0


Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 455/1,474 Given: 315/2 |
It isnt non existant AFAIK . I2a1b does exist among North Slavs , in some more than othets. It's high frequency in South Slavs has been explained to possibly be a bottleneck or founder effect. It's a coincidence that South Slavs aren't majority R1a basically.
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 775/25 Given: 763/70 |
First of all, Aromanians are part of the Greek ethnogenesis and very patriotic. Not my fault her Romanian dad got stuck on the wrong side of the border after the dissolution of the Ottoman Empire.
Secondly, my Anatolian grandad crushed your little Slavic ancestor uprisings a couple of times. So to the victor go the spoils.
Lastly, I am not offended by my Near East admixture you OWD clown, I am proud of it. Now fuck off, like a good little boy that you are. You can still hope for a pity handjob, white knight loser.
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 455/1,474 Given: 315/2 |
The Iranian origin of Proto Serbs isn't a fantasy but a very plausible theory IMO. They made their way from the Caucasus as Indo Iranians and into central Europe where they got Slavicized and from there into the Balkans. Very plausible theory and possibly true.
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 8,204/1,115 Given: 5,689/520 |
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 5,646/170 Given: 40/24 |
Have you ever heard for Nabsky Srbove (Serbs)? They are Serbian leftovers in Czechia after 7th century assimilatted by Czechs in late middle age.
Descendant of Nabsky Srbove https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tereza_Srbova
Serbs arrived to Iran from Europe (Podunavlje) 17:24 - 22:00 (about origin of Serbian name since 20:40) https://youtu.be/gIDzpUm5Q_U?t=1044
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 3,759/90 Given: 722/122 |
Exactly what I thought, Germanic and Celtic.
![]()
Last edited by Gründig; 04-08-2019 at 04:16 PM.
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 11,114/213 Given: 10,109/550 |
If the majority of Sorbs/Serbs moved south in the 5th century, who's to say they didn't bring I-PH908 with them and create a founder effect in the Balkans? I-PH908 is equally non existent in the Belorussian triangle where it supposedly originates, it's something like 1%, with the rest of I2a being clades under Din-North.
The remaining Sorbs could easily of mixed with the R1a majority Slavs that surrounded them. Issue here is you're assuming the Sorbs of 2019 are identical to the Sorbs over 1500 years ago, and there's no evidence for this. Sorbs started speaking German by the 17th century, and most stopped speaking slavic by the 19th, but they're somehow representative of Proto Serbs 1500 years ago? Not to mention the centuries they spent under Polish rule, Bohemia, the mixing they undertook with Czechs.
I don't believe I-PH908 is "proto Serb" like Pribislav does, but this is a dishonest argument until we find White Serb samples from 500AD.
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 2,546/15 Given: 1,644/0 |
Ancient populations
Avar + Kievan Rus (2.983)
Kievan Rus (4.11)
Scythian + Kievan Rus (4.911)
Avar (7.199)
Scythian (8.543)
Archaeogenetic matches
1. Kievan Rus (1130 AD) (4.11)
2. [Hidden] - upgrade your account (7.199)
3. Avar (590 AD) (8.361)
4. [Hidden] - upgrade your account (8.543)
5. Scythian Ukraine (600 BC) (11.26)
6. [Hidden] - upgrade your account (11.43)
7. Western Pommerania Unetice (2000 BC) (12.52)
8. [Hidden] - upgrade your account (12.52)
9. Medieval Czech Brandysek (710 AD) (15.58)
10. [Hidden] - upgrade your account (16.28)
11. [Hidden] - upgrade your account (17.73)
12. [Hidden] - upgrade your account (18.35)
13. [Hidden] - upgrade your account (18.36)
14. [Hidden] - upgrade your account (18.39)
15. [Hidden] - upgrade your account (18.39)
16. [Hidden] - upgrade your account (18.59)
17. [Hidden] - upgrade your account (19.39)
18. [Hidden] - upgrade your account (20.4)
19. [Hidden] - upgrade your account (20.55)
20. [Hidden] - upgrade your account (20.59)
Modern populations (the same with Eurogenes K15 oracle)
1. Polish (3.578)
2. Ukrainian (4.380)
3. South_Polish (4.381)
4. Russian_Smolensk (4.704)
5. [Hidden] - upgrade your account
6. [Hidden] - upgrade your account
7. [Hidden] - upgrade your account
8. [Hidden] - upgrade your account
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 15,693/315 Given: 8,913/358 |
Thumbs Up/Down |
Received: 15,693/315 Given: 8,913/358 |
So they have only one sample from medieval Russia? Nah, I won't bother uploading my data onto there.
There are currently 2 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 2 guests)
Bookmarks