Which of you are from the Great Plain?

Scandal
08-12-2020, 07:47 PM
Which of you are from the Great Plain?

Me. I probably have 32/32 of my ancestry from there.

Dunai
08-12-2020, 08:07 PM
Which of you are from the Great Plain?

All my ancestors that I found all lived only in the historic Southern Great Plain/Alföld, back into the mid 18th century (I include the German and Slovak settlers here also), but I have to mention I haven't found all my branches of my family tree so far back. I definitely have a solid assumption that some of those branches have migrated there from historic Northern Hungary, so if looking back even more in time (18th-early 19th century), I must have Northern Hungarian origins also, but I cannot prove it with documents yet.

Dunai
08-12-2020, 08:22 PM
I think you are above average even for Alfold. Universe is Alfoldi and scores zero. You get lot more than Chris too who is Alfold + Szekely.
But I agree inside modern Hungary this admixture logically survived the most there.

Yeah, my closest Hungarian populations are both Transdanubian and Budapest Hungarians, but Alföld comes in third place, definitely I'm not an average Alföld representative, but my high Magyar Conqueror components are definitely more typical to Alföld than to Western and Northern Hungary. Without my more recent German ancestry I believe I would be very typical to the Alföld average.

Token
08-12-2020, 09:00 PM
Nice, it does seems like Hungarians from the Great Plain have more of this exotic, probably conqueror, admixture. It is surprising that no geneticist ever pointed that out.

Luke35
08-12-2020, 09:19 PM
I did find two more German branches in my family tree, based on their surnames (Klein and Waldner), but only more far away, the early 19th and mid 19th century respectively. The rest all have Hungarian surnames, except one of my great-grandmothers (who was German) and three branches with possible Slovak or Czech surnames (Janík, Kubík and Čulik) dating to the mid 19th century. I'm also surprised I get so much German, while most of my ancestors were Hungarians which I can testify to the early 19th century.

What is your total NW European % on 23andMe? Not including "Broadly European" in that total.

Scandal
08-13-2020, 06:28 AM
Nice, it does seems like Hungarians from the Great Plain have more of this exotic, probably conqueror, admixture. It is surprising that no geneticist ever pointed that out.

Székelys(Hungarian minority of Romania) have the most.
I think it's possible some of the conqueror-like admix in alföldis(ppl from great plain) is from Cumans, who settled the area later than hungarians, in the 13th century.

Scandal
08-13-2020, 06:33 AM
What is your total NW European % on 23andMe? Not including "Broadly European" in that total.

https://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?194387-My-23andme-results-are-finally-here-quite-typically-Hungarian-and-Danubian

Jana
08-13-2020, 10:23 AM
I am suprised how some Hungarians like Universe and my friend get such high distances.

Jana
08-13-2020, 10:26 AM
Székelys(Hungarian minority of Romania) have the most.
I think it's possible some of the conqueror-like admix in alföldis(ppl from great plain) is from Cumans, who settled the area later than hungarians, in the 13th century.

Stears thinks exotic admix in Szekelys is also more recent Turkic input (Cuman/Pecheneg/Tatar), because Szekelys guarded eastern borders of Hungary and fought them.
He thinks Turkic tribes raped and looted some Szekely villages and that's how they got such DNA at least eastern Szekelys.

It's not my opinion but his. And it suprised me how he said that because his Szekely half is from extreme southeast of Szekely Land.

Luke35
08-13-2020, 11:04 AM
https://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?194387-My-23andme-results-are-finally-here-quite-typically-Hungarian-and-Danubian

Thanks. As I wrote you, it seems his updated (Current 23andMe results) put him at 23% NW European.

He also gets 9% Broadly European.

ph2ter
08-13-2020, 12:28 PM
Target: ph2ter
Distance: 1.7914% / 1.79137073
90.2 West_Slav:Czech
5.8 German:South_Dutch
4.0 Jász:Ossetian

Distance to: ph2ter
3.30109073 West_Slav:Czech
4.09696749 West_Slav:Slovak
5.94740631 South_Slav:Slovenian
7.33124819 German:Austrian
8.02059225 West_Slav:South_Polish
8.58571488 South_Slav:Croat
9.64044605 East_Slav:Ukrainian_Ivano_Frankivsk
14.34252419 Vlach:Romania_Maramures
14.46661674 South_Slav:Serb
14.95315351 Vlach:Romania_Crisana
16.14956037 German:Swiss_German
16.35657360 Vlach:Romania_Moldavia_average
16.49612682 German:West_German
16.49612682 German:West_German
17.47879859 French:Swiss_French
17.68944035 German:South_Dutch
17.85889134 Vlach:Romania_Transylvania
19.99029515 Vlach:Romania_Banat
21.73976081 French:French
22.61744017 Magyar_conqueror:Tatar
29.84180792 Italian:Lombardy
30.53336536 Magyar_conqueror:Chuvash
32.90410651 Greek:GR_Peloponese
33.00837621 Turkic:Crimean_Tatar
36.02310509 Uralic:Mari
42.23521635 Jew:Ashkenazi
45.43949934 Gypsy
55.16853360 Jász:North_Ossetian
56.54857293 Jász:Ossetian
62.19859886 Armenian

Chris596
08-13-2020, 12:39 PM
Stears thinks exotic admix in Szekelys is also more recent Turkic input (Cuman/Pecheneg/Tatar), because Szekelys guarded eastern borders of Hungary and fought them.
He thinks Turkic tribes raped and looted some Szekely villages and that's how they got such DNA at least eastern Szekelys.

It's not my opinion but his. And it suprised me how he said that because his Szekely half is from extreme southeast of Szekely Land.

It's possible but that can't be the case for thousands of people (basically everyone from Szekely Land), at least I don't think that's possible... He can't seriously think that. Or maybe if some of them assimilated, but that's also unlikely imo.

Although my theory about Armenians is much more likely (and you agreed with me on this), thousands of Armenian families have settled in Szekely Land and also in that city where half of my father's family come from. And I'm not talking about mass rape but slow assimilation and ,,magyarization'' which is very likely. But many of them didn't forget their identity I know this. It is now clear that there were Armenians among my ancestors

A very good source (only in Hungarian unfortunately): https://eda.eme.ro/bitstream/handle/10598/25366/EM_1997_1-2__004_Pal_Judit-Az_erdelyi_ormeny_nepesseg_szamanak.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y

celticdragongod
08-13-2020, 02:12 PM
Try these too (smaller update)


Vlach:Romania_Maramures,23.92,30.36,17.05,8.43,15. 11,1.77,1.22,0.78,0.69,0.01,0.52,0.13,0.00
Vlach:Romania_Crisana,26.04,27.78,16.80,7.48,16.43 ,1.66,0.61,1.03,1.02,0.47,0.46,0.07,0.14
Vlach:Romania_Banat,21.33,26.23,17.90,10.94,18.38, 2.13,0.66,0.51,1.02,0.52,0.14,0.10,0.14
Vlach:Romania_Moldavia_average,23.92,27.62,16.56,9 .91,16.68,1.51,0.58,0.43,1.36,0.63,0.46,0.16,0.16
Vlach:Romania_Transylvania,23.89,26.03,17.75,9.96, 17.32,1.57,0.63,0.65,1.03,0.56,0.44,0.06,0.12
German:West_German,43.14,22.44,14.78,6.85,8.54,0.8 6,0.94,0.13,0.40,0.60,0.64,0.47,0.22
German:Swiss_German,40.15,22.01,17.27,6.58,10.31,1 .90,0.08,0.28,0.25,0.52,0.29,0.29,0.09
German:Austrian,37.21,29.87,14.58,7.23,8.23,1.56,0 .78,0.07,0.16,0.12,0.11,0.07,0.00
German:South_Dutch,44.59,22.22,15.74,6.01,7.37,1.4 7,1.05,0.20,0.84,0.24,0.02,0.09,0.16
German:West_German,43.14,22.44,14.78,6.85,8.54,0.8 6,0.94,0.13,0.40,0.60,0.64,0.47,0.22
Armenian,2.79,0.85,13.02,38.87,34.79,5.23,3.41,0.4 3,0.03,0.05,0.44,0.04,0.05
South_Slav:Croat,28.03,32.78,14.98,7.92,12.34,1.46 ,0.46,0.31,0.55,0.55,0.41,0.10,0.11
Gypsy,9.73,9.53,12.55,16.84,18.44,2.86,26.43,1.28, 0.92,0.27,0.61,0.45,0.09
South_Slav:Serb,24.91,29.30,17.19,9.07,15.58,1.62, 0.52,0.29,0 .67,0.47,0.31,0.09,0.05
South_Slav:Slovenian,29.8778571429,33.85,15.34,7.0 314285714,9.9878571429,1.3564285714,0.7821428571,0 .265,0.4478571429,0.5314285714,0.2942857143,0.1414 285714,0.1157142857
West_Slav:Czech,33.53,37.14,12.43,5.94,7,0.9,1.18, 0.14,0.66,0.59,0.26,0.19,0.13
West_Slav:Slovak,30.84,37.1846153846,12.9876923077 ,6.2976923077,8.0007692308,1.0869230769,1.02769230 77,0.3915384615,0.5769230769,0.7338461538,0.530769 2308,0.1461538462,0.2138461538
East_Slav:Ukrainian_Ivano_Frankivsk,26.18,38.44,13 .89,5.43,11.20,1.12,1.13,0.20,1.35,0.50,0.20,0.16, 0.21
West_Slav:South_Polish,30.66,42.03,11.08,6.56,6.22 ,0.35,1.02,0.45,0.97,0.07,0.25,0.12,0.22
Jew:Ashkenazi,15.32,10.16,18.44,10.29,34.61,5.98,1 .04,0.79,0.97,0.46,0.29,1.15,0.50
Turkic:Crimean_Tatar,13.17,20.04,7.55,16.36,8.88,1 .83,3.23,10.25,16.40,1.28,0.47,0.27,0.21
Uralic:Mari,13.18,42.21,1.21,6.31,0.63,0.45,4.35,0 .87,26.26,3.33,0.38,0.15,0.67
Jász:North_Ossetian,6.39,11.93,7.27,48.78,14.62,1. 38,1.74,2.27,4.59,0.62,0.30,0.06,0.05
Jász:Ossetian,7.84,7.30,9.08,48.98,14.05,1.99,2.74 ,2.92,4.19,0.56,0.21,0.13,0.01
Italian:Lombardy,32.35,12.62,26.19,5.59,20.25,2.1, 0.32,0.13,0.06,0.02,0.16,0.1,0.11
Greek:GR_Peloponese,18.50375,15.75625,19.3175,12.9 6125,26.99875,3.585,1.23375,0.375,0.34375,0.205,0. 50875,0.2075,0.00125
French:French,42.60,17.48,19.50,4.96,10.33,2.82,1. 08,0.15,0.27,0.38,0.23,0.07,0.12
French:Swiss_French,37.79,20.53,19.52,7.90,10.97,1 .49,0.27,0.26,0.44,0.44,0.36,0.04,0.00
Magyar_conqueror:Tatar,18.88,34.62,5.85,11.66,3.85 ,0.90,2.68,3.12,15.56,2.00,0.28,0.13,0.46
Magyar_conqueror:Chuvash,14.88,43.07,2.02,8.74,1.2 9,0.85,2.28,2.66,20.08,2.77,0.44,0.55,0.36

8.49389781 German:South_Dutch
9.67407877 German:West_German
9.67407877 German:West_German
13.81333052 German:Swiss_German
14.75131181 German:Austrian
15.25435675 French:French
17.14558252 French:Swiss_French
20.54154327 West_Slav:Czech
22.99541067 West_Slav:Slovak
23.09321419 South_Slav:Slovenian
25.15253665 South_Slav:Croat
25.64920856 West_Slav:South_Polish
27.94858494 Vlach:Romania_Crisana
28.34309440 East_Slav:Ukrainian_Ivano_Frankivsk
28.87022341 South_Slav:Serb
29.62888118 Vlach:Romania_Maramures
30.04364325 Vlach:Romania_Moldavia_average
30.49335337 Vlach:Romania_Transylvania
31.13491127 Italian:Lombardy
33.36706910 Vlach:Romania_Banat
36.83771708 Magyar_conqueror:Tatar
41.99366411 Greek:GR_Peloponese
43.62327246 Turkic:Crimean_Tatar
45.20587572 Magyar_conqueror:Chuvash
49.30645090 Uralic:Mari

Target: CDG
Distance: 8.4939% / 8.49389781 | ADC: 2x
100.0 German:South_Dutch

Target: CDG
Distance: 8.4939% / 8.49389781 | ADC: 1x
100.0 German:South_Dutch

Target: CDG
Distance: 8.4939% / 8.49389781 | ADC: 0.5x
100.0 German:South_Dutch

Target: CDG
Distance: 8.4862% / 8.48618069 | ADC: 0.25x
99.4 German:South_Dutch
0.6 West_Slav:South_Polish

Target: CDG
Distance: 8.4782% / 8.47824611
98.0 German:South_Dutch
2.0 West_Slav:South_Polish

Scandal
08-14-2020, 12:26 PM
Nice, it does seems like Hungarians from the Great Plain have more of this exotic, probably conqueror, admixture. It is surprising that no geneticist ever pointed that out.



Stears thinks exotic admix in Szekelys is also more recent Turkic input (Cuman/Pecheneg/Tatar), because Szekelys guarded eastern borders of Hungary and fought them.
He thinks Turkic tribes raped and looted some Szekely villages and that's how they got such DNA at least eastern Szekelys.

It's not my opinion but his. And it suprised me how he said that because his Szekely half is from extreme southeast of Szekely Land.

ethnic Hungarians from Siret (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siret) scoring 5-6% mongoloid: https://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?330080-Csangos-from-northen-Siret-GEDMATCH

Freeroostah
08-14-2020, 12:38 PM
Without the Armenian

Target: Freeroostah(greek)
Distance: 520.1514% / 5.20151396
62.8 Vlach
35.8 Jew
1.4 Gypsy



With the Armenian

Target: Freeroostah(greek)
Distance: 425.1116% / 4.25111557
56.6 South_Slav
31.6 Jew
11.8 Armenian

Jana
08-14-2020, 12:49 PM
ethnic Hungarians from Siret (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siret) scoring 5-6% mongoloid: https://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?330080-Csangos-from-northen-Siret-GEDMATCH

Kaspias posted Szekely who scored similar amount of mong. https://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?316125-Hungarians-post-your-K13-K15&p=6524375&viewfull=1#post6524375

1 Baltic 31.54
2 North_Atlantic 24.47
3 West_Med 18.62
4 East_Med 11.85
5 West_Asian 5.62
6 East_Asian 3.44
7 Siberian 2.02
8 Amerindian 1.26
9 Red_Sea 1.03
10 Northeast_African 0.14
(https://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?316125-Hungarians-post-your-K13-K15&p=6524375&viewfull=1#post6524375)

Bessarion
08-14-2020, 08:38 PM
Target: bojan
Distance: 195.9728% / 1.95972838
49.0 West_Slav
33.8 German
12.0 Jew
4.8 Armenian
0.4 Jász

Maybe this "high" Jew revealed the truth behind my slightly higher West Asian components in most calculators.