2





| Thumbs Up/Down |
| Received: 15,697/315 Given: 8,913/358 |


| Thumbs Up/Down |
| Received: 2,900/98 Given: 2,616/27 |
Viking Rus wasn't Slavic, but Germanic for sure, but for sure they were the large minority among Slavs.
Also, monk Nestor in the "Primary Chronicles" is saying to us that Slavic and Finnic tribes first expelled Vikings when they tried to invade modern day West Russia, and then after they (Rus' tribe) lost, they were invited by Slavic and Finnic tribes to rule among them, becouse they were in many conflicts before it.





| Thumbs Up/Down |
| Received: 5,325/177 Given: 6,202/72 |






| Thumbs Up/Down |
| Received: 5,404/770 Given: 6,855/520 |
The difference is that Tokharistan was just a region, not an ethnic name, its basically a Turkic word: Tokh "mountain" + ar "people", its the people of Togarmah, son of Gomer, one of the 24 Oghuz clans. Armenians, Georgians and Turks descended from this ancient guy.
And how can Turks have migrated into Middle Asia in the late 1st millennium AD, when there were already Turks in Europe in the early 1st millenium AD?![]()
Last edited by Proto-Shaman; 01-18-2018 at 04:29 PM.






| Thumbs Up/Down |
| Received: 5,404/770 Given: 6,855/520 |
Gedrosia K3
Using 1 population approximation:
1 Hazara @ 1.092248
2 Irula @ 4.759782
3 Kattunayakkan @ 5.122586
4 Nihali @ 6.114567
5 Madiga @ 8.526909
6 Chenchu @ 8.873101
7 Hallkipiki @ 9.133532
8 Mala @ 9.250433
9 Gond @ 10.722106
10 Kamsali @ 11.002162
11 Paniyas @ 11.521728
12 Bengali @ 11.555750
13 UP_Chamar @ 11.572104
14 Bhil @ 13.876436
15 Kallar @ 14.021095
16 Tharu @ 14.205913
17 Piramalai @ 14.480849
18 Kyrgyz @ 16.874592
19 Bhumij @ 17.202101
20 Kurumba @ 17.260006
Using 2 populations approximation:
..1 50% Nganasan +50% Tajik_Pomiri @ 0.000000
..6 50% Turkmen +50% Yukagir @ 0.425719
..8 50% Kyrgyz +50% Uzbek @ 0.431844
..9 50% Changapa +50% Kalash @ 0.485189
10 50% Changapa +50% Pashtun_Afghan @ 0.618841
12 50% UP_Brahmin +50% Yukagir @ 0.745615
14 50% Burusho +50% Yukagir @ 0.784907
16 50% Kyrgyz +50% UP_Caste @ 0.788417
17 50% GujaratiB +50% Yukagir @ 0.811810
Using 3 populations approximation:
1 50% Altaian +25% Altaian +25% Chechen @ 0.000000 <---- !




| Thumbs Up/Down |
| Received: 646/76 Given: 214/1 |
Currently no evidence exists that Tengri (Täŋri) was some kind of a deity, let alone ‘religion’. It is not even clear if such notorious figures as Genghis khan believed in Tengri. ‘By the power of Eternal Heaven’ (Tengri) was used by the old Turks and later Mongols as an ultimatum, a statement indicating inevitability of fate, or coercing to acknowledge the inevitable. Tengri was a call to the heavens/sky. In medieval old Uighur documents, literary/religious works Tengri simply meant sky/heavens. Considering all of the above we can firmly attest that Christianity is in fact a religion of Tengri (our Father, who art in heaven). (NOT) Even cro-magnons had some kind of belief systems with an afterlife and likely called onto heavens. But to call their beliefs and practices as ‘religion’ would be farfetched.


| Thumbs Up/Down |
| Received: 3,714/1,597 Given: 1,298/111 |
Sky God (Gök Tengri) was referred to as one God.
If it was simply nature or universe, that wouldn't be something countable.
Ibn Fadlan reports during his journey to Bulgar, while travelling lands of Oğuz Turks somewhere around north-east of Caspian.
Ibn Fadlān and the Land of Darkness
Arab Travellers in the Far North
chapter about Oghuz Turks
...
That's around 920 or 921 when the Oghuz weren't Muslims.
Last edited by Böri; 01-22-2018 at 08:05 PM.




| Thumbs Up/Down |
| Received: 646/76 Given: 214/1 |
'One' god is even more far fetched than considering Tengri a deity (among others) which in itself is far fetched. There is no 'reliable' evidence from the Turkic runes or Uighur documents or even with later Mongol conquests that 'Tengri' was some kind of a 'deity'. They did not have to be Muslims, they could have adopted notions and understanding from neighboring 'monotheistic' populations. 10th century is pretty late and these tribes were out of the 'core land'.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Bookmarks