Gedmatch calculators on Vahaduo

https://i.postimg.cc/NFH8ZSQW/image.png

https://i.postimg.cc/HxyDPW7H/image.png

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kaspias

Bulgarians, Pomaks and Turks.

Code:

---

Bulgarian_Sofia,20.64,27.60,18.10,9.15,17.80,2.88,0.90,0.53,0.82,0.70,0.66,0.20,0                                                                               
Bulgarian_Dupnitsa,27.23,27.16,16.45,9.78,13.18,2.69,0,0.28,2.16,0.23,0.84,0,0                                                                               
Bulgarian_Southwest,26.90,22.33,16.06,9.16,21.27,1.27,0.06,0.11,2.00,0.56,0.29,0.00,0.00                                                                               
Bulgarian_Serres,22.95,22.58,19.15,8.27,19.21,5.11,1.60,0.07,0.20,0.49,0,0,0.36                                                                               
Bulgarian_Thrace,17.09,19.89333,19.62667,12.54,24.65667,2.01,2.416667,0.726667,0.753333,0,0.286667,0,0                                                                               
Bulgarian_Eastern-Rhodopes,21.73,21.46,17.37,14.88,16.78,3.54,1.61,1.12,0,0.47,0.88,0.16,0                                                                               
Bulgarian_Central,23.19,22.39,17.70,8.96,20.02,3.71,0.87,0,1.54,1.62,0,0,0                                                                               
Bulgarian_Haskovo,20.45,23.47,21.57,10.51,19.54,0.61,0,0,2.14,0.75,0.88,0.06,0                                                                               
Bulgarian_Northwest,16.56,29.65,18.57,12.5,17.17,2.86,0,1.4,0.38,0,0.91,0,0                                                                               
Bulgarian_Pazardzhik,17.05,26.34,20.12,11.33,18.95,2.93,0,0.48,0.95,0.76,0.53,0.54,0                                                                               
Bulgarian_Burgas,23.92,21.59,14.33,17.54,19.18,1.39,0.35,0.27,0.49,0,0,0.94,0                                                                               
Bulgarian_Pleven,24.14,27.52,16.69,7.96,18.37,1.31,1.09,0.31,1.44,0.96,0.21,0,0                                                                               
Bulgarian_Gabrovo,22.02,23.32,18.08,12.17,18.41,3.15,1.36,0.41,1.08,0,0,0,0                                                                               
Bulgarian_Ruse,17.59,29.84,17.48,15.72,15.73,1.36,0,0.45,0.25,0,1.40,0.18,0                                                                               
Bulgarian_Plovdiv,23.68,20.24,18.62,11.63,22.44,1.85,0,0,0,0.99,0.55,0,0                                                                               
Bulgarian_Stara-Zagora,21.65,24.49,17.67,11.29,19.07,3.29,0,0,1.33,0,1.08,0,0.13                                                                               
Pomak_Komotini,15.18,22.66,17.87,16.57,21.45,3.07,0.04,0.92,0.63,0.9,0.45,0,0.27                                                                               
Pomak_Central-Macedonia,24.01,21.38,13.21,13.02,20.84,5.57,0,0,0,0,0,0,0                                                                               
Pomak_Xanthi,14.67,28.41,17.04,8.30,26.71,3.25,0,0,0.49,1.13,0,0,0                                                                               
Pomak_Plovdiv,21.86,27.36,16.93,7.50,22.14,1.68,0,0.82,0,0.78,0.23,0.47,0.24                                                                               
Pomak_Nevrokopi,20.29,23.47,17.57,12.92,20.7,2.76,0,0.75,0.19,0.68,0.66,0,0                                                                               
Pomak_Drama,17.96,22.92,16.03,14.84,21.63,3.02,1.80,0,1.02,0.59,0.20,0,0                                                                               
Pomak_Kavala,21.86,24.65,14.51,14.45,16.30,6.90,0.25,0,0,0,0,1.08,0                                                                               
Turk_Kardzhali-Mountaineer,15.65,18.37,15.33,17.42,17.18,3.97,0,3.47,7.75,0.47,0,0.4,0                                                                               
Turk_Xanthi,17.64,19.53,13.78,14.43,25.22,2.09,0,1.91,3.70,0.16,0.61,0,0                                                                               
Turk_Komotini,14.83,18.25,12.70,15.92,22.85,2.77,1.68,1.92,6.80,0.87,0.46,0,0.95                                                                               
Turk_Kardzhali-South-Plain,14.6,18.22,12.61,16.66,21.62,4.36,0.63,2.34,8.17,0.34,0,0.42,0.04                                                                               
Turk_N-Macedonia,19.62,26.16,14.14,12.18,18.91,2.55,2.33,1.13,2.05,0.67,0.04,0.21,0                                                                               
Turk_Thessaloniki,19.29,19.58,17.35,12.55,26.1,1.97,0,0.51,1.38,0.94,0,0,0.32                                                                               
Turk_Stara-Zagora,21.7,18.28,14.13,15.26,19.21,4.15,1.27,0.54,4.73,0.58,0,0.14,0                                                                               
Turk_Edirne,13.92,14.66,16.81,19.56,20.22,2.35,3.04,3.03,5.28,0.53,0.53,0.07,0                                                                               
Turk_Kardzhali-Alevi,17.75,17.11,15.37,21.97,16.46,0.9,0.12,4.61,5.19,0,0,0,0.53                                                                               
Turk_Kazanlik,20.10,16.93,17.68,11.70,22.85,1.50,2.76,1.72,3.09,0.72,0.59,0.37,0                                                                               
Turk_Burgas,19.03,11.49,14.52,19.18,23.94,3.15,1.32,2.12,4.28,0.44,0,0.16,0.37                                                                               
Turk_Kavala,22.02,18.10,16.46,14.95,20.83,1.60,0,1.12,2.06,0.27,0.21,0,0.12                                                                               
Turk_Sliven-Alevi,20.29,20.76,14.36,19.19,13.55,2.51,2.98,2.70,1.95,1.38,0,0,0.33                                                                               
Turk_Crete,15.92,13.82,17.01,15.12,26.39,4.34,0,1.98,2.4,0.21,0.19,1.76,0.87                                                                               
Turk_Drama,17.20,22.87,15.61,15.52,19.94,1.52,1.62,2.76,1.90,0.27,0.26,0.19,0.34                                                                               
Turk_Dobrich,18.15,22.61,15.49,12.65,18.85,4.32,2.72,2.17,0.35,1.73,0,0.59,0.38                                                                               
Turk_Razgrad,21.27,22.84,14.09,12.92,19.33,1.03,2.24,2.57,2.24,0.25,0.12,0,1.10                                                                               
Turk_Alexandroupoli,21.94,16.43,16.91,13.31,23.54,4.30,0,0.35,2.08,0.99,0,0.13,0                                                                               
Turk_Targovishte,20.17,18.88,12.05,14.29,22.67,2.61,1.15,3.42,3.38,0.61,0.77,0,0                                                                               
Turk_Kardzhali-West,16.43,21.01,14.99,15.94,16.79,3.94,3.41,3.15,3.24,0.79,0.31,0,0                                                                               
Turk_Kardzhali-East,21.29,16.80,14.74,14.36,18.50,2.29,0.23,1.80,5.40,2.55,1.10,0.66,0.29                                                                               
Turk_Dobruja-Tatar,12.70,25.39,7.77,11.38,5.82,2.15,2.09,10.20,20.74,0.91,0.52,0,0.33

---

---

could you make simplified Bulgarian regional averages?

maybe along these lines:
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikiped...r_Bozhinov.png

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by vbnetkhio

could you make simplified Bulgarian regional averages?

maybe along these lines:
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikiped...r_Bozhinov.png

---

I agree with this approach, within one nation there should be differentiations based on regions (8-10 at max) rather than counties or cities (with the exception of the capital, which is often the meeting point of all regions), otherwise we get way too many results from the same nation.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Dunai

I agree with this approach, within one nation there should be differentiations based on regions (8-10 at max) rather than counties or cities (with the exception of the capital, which is often the meeting point of all regions), otherwise we get way too many results from the same nation. Nothing against Pomaks, but there are way more Pomak regions in K13 than German.

---

Exactly. Also the Balkan Turks. I mean they are like 10% of Bulgaria's population and in Greece and Romania their share is even smaller.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Leto

Exactly. Also the Balkan Turks. I mean they are like 10% of Bulgaria's population and in Greece and Romania their share is even smaller.

---

Many of those Bulgarian, Pomak, Balkan-Turk averages are based solely on one or two samples.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CommonSense

Many of those Bulgarian, Pomak, Balkan-Turk averages are based solely on one or two samples.

---

I believe 5 samples should be absolute minimum to create any separate cluster, and even that is kinda on the borderline. Now I do wonder if anyone still even knows on how many samples are the various groupings even created on? Rather have one or two well representative national categories than 7-8 based on 2-3 samples each.

In my opinion 3 samples should be absolute minimum for one average, around 10 is decent. 1 is unacceptable, that person can be atypical for the region and that's not average.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Est.1992

In my opinion 3 samples should be absolute minimum for one average, around 10 is decent. 1 is unacceptable, that person can be atypical for the region and that's not average.

---

Agree. But when we have free service like Vahaduo updated sheets, one can be less strict.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lukasz

Agree. But when we have free service like Vahaduo updated sheets, one can be less strict.

---

Do you keep any database about how many samples are the averages based upon? Are there any which are based on less than 3? If yes, would you merge those which don't fit this minimum?

Do you have the PCA with the new french sample?