How to group Italian samples in order to obtain good references?

[gixajo]

Noroeste: Lombardia, Bergamo, Liguria y Piamonte.
Noreste: Trento y Veneto.
Centro: Abruzzo, Toscana, Lazio, Apulia, Umbria y Marche.
Cerdeña: Cerdeña.
Sur: Basilicata, Sicilia, Campania y Calabria.

Con eso bastaria, hay una homogeneidad entre referencias por sub-region, pero una vez que te sales de ahi, las cosas o cambian mucho o demasiado.

Sicilia casa bien con el resto del Sur de Italia?, en MH y así suelen meterlos a todos juntos.

[Defcon2]

Pero me refiero con todos los samples, no con uno de cada, además los más distantes.

Pero eso ya sería hacer trampa es normal que con promedios de 100 regiones de los países cercanos obtenga una buena distancia, hay tanta variedad como para representar la ascendencia de todos los europeos incluso.

Target: Juan_scaled
Distance: 2.6831% / 0.02683102
43.2 Basque_French
23.6 Italian_Lombardy
14.6 Moroccan_North
13.0 Italian_Liguria
5.6 Irish

Target: German
Distance: 1.5331% / 0.01533130
48.2 French_Alsace
39.0 Irish
12.8 French_Seine-Maritime

Target: Romanian
Distance: 2.4872% / 0.02487163
88.2 Italian_Northeast
9.2 French_Seine-Maritime
2.6 Italian_Basilicata

Target: Greek_Thessaly
Distance: 1.2413% / 0.01241328
59.8 Italian_Apulia
34.0 Italian_Northeast
6.2 French_Seine-Maritime

Target: Swedish
Distance: 2.7534% / 0.02753351
100.0 Irish

Target: Croatian
Distance: 3.7600% / 0.03760019
46.6 French_Seine-Maritime
34.0 French_Alsace
19.4 Italian_Northeast

[gixajo]

Pero eso ya sería hacer trampa es normal que con promedios de 100 regiones de los países cercanos obtenga una buena distancia, hay tanta variedad como para representar la ascendencia de todos los europeos incluso.

Lo que es hacer trampa es coger el sample mas distante de cada país!!!

[Defcon2]

Lo que es hacer trampa es coger el sample mas distante de cada país!!!

Hombre, sirve para probar tu teoría de que escogiendo samples random de cada país cercano podría modelar a todos los españoles, está claro que no. Obviamente una muestra italiana del norte + sur de Francia se podría modelar bastante bien a un español.

[gixajo]

I will make a mix between what Samnium, Rocinante and VidFlumina suggested.

I will do it with Campania sample for now.

Doubts are: Adding Sicilia to the South average, and adding or not Bergamo/Lombardia and where, Northwest or NorthEast?


South=Campania+Basilicata+Apulia+Sicilia

Central=Tuscany+Marche+Lazio+Umbria

NorthEast=Veneto-Friuli+TrentinoAltoAdigie+Italian_NorthEast

NorthWest=ValdeAosta+Liguria+Piemonte

Are you agree?

Edit:i added italian NorthEast because I thought Veneto and Friuli were 2 different samples.

[Defcon2]

I will make a mix between what Samnium, Rocinante and VidFlumina suggested.

I will do it with Campania sample for now.

Doubts are: Adding Sicilia to the South average, and adding or not Bergamo/Lombardia and where, Northwest or NorthEast?


South=Campania+Basilicata+Apulia+Sicilia

Central=Tuscany+Marche+Lazio+Umbria

NorthEast=Veneto+Friuli+TrentinoAltoAdigie

NorthWest=ValdeAosta+Liguria+Piemonte

Are you agree?

Una vez hice promedios de Italia separandolos en dos, ahora no me acuerdo de qué muestras utilicé para hacerlo.

North_Italy,0.1233471,0.14700055,0.03081834,-0.00690665,0.0339204,-0.00273766,0.00223906,0.0016094,0.00958434,0.02398 311,-0.00328104,0.00564268,-0.0121582,-0.00397185,-0.00091271,-0.00268889,-0.00011883,0.00089686,0.00360974,-0.00288958,-0.00114275,0.001513,-0.0008338,0.0032579,-0.00057853
South_Italy,0.10566103,0.14688977,-0.0062129,-0.04125893,0.01543405,-0.01391903,-0.00089583,-0.00134823,0.00612613,0.0212079,0.00195132,0.00317 238,-0.00541833,0.00045687,-0.00693987,-0.00353285,0.00206895,-0.00003228,0.00290978,-0.00455928,-0.00193523,0.001194,-0.00002353,0.00144457,0.0001378

[gixajo]

Una vez hice promedios de Italia separandolos en dos, ahora no me acuerdo de qué muestras utilicé para hacerlo.

A tí te suelen salir bastante representativos esos promedios, posiblemente tengan más éxito que los que haga yo, que los usen si quieren.

Si no me dicen nada, voy haciendo los que puse.

[gixajo]

Una vez hice promedios de Italia separandolos en dos, ahora no me acuerdo de qué muestras utilicé para hacerlo.

Están cerquita , como debe de ser el tuyo y el mío:

Target: Sout_Italian
Distance: 0.2812% / 0.00281245
100.0 South_Italy_Defcon2


Paso a los del Norte, antes me fumaré un cigarrito en la terraza.

Como relaja esto...

[gixajo]

South_Italian,0.10736598,0.14725883,-0.00537531,-0.04065114,0.01536774,-0.01480103,-0.00041355,-0.00131084,0.00544821,0.02098400,0.00147906,0.00318490,-0.00570559,0.00030105,-0.00697726,-0.00277458,0.00198963,-0.00014346,0.00262584,-0.00482755,-0.00234661,0.00195073,0.00064253,0.00137365,0.00009691
NorthEast_Italian,0.12542900,0.14592190,0.03352107,-0.00264457,0.03564947,-0.00060257,0.00285707,0.00234943,0.00940747,0.02095333,-0.00253820,0.00509107,-0.01078937,-0.00234117,-0.00259897,-0.00018743,0.00269963,0.00150253,0.00365313,-0.00328243,-0.00198453,0.00203360,-0.00081240,0.00217507,-0.00182223
Central_Italian,0.11701408,0.14925148,0.00917310,-0.02814708,0.02221933,-0.01003865,0.00044550,-0.00159775,0.00642820,0.02364700,0.00002603,0.00452040,-0.00955638,-0.00467495,-0.00375115,0.00052440,0.00259400,0.00045623,0.00235623,-0.00327855,-0.00208228,0.00226180,-0.00011475,0.00257140,-0.00120693
NorthWest_Italian,0.12070933,0.14655777,0.02910123,-0.00726750,0.03182627,-0.00322107,0.00253410,0.00137310,0.00910150,0.02380610,-0.00491210,0.00471067,-0.01256423,-0.00458970,0.00161273,-0.00296987,-0.00011317,0.00007823,0.00310690,-0.00120490,0.00003520,0.00159713,0.00020753,0.00423140,-0.00031917
Sardinian,0.1216872,0.1672855,0.0284897,-0.0506523,0.060151,-0.0221337,-0.0039523,0.0024964,0.0415743,0.077351,-5.9e-05,0.0166487,-0.0286645,-0.012974,-0.013572,-0.0030013,0.0114027,-0.0013475,0.0016798,-0.0129947,-0.0021212,-0.0011018,-0.010084,-0.021383,0.0003375

I think it´s done.



Edit:added corrected coordinate and changed imeage with the new results.

[Rocinante]

Sout_Italian,0.10736598,0.14725883,-0.00537531,-0.04065114,0.01536774,-0.01480103,-0.00041355,-0.00131084,0.00544821,0.02098400,0.00147906,0.00318490,-0.00570559,0.00030105,-0.00697726,-0.00277458,0.00198963,-0.00014346,0.00262584,-0.00482755,-0.00234661,0.00195073,0.00064253,0.00137365,0.00009691
NorthEast_Italian,0.12542900,0.14592190,0.03352107,-0.00264457,0.03564947,-0.00060257,0.00285707,0.00234943,0.00940747,0.02095333,-0.00253820,0.00509107,-0.01078937,-0.00234117,-0.00259897,-0.00018743,0.00269963,0.00150253,0.00365313,-0.00328243,-0.00198453,0.00203360,-0.00081240,0.00217507,-0.00182223
Central_Italian,0.11701408,0.14925148,0.00917310,-0.02814708,0.02221933,-0.01003865,0.00044550,-0.00159775,0.00642820,0.02364700,0.00002603,0.00452040,-0.00955638,-0.00467495,-0.00375115,0.00052440,0.00259400,0.00045623,0.00235623,-0.00327855,-0.00208228,0.00226180,-0.00011475,0.00257140,-0.00120693
NorthWest_Italian,0.12070933,0.14655777,0.02910123,-0.00726750,0.03182627,-0.00322107,0.00253410,0.00137310,0.00910150,0.02380610,-0.00491210,0.00471067,-0.01256423,-0.00458970,0.00161273,-0.00296987,-0.00011317,0.00007823,0.00184990,-0.00120490,0.00003520,0.00159713,0.00020753,0.00423140,-0.00031917
Sardinian,0.1216872,0.1672855,0.0284897,-0.0506523,0.060151,-0.0221337,-0.0039523,0.0024964,0.0415743,0.077351,-5.9e-05,0.0166487,-0.0286645,-0.012974,-0.013572,-0.0030013,0.0114027,-0.0013475,0.0016798,-0.0129947,-0.0021212,-0.0011018,-0.010084,-0.021383,0.0003375

I think it´s done.

0.03973366 NorthWest_Italian
0.04104727 NorthEast_Italian
0.04930885 Central_Italian
0.06570161 Sout_Italian
0.09738753 Sardinian

Distance: 3.8783% / 0.03878300
43.6 NorthEast_Italian
40.6 NorthWest_Italian
9.2 Sout_Italian
6.6 Sardinian

Interesante.