0


Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 141/39 Given: 119/11 |
Hittite and proto-Iranians came from the same early PIEan source SOUTH of Caucasus. Not Yamnaya.
Graeco-Aryans = Hittites & Iranians = came from 1 source. Both linked to Y-DNA J2a, R1b, R2a and T & L.
Some minor Steppes ancestry in Kurds is from the Scythians and Parthians : https://www.theapricity.com/forum/sh...ight=scythians
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 141/39 Given: 119/11 |
Hittites (J2a & R1b people) themselves can't be from Yamnaya, because proto-Anaolian from which Hittites are from is dated older than Yamnaya. Same can be said about the proto-West Iranians (Aryans).
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 141/39 Given: 119/11 |
He was a true Mede because at the same time (around 900 BC) the Medes who evolved from the Gutians/Kassites already lived in that area/region.
Also, the Kurds as Northwest Iranian speakers are directly evolved from the Medes also Northwest Iranian speakers. And Kurds are the evidence that this ancient R1b fella was a Median Aryan.
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 1,250/11 Given: 524/7 |
As per Dilawer from Eurasian DNA that f3s and f4s sjpw that Hasanlu IA sample is N and E shifted compared to Iran Chl. He will not give me exact numbers or tables because he is reserving those for his paper. He also said that some modern Kurds and Iranians are significantly more certain Scythian/Saka/Sarmatian shifted than Hasanlu IA meaning that there was admixture from some Scythian/Sarmatians into Kurds and W Iranians after the time of Hasanlu IA. After bugging him some more he indicated that the biggest shift is towards some Sarmatians from Kazakhstan and that he'll publish details over the next few months.
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 8,699/66 Given: 8,957/110 |
This thread turned into a absolut kurdish shitfest.
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 141/39 Given: 119/11 |
Exactly, most people FAIL to understand that ancient proto-Iranians were native to West Asia and had very little Steppes ancestry. Most Steppes ancestry in Kurds and Western Persians arrived much later with the Scythians and Parthians.
Many people fail to understand (or try to deny) that Steppes related ancestry came very late with the Scythians and later even with the Turkic tribes. Nothing to do with the original Aryans who were Caucaso-Gedrosian people (close to Kura-Araxes)..
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 141/39 Given: 119/11 |
Well, if you discussing the ancient Iranians it is not possible to mention them without the Kurds. Since it has been proven by Kurdish DNA that Kurds are the purest West Iranians. More pure than Persians and much, much more pure than Turkified Azeri.
Kurds are the pride of the ancient West Iranians (Gutians, Medes), the knights of the ancient Middle East!
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 1,250/11 Given: 524/7 |
I suppose Parthian genomes when and if they are published could show how much of this Kazakhstan Sarmatian DNA or some other Scythian DNA they carried.
They would also show how much admixture Kurds and other Iranians have from them. We need some place to fund their excavatian from Iran.
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 3,746/73 Given: 5,142/86 |
Why does every Iranic related thread turn into a Kurdish nationalist infested shitshow?
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Bookmarks