Actual Importance of Haplogroups

My posts have gotten deleted an explanation would have been respectful at least....

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bobby Martnen

Because my ancestors were Mennonites, and Mennonites, like Orthodox Jews, have very high sexual morals.

---

But mixed YDNA, like Orthodox Jews.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Shaggy

My posts have gotten deleted an explanation would have been respectful at least....

---

I deleted cyclical off-topic posts where you just go around calling me a bitch. Is this respectful enough for you?

There is G and then there is the rest of you...people.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Longbowman

But mixed YDNA, like Orthodox Jews.

---

Most Mennonites are I1...

Im not an expert on DNA.

But Isnt I1 usually associated with Nordic ydna? More accurately Mesolithic Euro?

I recently read that R1b may be the dominant ydna in Germans but R1b was originally not IndoEuropean speakers.
And Germanic language was created by spread and borrowing of Celtic and Slavic.

Also how come some people say Nordic = Germanic?

Sometimes confusing between the language and the dna.

(its just questions to learn).

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Dragoon

Im not an expert on DNA.

But Isnt I1 usually associated with Nordic ydna? More accurately Mesolithic Euro?

I recently read that R1b may be the dominant ydna in Germans but R1b was originally not IndoEuropean speakers.
And Germanic language was created by spread and borrowing of Celtic and Slavic.

Also how come some people say Nordic = Germanic?

Sometimes confusing between the language and the dna.

(its just questions to learn).

---

I1 itself probably arose in the Neolithic in Central Europe going by how the oldest I1 sample was from Neolithic Hungary and I1 hasn't been found in Mesolithic or Paleolithic Europe so far although it's ancestor was in Europe since the Paleolithic. The R1b which is found in modern Europeans is from Indo-Europeans and was originally found among them, the Yamna were dominantly R1b going by ancient samples. Germanic isn't the result of Slavic and Celtic mixing, the Germanic languages developed from their own branch of Indo-Europeans. People link Nordic with Germanics as Germanics arose in the Nordic Bronze Age culture I guess

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bobby Martnen

Most Mennonites are I1...

---

How do you know this?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kelmendasi

How do you know this?

---

Because most West Germans are.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ovidiu

When you go back many generations, that direct lineage doesn't count for any more than other of your ancestors' lineages. It may be interesting, but that's about it.

---

Actually thats when its more important. Because autosomal dna cant prove too distant relations. Haplos can though.