Indigenous Balkan I2a1 in southern Albania

[Dema]

0% I2a1b among my DNA relatives, which is why I plot like a civilized ancient man.

I don't have any I2a1 among my 1250 relatives. Any other name for this?

Do you guys speak about 23andme matches or you include Ged Match too?

I get 205 matches on Family Finder.

[Scholarios]

They would need to test thousands of them to make that conclusion and separate I2a1 clades from others. Sardinia peaks in I2a1 aswell.

Well, here lay the problem with modern population genetics. (or how it is used by people like us).

But just a bet, but really don't believe Arbereshe I2a1 is related to Sardinian.... just a hunch.

[Era]

Do you guys speak about 23andme matches or you include Ged Match too?

I get 205 matches on Family Finder.

Those are my 23andme relatives only. I'm not familiar with Gedmatch except when comparing one to one.

[Laberia]

Central Albania, so I have both southerners and greeks as relatives

Responding to your question, a DNA test is a survey on the population. More people participate, the more small is the margin of error. Here we are not talking about personal test, but the surveys on the population. According to this study that Scholarios introduced us, testing 104 people, there was a result of 23% of Slavic presence in South Albania. Although we're not sure if this is a typical haplogroup of haplogroup Slavs.
One must remember that there are no serious scholars who take on these results seriously. One reason, certainly there is, because this historians use other scientific disciplines in their work.
Even the exit polls made before the elections are a scientific work. The problem is that against all the so-called serious polls, won Trump, not Clinton.

[Voskos]

lol, i love how albanians take it as an insult to be related to slavs.as if they had the plague or something

[Laberia]

So you have told nothing with this famous study Scholarios.
And you didn't answer what happened to all this slavs.

[Dick]

lol, i love how albanians take it as an insult to be related to slavs.as if they had the plague or something

[Wrong]

lol, i love how albanians take it as an insult to be related to slavs.as if they had the plague or something

http://www.theapricity.com/forum/sho...py-I-m-Not-E1b

[Laberia]

lol, i love how albanians take it as an insult to be related to slavs.as if they had the plague or something

Yes it's true, we hate them. But here is not the discussion about this. This Scholarios have a theory and he is not accepting a serious discussion. And was him who organized all this.

[Scholarios]

Responding to your question, a DNA test is a survey on the population. More people participate, the more small is the margin of error. Here we are not talking about personal test, but the surveys on the population. According to this study that Scholarios introduced us, testing 104 people, there was a result of 23% of Slavic presence in South Albania. Although we're not sure if this is a typical haplogroup of haplogroup Slavs.
One must remember that there are no serious scholars who take on these results seriously. One reason, certainly there is, because this historians use other scientific disciplines in their work.
Even the exit polls made before the elections are a scientific work. The problem is that against all the so-called serious polls, won Trump, not Clinton.

Sure, but that 23% Slavic dna combined with




and this



and this



plus this



and (old phylogenic name) map of i2a1b



So these provide some perspective, don't you agree? All the objections in TA can't really stop me from thinking.... hmmmm. that's weird. Amirite or amirite?