1


| Thumbs Up/Down |
| Received: 431/0 Given: 618/0 |
G25/nMonte does not recover true ancestral composition. It only finds the best geometric fit of a target in PCA space using the source populations you give it. So if you model French people with ‘Celtic’, ‘Germanic’ and ‘Latin’ proxies, the result is just the best approximation within that reference set, not a biologically real breakdown of French DNA.


| Thumbs Up/Down |
| Received: 431/0 Given: 618/0 |
This model does not work because nMonte is fitting French targets to the available ancient sources as a geometric best fit in PCA space, not recovering their true biological ancestry. A low distance only means the coordinates were approximated well with that source set; it does not validate the historical meaning of the components or make the solution uniquely true.”


| Thumbs Up/Down |
| Received: 5,444/8 Given: 4,578/11 |
“It is said that in his wars in Gaul he slew a million men and enslaved another million.”
— Plutarch, Parallel Lives (Life of Caesar)
Since the invasion of Gaul by Julius Caesar, France has undergone continuous and significant population changes driven by warfare, migrations, and long-term demographic shifts.
There are currently 10 users browsing this thread. (1 members and 9 guests)
Bookmarks