Nije baš da to Hrvati rade, pa Tropolje nije Hercegovina ali nije ni Bosna. To je zapravo produžetak Dalmatinske Zagore.
Printable View
View of eastern Herzegovina from Srđ fortress above Dubrovnik
https://i.imgur.com/OyFuNGj.jpg
It's a stone desert mainly, with super low population, so I don't buy the story such huge amount of people (meaning Serbs) originate from there.
Doesn't make any sense.
When it is said Herzegovina, it means not only todays eastern Herzegovina, but historical Herzegovina, with parts of west Montenegro, southwest Serbia, and this already mentioned upper Podrinje (Foča-Goražde region).
As I said few months ago, it is not only Herzegovina as a place of origin of western Serbs, but also neighbouring regions. It is mentined that Austrian diplomat found Serbs in Bosanska Krajina who said their origin from Smederevo. That doesnt mean litteraly Smederevo as a towns, but Smederevo sanjak, that comprised lot o todays central and western Serbia.
One interesting thing I found is toponymes in close Višegrad surrounding:
https://i.imgur.com/Jw7vehq.png
They resemble Krajina Serbs.
There are villages Uništa, Mirlovići in northern Dalmatia, Kosovo polje near Knin, Babin Potok is village in Lika, Dubovik in Bosanska Krajina.
Rodić is well known Krajina Serb surname.
^^^^I see, that makes sense, interesting to learn.
Istočna Hercegovina je u zadnjih +500 godina izrazito iseljeničko područje.
One of the most beautiful places in eastern Herzegovina to me is Dabar field https://bs.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dabarsko_polje
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikiped...skoPolje02.JPG
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/D7qVldTX...pg&name=medium
https://s41.radikal.ru/i094/1307/0f/f51aab4f7065.jpg
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DUPXUrYW...pg&name=medium
Few more toponymes in Višegrad surroundings that resemble Krajina Serbs.
Strmica in northern Dalmatia (Knin), Turjak and Međeđa in Bosanska Krajina (Dubica and Gradiška), Bjelajci near Pakrac in western Slavonia.
https://i.imgur.com/KhTOOoR.png
Riđane in Dalmatian Kosovo near Knin and Riđani near Nikšić, Pađene near Knin and Pađeni near Bileća etc. Look at this http://nebojsavukanovic.info/hercego...inu-i-krajini/
Uništa is only ikavian speaking village in Bosansko Grahovo minicipality. Both Serbs and Croatians from Uništa used ikavian. Both settled from Vrlika area in 19th century.
I posted the latter result a year ago:
https://www.theapricity.com/forum/sh...=1#post6629911
Krajina Serbs from the SDNKP, 635 samples
J2b-M205>Y22059 = 8.3%
N2-P189.2>FGC28435 = 8.2%
I1-P109>FGC22045 = 3.8%
total - 20.3%
Krajina Serbs from 23andMe, 287 samples
хаплогрупа J2b-M205 = 9.1%
хаплогрупа N2-P189.2 = 8%
хаплогрупа I1-P109 = 2.8%
total 19.9%
^those subclades definitely originate from the very sparsely populated Old Herzegovina, they simply migrated to empty areas and had a huge population boom there.
and that's without r1a and i2. for those it's harder to distinguish which subclades are from Herzegovina and which from elsewhere.
Map of medieval Herzegovinian clans Attachment 107363
We already have genetically confirmed descendants of Predojevići, Nikšići, Drobnjaci, Mirilovići, Banjani, Maleševci (they lived between Bileća and Trebinje), Ugarci-Dubravčići (from Trebinje-Ljubomir) among Krajina Serbs. I thinks also Burmazi have descendants among Krajina Serbs (it's not officially for now).
Borjan family from northern Dalmatia might be connected with Borjani Herzegovian medieval clan (Borjan from Kričke near Drniš is tested as I2-Y3120). Milan Borjan originated from Kričke https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milan_Borjan
We also have toponyms from Herzegovina on my island (including island name), from Mostar/Čapljina area. Toponyms are almost entirely Slavic, often referring to Slavic deities like Veles.
Recently is published result of Serb with surname Krasić who is from here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Šeškovci
He is I2-PH908 and it's close to Dalmatian Croatian guy Akmadžić and to several Bunjevci (Jurić, Dragičević, Rukavina etc) who are Y144305 sub-branch.
Predojevići I2-PH908
Maleševci I2-PH908
Mirilovići I2-PH3414
Ugarci-Dubravčići R1b-U152
Banjani N-P189.2 (mostly)
Burmazi R1a (not confirmed yet)
Genetic descendant of Maleševci is Petar Kočić https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Petar_Kočić
Descendant of Ugarci-Dubravčići is Marinko Rokvić https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marinko_Rokvić
Descendants of Predojevići are TA users Dušan and Bosniensis.
S druge strane, Dubrovčani se ne identificiraju kao Dalmatinci (ne samo grad DU nego sve do Neuma), pa i nisu, skroz drugi govor i još štošta. Više su kao Hercegovci i Crnogorci, samo sa Med kulturom.
Dubrovniku je sličniji Kotor nego Split.
A oni iz Zagore zove one s primorja Škutori.
Što se tiče porijekla iz Zagore treba pričati o gradijentu. Nije sve crno i bijelo. Taj gradijent je jak i u Zapadnoj Hercegovini (Posušje, Široki, Grude, Ljubuški i Brotnjo). Mi u južnoj Hercegovini (Čapljina, Ravno, Neum) više naginjemo Dubrovniku tj. južnoj Dalmaciji. Mostar (srednja Hercegovina) i sjeverna Hercegovina su miks. Ali nas ostale zaboli neka stvar. A ovi u Tropolju uvijek za sebe misle da su nešto posebno, a ako trebaju pripadati nečem širem dosta ih kažu da su najbliži Dalmaciji. Dosta ih isto kaže i Hercegovini, ali opet...Quote:
Pa navodno i jesu, većina bi trebala potjecati iz Zagore (i po govoru). Ima o tome na HB forumu.
Krasojevići/Kresojevići were medieval clan from eastern Herzegovina in vlach social status (many Herzregovinians in late middle age and early Ottoman period were in vlach caste). I know they are R1a and that today exist their genetic descendants among Serbs from eastern Herzegovina and some other regions.
About them https://www.poreklo.rs/2012/03/07/kresojevi%C4%87/
very interesting. they aren't on that map of vlach katuns, so I thought they could be a non-vlach family.
so none of the Herzegovinian "vlachs" have a certain pre-Slavic haplogroup. even N-P189.2 is currently considered a "northern" haplogroup by most of the poreklo admins.
https://www.tportal.hr/vijesti/clana...tinci-20130511
nije anketa, ali indikativno
Bila sam u Dubrovniku 5 dana prije 2 tjedna, i u Konavlima, Stonu, dolini Neretve...Dubrovčani s kojima sam razgovarala se ne osjećaju Dalmatincima, već su sami za sebe, ali smatraju Hrvate iz Hercegovine i CG najbližima. Puno su manje negativno nastrojeni prema Hercegovcima nego mnogi Dalmatinci, i pozitivnije su govorili o Hercegovcima nego o Dalmatincima.
Pravoslavce iz istočne Hercegovine i Crne Gore ne podnose ali to je zbog rata i pustošenja (nisam ni znala da su bila takva), u budućnosti će vjerojatno odnosi ići na bolje sa svakom novom generacijom.
OK su Dubrovčani, mirniji i manje agresivni od Dalmatinaca, iznenadili su me srdačnošću.
Not all Herzegovinian vlach katuns are marked on the map from my post.
Accorring to legend fouder of Maleševci tribe was Serbian duke Maleš. He was from Herzegovina, but moved to the Berovo in eastern Macedonia. Because of Ottoman invasion he returned from Berovo in his native area between Trebinje and Bileća and died there in early 15th century https://malesevci.rs/males-srpski-vojvoda/
Maleševo mountain or Maleš moutain near Berovo is named by duke Maleš https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maleshevo_Mountain
Duke Maleš arrived to Berovo as part of Serbian administration in the time of tsar Dušan or tsar Uroš. Serbian nobleman who came to Macedonia, Albania and Greece in time of Serbian rule there were mostly from Dinaric region.
More about Maleševci
https://malesevci.blogspot.com/2008/02/blog-post.html
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maleševci
https://html.scribdassets.com/10wqmp...471d8dade9.png
Mislio sam da je Insuperable baš iz Škutorije (oblast otprilike omeđena Širokim, Ljubuškim i Posušjem, sa Grudama u srcu). A on je iz južnijeg/jugoistočnijeg kraja. Neću ga više zvati Škutorom. :)
Hrvati iz Mostara, Čapljine, Stoca, Rame, Duvna itd. nisu Škutori. Od Dalmatinaca Škutorima su najbliži/najsličniji Imoćani, i oni se često trpaju u Škutore (neki čak i sami sebe smatraju Škutorima). Čuo sam da su Škutori po mnogo čemu specifični i da se razlikuju od ostalih hercegovačkih i tropoljskih Hrvata.
Ne razlikujemo se po ničemu. Nema nikakve razlike između hercegovačkih Hrvata. Ja ne vidim. Da me bilo gdje staviš u Hercegovini ne bih znao među kojim sam ljudima. U Dalmaciji se osjeti razlika, kulturno, pa ja antro profesionalac vidim čak i fizionomski što je najviše izrazeno na otocima.
it's weirder that both the Baltic and NA are low.
this person has around the same level of Baltic, but the NA is much higher.
https://www.theapricity.com/forum/sh...=1#post7183413
basically the Bosniak has an Thracian-like pre-Slavic part, and the Serb Illyrian like.
Distance to: Bosniak_Hercegovina
2.25094841 46.40% I5769_Bulgaria_IA_2600_ybp + 53.60% AV1_Hungary_Avar_1361_ybp
Distance to: tepci
3.61568873 65.00% R1_Abruzzo_Teramo_Late_Bronze_Age_Italy + 35.00% AV1_Hungary_Avar_1361_ybp
All these villages down which connect Herzegovina and Krajina are Serbian or were until recent past, except Borojevići near Stolac wich have Bosniak majority
Kazanci (Gacko) and Kazanci (Bosansko Grahovo)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kazanci
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donji_Kazanci
Ugarci (Trebinje) and Ugarci (Bosansko Grahovo)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ugarci,_Trebinje
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ugarci,_Bosansko_Grahovo
Lastva (Trebinje) and Lastve (Bosanski Petrovac)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lastva
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lastve
Vođeni (Ljubinje) and Vođenica (Bosanski Petrovac)
https://bs.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vođeni
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vođenica
Borojevići (Stolac) and Borojevići (Banija)
https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Borojevići_(Stolac)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Borojevići
Maleševci (Bosansko Grahovo) and Maleševci tribe from Trebinje-Bileća (i wrote about them in detail in on of previous posts)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maleše...sansko_Grahovo
Ljubovo (Trebinje) and Ljubovo (Udbina)
https://bs.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ljubovo_(Trebinje)
https://ceb.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ljubovo
Rastovac (Kalinovik) and Rastovac Budački (Kordun)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rastovac,_Kalinovik
https://bs.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rastovac_Budački
Grkavci (Trebinje) and Grkovci (Bosansko Grahovo)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grkavci
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grkovci
Borkovići (Plužine) and Borkovići (Banja Luka)
https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Borkovići_(Plužine)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Borkovići
Vrba (Gacko) and Vrba (Glamoč)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vrba,_Gacko
https://bs.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vrba_(Glamoč)
Todorići (Trebinje) and Todorići (Šipovo)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Todorići,_Trebinje
https://bs.wikipedia.org/wiki/Todorići_(Šipovo)
Examples of connections of toponyms from Herzegovina with Krajina Serb surnames
Diklići village near Trebinje and Krajina Serb surname Diklić (mostly from Lika) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diklići,_Trebinje
Budisavlje village near Nevesinje and famous Krajina/Lika Serb surname Budisavljević https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budisavlje
Zgonjevo village near Trebinje and Krajina Serb surname Zgonjanin (from Banija and western Bosnia) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zgonjevo
Grbići village near Trebinje and Krajina Serb surname Grbić (from western Bosnia, Lika and Kordun) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grbići_(Trebinje)
Mišljen village near Ljubinje and Krajina Serb surname Mišljen (from Oton near Knin) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mišljen
Dulići near Gacko and Krajina Serb surname Dulić (from western Bosnia) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stari_Dulići
Mrkonjići village near Trebinje and Krajina Serb surname Mrkonjić (from Kordun) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mrkonjići
Cerovac village near Trebinje and Krajina Serb surname Cerovac (from Strmica near Knin) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cerovac,_Trebinje
Kovačići village near Nevesinje and Krajina Serb surname Kovačić (from Kordun and western Bosnia) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kovačići,_Nevesinje
This is Bosniak, and according to surname he is from Gacko (eastern Herzegovina).
https://i.ibb.co/9T1tdYM/20200401-165759-2.jpg
https://i.ibb.co/Ng0wvkm/20200401-165812.jpg
He seems to have a bit of Mongoloid in him. Maybe distant Turkish?
Bosnia is a small country/region and the Bosniaks are just 1.5 or so million, they're not extremely diverse.
Bosnia is smaller than Denmark by territory (39,000 km2).